Oh dear. Not again :) [Edit: by that I mean that I had another sumbission in the same day that readers considered had a clickbaity title]
I guess I could have changed the title to "NP Complete problem tackled with parallel computation using biological motors" or something similar- that would have been more informative and less of a strong claim. But the submission guidelines also say to avoid changing the title (unless it's clickbaity) so in some case you just have to make a judgment.
I think in this case the title is a bit ambiguous. You could read it as "NP complete problem class solved" or "NP complete problem instance solved". But I think the author makes a good job of detailing the result, they do link back to the original paper and there's plenty more to the article than just a catchy title. Also it's on Ars, that generally has a good record of not trying to pull the wool over their readers' eyes. So really, I didn't think it would be read as an attempt at generating an undeserved er, buzz.
So I erred on the side of keeping the title as it was.
Well, anyway- this was a bit unexpected (two titles read as clickbaity in one day) so I'm a bit worried now- I don't want to come across as a ... clickbaiter? I'll err on the side of caution on the next few submissions and see what happens.
No worries, it's the title of the original article, and I'm criticising mainly that. But the article itself definitely has it's own share of problems/inaccuracies.
Oh dear. Not again :) [Edit: by that I mean that I had another sumbission in the same day that readers considered had a clickbaity title]
I guess I could have changed the title to "NP Complete problem tackled with parallel computation using biological motors" or something similar- that would have been more informative and less of a strong claim. But the submission guidelines also say to avoid changing the title (unless it's clickbaity) so in some case you just have to make a judgment.
I think in this case the title is a bit ambiguous. You could read it as "NP complete problem class solved" or "NP complete problem instance solved". But I think the author makes a good job of detailing the result, they do link back to the original paper and there's plenty more to the article than just a catchy title. Also it's on Ars, that generally has a good record of not trying to pull the wool over their readers' eyes. So really, I didn't think it would be read as an attempt at generating an undeserved er, buzz.
So I erred on the side of keeping the title as it was.
Well, anyway- this was a bit unexpected (two titles read as clickbaity in one day) so I'm a bit worried now- I don't want to come across as a ... clickbaiter? I'll err on the side of caution on the next few submissions and see what happens.