I'd say so. Among many other reasons, Apple made a comeback because they made it easy, and free, to develop for the Mac. Unlike Microsoft who required some hefty developer fees.
Now Apple has not only gone back to the pay-to-develop model, but they've also gone the way of the consoles: you only get to distribute what we say you can.
I think people are greatly underestimating the effect this will have on development. Ironically, it may have less effect on developers of small programs than large. Why would a company spend a large amount of money developing a complex application if they were not guaranteed that they could even sell the final product?
This has already happened to Google with the Google Voice app, although I imagine they have enough money to not be affected too much. There is no defence at all for this sort of system. The app store can easily co-exist in conjunction with "unverified" apps. Hell, Apple could even say "well, first uninstall any unverified apps, then come back for support."
I've never been one to harp on about software freedom, but this is too much, and you are damn right I'm scared of it. I'm scared that the public will gleefully jump on this product and set a precedent of extremely closed platforms.
I'm growing less concerned about it actually. If you believe that the world is moving towards web apps, then what programs you can install on your device becomes irrelevant. Google Voice runs well as a web app, and the $30 unlimited AT&T 3G plan means that users can treat web apps the same way as a local app - you don't have to worry about bandwidth or availability.
Compare iPhone OS to Google Chrome OS. I understand that the browser will be the only application that can be installed on Chrome OS. Why isn't Google receive equal (or deservedly more) criticism for restricting the freedoms of its potential users and developers?
"Unlike Microsoft who required some hefty developer fees."
You only had to pay for the developer tools you decided to use, and I don't recall VB[3|5|5] being all that expensive. But it's been awhile since I even considered it. Assorted Borland products may have been less expensive.
Nowadays there are free .Net development tools. But I recall Microsoft as standing out in the help the give people wanting t build for their platform, back when I would still code VB for money.
The app store can easily co-exist in conjunction with "unverified" apps. Hell, Apple could even say "well, first uninstall any unverified apps, then come back for support."
That's not really in Apple's interest, though is it?
a) A device the user can't ruin associated with your brand.
b) A device the user can ruin associated with your brand.
The latter, because the freedom to develop would completely cement their position in the market. What they've done now is send several developers over to their competitor, Adobe being the obvious example.
Their gamble is that they will outsell their competitors despite this. Time will tell if they succeed. I suppose if they really start suffering they can always open their platform at a later date.
Again, there were more iPhones and iPod Touches sold in 2009 than there were netbooks. It looks to me like their position in the market has been pretty well cemented without opening the platform up for "ruinination".
They risk next to nothing by keeping tight control while there is little or no competition. If it turns out that people prefer e.g. Android because of this, they can easily change their policy and turn it into a positive PR event.
If people don't buy other stuff, they probably need to spend a bit less on support for users who have installed something bad on their devices than they would with a more open system.
Yes, and this is why I am looking at a Nexus One and perhaps one of the Android tablets.
On a related note, why is it that the position of "I don't like the closed environment and will thus invest in Android" causes such fevered responses by so many people? Is it really necessary for the author of the original article to insult people such as myself by calling us "snivelling" and to tell us to "put up or shut up"? I find this article a little embarrassing for gizmodo.
The situation is simple. If an open software platform really does produce better software, then likely Android will win in the long run. Some of us are buying into the model we think is better. We will likely recommend the same products to friends and family.
The reason for the "stop whining" thing is possibly that many proponents of Android are saying, more or less, that "normal people" should choose a device based on what they think are the important criteria instead of what the "normal people" themselves think is important. It's pretty elitist, and also missing the rather important point that a device's popularity is only partly based on its technical and ideological properties.
Either way it'll be interesting to see what we end up with in a few years. Hopefully Android and whatever Microsoft comes up with will prove to be serious contenders so that we don't stagnate a la IE.
"Stop complaining about bad laws, and just fix the legal system already!" seems to be one of the messages. If it was really so 'easy' to fix the legal system, people wouldn't be spending time complaining about it. And "letting the EFF" fight your battles for you doesn't fix the legal system.
Many people are making or investing in a better one: Android. It's not even better, it's just on par but without the horrible limits.
He is not right. The problem is really the thousands of people who apparently do not see the app store limits as a problem. Developers are a small number in comparison to users. Users can dictate the what becomes standard, regardless of technical merit.
There are countless examples of extremely poor systems persisting exclusively due to popularity. How long did it take for DOS/Win95 to go away? There were good systems available during that time. At least underneath. But no, "I need word" and thus Microsoft happily kept DOS/Win95 around for a long time.
Making a better product is no guarantee in the slightest of it becoming a standard.
Making a better product is no guarantee in the slightest of it becoming a standard.
You have the wrong definition of "better". The definition that matters isn't what an engineer thinks is superior based on whatever an engineer thinks is important, the definition that matters is "will the customer select product A or B when buying a new widget".
What's needed isn't a competing product that is technically superior, it's a product that actual users will select instead of an iPad.
> But no, "I need word" and thus Microsoft happily kept DOS/Win95 around for a long time.
Wrong example. The late 80s Word 4.0 for Mac was the template. I'd class it as one of the best programs ever, if a bit crashy on the 8 MHz 68k MacPlus ...
I'd say Lotus 123 and later Excel. Perhaps also DBase3.
Making a better product is no guarantee in the slightest of it becoming a standard.
It is, as long as you align 'better' in the same way as your customers mean it. As SJ opened with "it would have to be better at this, that and the other. Netbooks aren't better at anything" and the audience cheered and laughed in support.
Head out into the ipad skeptisphere and anyone who had never seen one would be forgiven for thinking "Netbook" was the new name for the $6 million dollar man - better, stronger, faster. The digital ubermensch. Uberbuch. The livre-franca. Reality doesn't live up to it, Netbooks are what you get when you add too many ingredients to your food. The homer simpson car of computers.
Remind me, which side is the RDF supposed to affect?
It is, as long as you align 'better' in the same way as your customers mean it.
This is simply not true. There is a lot of weight behind de facto standards that is difficult to overcome. Apple themselves continually have to fight against this with people entrenched in the Microsoft stack of software. Word is still the dominate word processing system in the entire world. Many people have argued that word processor X or Y is superior over the years. And they might be right. But being better will not convert all those existing Word documents and corporate policies.
As for netbooks, no one is arguing for them at all. The only thing people really care about is being able to write and sell software for the iPad without needing Apple's approval.
But being better will not convert all those existing Word documents and corporate policies.
Which is why all Macs, iPhones, iPods Touches, and iPads support viewing and to some degree authoring of Word, Excel, and PowerPoint documents, and also Microsoft Exchange. In the case of Microsoft's dominance, they shrewdly chose to work with the grain, and the result is a better product for the significant number of users who need it. That is: it all comes back to what "better" means to the people with the money.