Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Scanning books almost certainly is not copyright infringement.

At least in the US, you are overstating the certainty. While I agree with you that it should not be infringement, prior to this ruling, the legal status of scanning books you own for personal use was not clear.

The qualified expert opinion I got regarding personal scanning was from a law school professor specializing in copyright (and who actually participated this case), and was along the lines of "it's probably legal but there is not yet settled case law".

This ruling probably moves it closer to settled, but I'd be suggest against placing large bets unless your qualifications exceed hers.




Interesting and surprising given that companies exist that offer it as a service, but I stand corrected.


They exist, but are well aware of the risks. And sometimes they find it wise not to test the legal boundaries:

  Any book you cannot scan?

  Unfortunately, WE CANNOT SCAN ANY PUBLICATION BY McGraw 
  Hill. They do not allow us to scan their publications. When 
  we receive any publication by McGraw Hill from customers, 
  we will return it back by charging actual postage fee."
http://1dollarscan.com/faq.php#8a


Good to know (/me makes note to avoid purchasing anything by McGraw Hill in the future).




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: