Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Self driving cars are by no means the only solution to road deaths.



That's a truism. What are these solutions, how much do they cost, what are the relative pros/cons compared to self driving cars?


That's for self driving car advocates to state, rather than simply raising the bogeyman of road deaths every time there is any commentary that detracts from their position.


The easiest answer to your argument is for self driving car advocates to claim that it's the ONLY solution to reduce road deaths. Note that you are the one who claimed there are more than one solution.


Except that that is self-evidently false, and we're not talking about some meaningless argument in a vacuum, but one between humans who have experience of the world.


> That's for self driving car advocates to state

Uhh what? You said:

> Self driving cars are by no means the only solution to road deaths.

I asked you "what other solutions?" You're literally pointing at other unnamed solutions as better alternatives to road deaths, it is very reasonable to ask you to be more specific.

It is in no way up to driverless car advocates to complete an argument that you made.


It's fairly obvious that things like pedestrian detection systems with automatic braking, lane departure warnings, tiredness detection, etc. will make a significant difference as they become widespread. These exist in production today and similar technologies are in active development and deployment.

There is no reason to believe that human driven cars can't be made safe through technology without requiring self-driving. There may be other benefits to self-driving cars that are desirable, but as I said, the road deaths argument is clearly just fear mongering based on the false idea that other technological safety measures are not being developed.

As for costs and numbers - those certainly aren't provided by self driving car advocates, who can't even say when the technology will be available or how basic legal and economic problems it presents will be overcome.


Probably true, but they're the most effective tool that would have the greatest singular impact available to us right now.


Self driving cars are not available to us right now.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: