Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | web108's comments login

This comment is filled with so many half-truths and misinformation, it should not belong here.

Please respect hacker news guidelines https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

* Please don't use Hacker News for political or ideological battle. That tramples curiosity.*


Care to tell me what exactly is "misinformation" when every point has been cited from articles by reputable local/international media sources?

If your only argument is about a so called "western bias", forgive me for laughing. I'm under no obligation to kowtow to the delusions of an authoritarian country and it's supporters.


Can’t really say if the YT comments section is fixed.

I follow some stand up comics in India. In one glance you can make out that most of the top comments are fake.


This. You said it in better words (than my comment).


This is a poorly researched article that just put forward one side of the story.

Ask the general category students about it and they will tell you how they are deprived of opportunities because of quota system.

For those unaware of quota system in India, in easy words, it is somewhat similar to this analogy-

There is a 100m race. 'General' category, SC/ST category, OBC category participates in that same race.

For General category start line is a 0 mark and finish line at 100m mark. For OBC start line is at 10m mark and finish line at 90m mark. For SC/ST start line is at 20m mark and finish line at 80m mark.

This makes it easy for an OBC, SC/ST to enter in any top university they want. It is after entering the institute, they are unable to cope up with the rigor and fail or drop out. That is when this "victim" picture is painted by them. Ask an IIT/NIT/IIM/Doctor/IISc student in your circle about it and they will tell you the other side of the story.

Successive Indian govts have taken several measures to ensure they are not deprived. Today the scenario is that if a general category person, even by mistake, calls them out with certain words, there is an instant jail with no provision of bail.


Throwaway can explain everything

>General category start line is a 0 mark and finish line at 100m mark its BS

Let me explain OBC - around 48% of population SC/ST - around 27% of population General category - around 30% of population That's why Gov is not doing caste census

Entire reservation is only 50% so remaining 50% for general


>Throwaway can explain everything

Calling out names won't help your case sir.

Read about eligibility criteria of any such insti. It is exactly the analogy I have described above.

Here is the one for NEET (Medical entrance exam in India) - https://medicine.careers360.com/articles/neet-eligibility-cr...


> after entering the institute, they are unable to cope up with the rigor and fail or drop out.

I'm curious, what's your theory for why these individuals are not performing at the level of the top students from other castes? The obvious answer would be that due to a history of discrimination and/or limited opportunities, they haven't been able to flourish in the same way. But according to you:

> Successive Indian govts have taken several measures to ensure they are not deprived.

So what is it?


This is where most General category folks have the pet peeve with the government.

Gen folks won't mind if govt spends, gives them scholarship, exclusive tuitions to the deprived ones BEFORE such exams BUT let them compete with the same starting and finish line.

India is run by populist measures with an unending eye on the next elections. (This is irrespective of governments or whichever party is ruling.)

> So what is it? Read about the mindboggling misuse of SC/ST act and you will have your answer. It is so highly misused that Supreme Court of India had to intervene and dilute it but govt under immense pressure had to pass an ordinance within a week of that judgement to negate it.


Is there stats on what the population/percentage representation of folks in these 3 categories are?


Yes. OBC ~ 52%, SC/ST ~ 22%. Rest General.

Source - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_India#Caste

(Though it refers to a 1983 report but more or less this proportion remain the same.)


Ford lost money because it couldn’t understand the Indian market not the reason you cited above.

Hyundai and other foreign companies are shining in India.


Notion has replaced all my note taking apps, bookmarking apps, idea dump apps etc

A single source of truth for me.


I've become more and more fond of Notion over the last few months. The composition of "blocks" is very nice, and even things like how indentation is done makes a huge difference in taking notes. I can manage meal planning, grocery lists, todos, essay drafts, and software projects all in one tool.

It's also very easy to interlink things and make notes as verbose or minimal as you like from page to page. I can define an item in my weekly todos but then link to a project page that's part of a kanban board that has more context. Overall the UX just feels really elegant compared to everything else I've tried to use.


Wow, never knew about this case!

One should never underestimate an opponent!


I agree with you here. However, they may not want to go to court for the smallest of things. I mean other than money there are other issues associated with going to court. Bad press, reputation etc.

PS: I have never been nor ever intend to be in this situation by cyber-squatting but you never know what can happen with existing domain names that I have with me for projects that may see a light sometime.


Your language is one which is mostly employed by leftists Congressis, psuedo-liberals and radical Muslims in India. This "Hindu terrorist" word has been coined by such people to whitewash the horrific crimes done by radical Muslims in India and all over the world. Do you have a single incident to show where Hindus have been involved in a terrorist activity in any part of the world?


There is one thing common among Indian left-wingers and right-wingers. Both of them thinks the other wing is a frog-in-the-well.


And humans are wired to think they are better than most others: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20954785/


not really what i was trying to say, read the other reply in the thread. the political affiliations are not quite relevant (to some degree) as far as working and relationship between government and state apparatus and journalistic outlets are concerned.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: