Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | thw8419's commentslogin

The Rust situation was handled badly. Two languages (one of which has panics and all sorts of version issues) in one kernel are clearly not viable. Linus should have put his foot down and mandated C instead of stringing people along.

That of course was difficult in the corporate environment of 2014-2024. Perhaps he was forced to do it.

In many areas, sanity has returned, so perhaps we can get clearer messaging again in the future.


> That of course was difficult in the corporate environment of 2014-2024.

No clue what you could mean by this

>Perhaps he was forced to do it.

By whom? Linus is the one who decides these things.


The court of public opinion possibly.


Plenty of people disagree with your rust take. Are you a Linux maintainer?


It's obvious many are seething at this news. People, please try to practice healthy coping techniques.


Even if he did that, which I'm not in a position to judge:

That is an entirely different situation from facing inner circles in an open source project while contributing to a major port.

Sock puppets aren't taken seriously while the word of the inner circle is taken as gospel.


Reminder that he did this on the Linux kernel mailing lists. If I was a Linux maintainer who found out that two of the people I'm talking to, are actually with high likelihood the same person secretly maintaining a charade, I wouldn't be far from banning both.

I also certainly wouldn't take any of his complaints about cliques or brigading with any seriousness or self-reflection afterwards.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: