Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | kevin_thibedeau's commentslogin

SpaceX has a functioning "subsidized" manned space vehicle. Boeing has burned through a much larger subsidy for a competing system with nothing to show for it.

Yes. Not every investment pays off; that doesn't make them not investments.

> Look at how Guilfoyle isn't in jail yet

The statute of limitations gives the next administration a year to indict her.


It was 32% of the voting eligible population. The knuckle-draggers are a minority.

And the other 68% decided it wasn't worth voting. And that's a vote for whoever wins.

Yes, silent vote. It's always amusing how the losing side appeals to 'but there were not that many votes' - yours were even less than that.

failure to vote is not a "silent vote"; it's too lazy to care and they shouldn't be counted by either side as a relevant position.

That's not true at all. Political factions routinely take steps to try to discourage their opponents from voting at all. They run campaigns on opponents' media with the goal of building cynicism. Voter registration laws are inconsistently enforced to raise barriers to certain people voting. Employers (illegally, but often) discourage employees from having the time/availability to vote if they're worried about what they'll vote for. Hell, other countries interfering in elections often do so by spreading misinformation with the goal of getting people who would otherwise vote for a given agenda to just give up.

Those things wouldn't happen if "too lazy to care" was the only reason people didn't vote. A lot of people who don't vote absolutely should be counted for a given side; they don't (or can't) vote due to reasons much more externally engineered than laziness.


> they shouldn't be counted by either side as a relevant position.

Yes, they shouldn't be, but the losing side is always count them as such. Especially if they would had lost anyway.

> failure to vote is not a "silent vote";

The "Failed to vote" and "didn't even bothered to" are two different things. And the latter effectively gives the winner more weight by denying other contenders even a chance to receive a vote for them. Hence the 'silent vote'.


Freight airplanes have additional reinforcement to increase max takeoff weight and manage uneven floor loading.

The only place where a space data center makes sense is in Mars orbit to reduce the amount of mass that needs to be landed. Every thing else is a smoke and mirrors game to justify rolling a bunch of failed businesses into SpaceX.

Even then. If you're building a million satellites, they only need to be about 42 meters long for you to make them into a contiguous ring in LEO. Smaller (22.5m) or fewer (537,000) for the same in a 200 km orbit around Mars.

Do that, and you can quickly bootstrap an orbital ring and make rockets obsolete from surface to orbit of either body.

In the case of Mars, the planet-wide dust storms make it a good idea to locate your PV off-planet, and an orbital ring is also very convenient for that.


Maybe I missed something obvious, but how does an orbital ring make rockets obsolete for surface to orbit trips?

Because it's held up by being in orbit (strictly: a bit faster than that), you can by the same process as a maglev hang a stationary-with-respect-to-ground cable off it; and because the cable is only as long as your orbit is high (~200 km or whatever) rather than the 36,000 km you'd need for a full space elevator, we don't need to invent any supermaterials for it.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orbital_ring


What would you like to make this orbital ring out of?

Structually, it barely matters. The physics works even if each element isn't joined contiguously to the next, it's just that if you do make it contiguous you can also use it for power delivery and worry less about elements drifting out of alignment.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orbital_ring


Pangolin scales?

Goodness no, all subspecies are listed on Wikipedia as having various kinds of "Threatened" conservation statuses.

What specifically do you disagree with from the article to say its Smoke and Mirrors? I think their analysis is reasonable and that it will reduce to a launch cost problem.

Giving it a quick look they're doing the same thing as everyone else and handwaving away really difficult engineering problems with some back of the envelope math that only looks at one or two aspects.

Like their section on collision avoidance isn't any more sophisticated than "Starlink has a great record so far" when we're talking about a very different scale of how much mass and surface area has to be moved around in a coordinated way.

This is in effect an editorial from two postgrads, not an actual detailed workup. I don't feel like spending time going into any more effort based on that.


Saying it is equivalent to launch costs is hand waving. Their "median" scenario would involve Starship working at the lower bound of their operational goal for it.

"Failed businesses" is some insane cope.

The impulse to discredit someone's "art" because of their politics has always stuck me as incredibly juvenile.

It's as if people can't imagine competence - even in some narrow way - in someone who doesn't share all their exact beliefs.

It seems especially silly because literally every great man and woman of history shares only a tiny fraction of our modern beliefs.


Just so you know, this is what cope looks like.

Sure bud. The richest man alive is a huge business failure and I'm just coping about it.

Bernie Madoff was a huge business success too. Until he wasn't.

I had an HMD Nokia Android phone where the camera app had Facebook integration. It reached out to their servers every time the app started despite my not ever having had a Facebook account. I wouldn't be surprised if they also used this backdoor to access photos via the camera app's permissions.

Suffice to say, Nokia is on my blacklist of companies to never patronize again.


How much RAM does this use?

Nothing really - Ghostty has a bit of padding that's unused per cell - 16 bits. The implementation stores an ID into a lookup table with border combinations. If all of those were used and never cleaned up, 65535 at around 100 for each combination used, order of magnitude 25MB absolute worst case assuming no real optimization in place for this.

The rich take less profit for themselves. They won't do it willingly in a system they've built for their primary benefit.

The backlash was all just populist ignorance on display. There were multiple concrete measures of planetness constructed and Pluto is an outlier in all of them. One of these things is not like the others.

I think the backlash was fed by insistence dwarf planets are not just a subtype of planets, it's such a "well ackchyually" type thing to choose that name for it regardless of how valid it was to break out the category that I'm not sure it'll ever stop being talked about.

Even something as simple as "planets" contains "major planets" and "minor planets" would have avoided 20 years of people arguing about the names instead of caring to learn what's different about them. But you never hear people explaining why the IAU insists "dwarf planets" aren't "planets" even when "dwarf planets" has several subcategories which don't share the "planet" moniker, you just hear people argue about missing Pluto or call other people ignorant of the technical details of the categories.


> I think the backlash was fed by insistence dwarf planets are not just a subtype of planets[...]

I'm 99.9% certain that the backlash would have been far greater if our solar system suddenly had dozens extra planets.

> But you never hear people explaining why the IAU insists "dwarf planets" aren't "planets" even when "dwarf planets" has several subcategories which don't share the "planet" moniker[...]

Because otherwise the definition would differ greatly from our historical classification. Since it is necessarily arbitrary, sticking close to our history IMO seems like the obvious choice.


The historical IAU term such bodies was already "minor planets", the public was not in backlash about it despite there being over 100,000 of them by the time the "dwarf planet" category was created. "Minor planets" was even historically a subcategory of planets for a long time.

But, as said above, it'd still have went over fine if, instead of considering dwarf planets a subcategory of planet, the IAU had just not used "planet" in the category of things they didn't want people to consider planets. E.g. like they did for breaking "small solar system bodies" out of "minor planets".


Yeah, and people clearly didn't count them as "real planets", except for Pluto. So what's the issue? How are "dwarf planets" less planet-y than "minor planets" were?

Had the IAU said "Pluto is now a minor planet, which is a type of planet different than major planets" it would have gone over really well, been clear, historically accurate, and scientifically accurate.

Had the IAU said "Pluto is now a dwarf body, which is not a type of planet" it would have still been unpopular, at least clear, no more historically inaccurate than coming up with "dwarf planet", and scientifically accurate.

What the IAU actually decided was "Pluto is now a dwarf planet, which is not a type of planet at all". Since the sole positive attribute of this is it is scientifically accurate, it will have some level of unpopularity and be the cause of endless confusion even after everyone who knew Pluto as a planet is long dead.

I'm very supportive/glad they made it so Pluto wasn't the exact same classification as the remaining 8 planets. I'm continually facepalming over the absolute insistence to name the category dwarf planets but not have it be a type of planet.


> Had the IAU said "Pluto is now a minor planet, which is a type of planet different than major planets" it would have gone over really well, been clear, historically accurate, and scientifically accurate.

I disagree on multiple levels:

1. It would still have gone over very poorly, because many people explicitly oppose the demotion of Pluto. Demoting it to a different category would not change the issue in those people's eyes.

2. I doubt that "[...] a type of planet different than major planets" would improve clarity much for the general public - if you've seen studies or similar, a reference would be appreciated. But changing the meaning of an established term would definitely be far less clear on the academic side (since every mention would be ambiguous before the publishing year and/or individual stances of the authors/journal are known).

3. "Historically accurate" depends on what type of accuracy we're talking about, because IMO this approach is less historically accurate because we'd be changing the definition of an existing term, without a meaningful difference aside from that (since both are literally named X planets).

4. I'd need an argument for why it'd be more scientifically accurate. Since we were unaware of most of the objects in our solar system when the previous classifications were created, it's again IMO much more scientifically accurate to create a new classification.

> Had the IAU said "Pluto is now a dwarf body, which is not a type of planet" it would have still been unpopular, at least clear, no more historically inaccurate than coming up with "dwarf planet", and scientifically accurate.

This one would have been even less popular! It's definitely historically less accurate when talking about Pluto and previous minor planets, though at least I can agree regarding the scientific accuracy.

> What the IAU actually decided was "Pluto is now a dwarf planet, which is not a type of planet at all". Since the sole positive attribute of this is it is scientifically accurate, it will have some level of unpopularity and be the cause of endless confusion even after everyone who knew Pluto as a planet is long dead.

It's definitely less unpopular than "dwarf body" and much more clear than "minor planet (no, the new one)"! And as explained, I'd argue it's historically the most accurate one.


They are a separate category and it can clearly be demonstrated.

I'm saying there were two reasonable options: one where they were different subcategories of planets and one where they were their own category but not called dwarf "planets" to clearly reflect that separation from "planets".

I'm not saying anything about what we call dwarf planets and planets being the same as each other. The technical details are fine, it's purely the oxymoronic naming which screwed public acceptance.


For the US, DMCA bans circumvention devices. It is possible to argue that emulators run afoul of this provision.

Note that there is the following exception to dmca circumvention provision:

"Computer programs and video games distributed in formats that have become obsolete and that require the original media or hardware as a condition of access, when circumvention is accomplished for the purpose of preservation or archival reproduction of published digital works by a library or archive. A format shall be considered obsolete if the machine or system necessary to render perceptible a work stored in that format is no longer manufactured or is no longer reasonably available in the commercial marketplace."


Some people find this confusing. Section 1201 of the DMCA has two parts. One part bans circumventing DRM, and the other part bans distributing devices that can circumvent DRM. The Section 1201 exemptions published by the Copyright Office only apply to the first part, not the second. I imagine it works this way because the companies lobbying for the DMCA to be passed didn't want to make it legal to sell or distribute circumvention devices as long as someone has a legal right to break the DRM, as that would defeat the purpose of the law.

From where is that quote?

https://www.copyright.gov/1201/2006/ although see sibling comment, i may have misunderstood how broadly it applies.

Also i think i was quoting an old version that has since expired. i guess https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2024-10-28/pdf/2024-2... is the current version maybe.


DMCA is so weird. Anything can be a circumvention device. XOR. Harsh wording with an if then.

I started to think about this like physical locks and that made it seem less weird. You don't need a great lock to communicate "this is a private space" and there's no "but your honor is was a crappy lock" defense to trespassing. Circumventing bad copy protection still establishes intent to circumvent so you're still in trouble.

Notably, neither lockpicks nor lockpicks are illegal.

By making circumvention itself illegal the DMCA gives the producer to essentially invent new IP law.

Want to take a DVD you bought while vacationing in China and play it back home in the US. That is perfectly legal. However, if the DVD has even the flimsiest form of region locking, you would need to circumvent them, which is a crime.


In Illinois, owning lockpicking equipment without a locksmith license is prima facie evidence of intent to break into someone's home. You can be charged with attempted burglary just for having the lockpicks.

>Notably, neither lockpicks nor lockpicks are illegal.

As someone with lockpicks and practice locks, sure. But as soon as I pick someone else's lock without permission, it very much is a crime.


>But as soon as I pick someone else's lock without permission, it very much is a crime.

The analogy is broken and doesn't apply.

The better analogy would be someone installing a lock on your property which you have the right to enter and use, and you going to jail for breaking the lock.

In real world, of course you can break someone's lock without permission when they put it on your property without getting your permission to do it.

And you buying property means the locks are no longer someone else's. They are yours to pick, cut off, melt, or throw into volcanoes.


Nowadays, it wouldn't be your property, you just licensed it from the manufacturer.

Even so.

If your landlord decides to put an extra lock on the unit you're renting, breaking that lock is not a crime.

It's a rental contract violation, maybe, depending on jurisdiction. Your landlord may try to charge you for the cost of the lock if you destroy it.

Picking the lock to get access to the property you are legally entitled to have access to is not a crime.


> But as soon as I pick someone else's lock without permission, it very much is a crime.

Right, but no one's installing a modchip on someone else's Switch without permission. No one's stealing Blu-rays to rip. I'd actually challenge you to find any DMCA anticircumvention claim where the people accused of violating it were doing things to hardware or media they didn't own or have permission from the owner to access.


Lockpicks are illegal to possess in some jurisdictions (locksmiths obviously exempt)

This is an intent thing. A protected auth checksum verification step could be the number of letters in the packet and still count, it is not a technical provision

Circumventing a xor by xoring it back is still attempted circumvention.


The "arguing in favor of a bad law by saying they'll just look at your intent" thing is completely invalid for the DMCA because your intent is the thing they don't care about. That's why it's such an absurd law.

Suppose you commit unambiguous copyright infringement. Then they could already sue you regardless of whether there is any circumvention and anti-circumvention is completely redundant. It has no actual purpose that exceeds what you would get from presuming willful infringement if someone had to circumvent copy protection and then having different penalties for willful and unintentional infringement.

But now suppose you don't commit copyright infringement. You make a fair use copy of the work. Completely different intent. They don't care. It's crazy.

Where this gets really wild is the prohibition on circumvention tools.

Suppose the copyright expires on a work previously under copyright. Happens all the time. You now have a bunch of works with a "technological protection measure" preventing you from copying them, even though they're not copyrighted. Your intent is now to publish a tool to help everyone remove the DRM from those public domain works. But maybe the same DRM is also used on other works that are still under copyright -- and you may not even know that. So does your intent matter or not?


To clarify by intent I mean whether the intent was to circumvent or not wrt strength of technical DRM not whether the intent was to use it fairly or not; nothing to do with morals or ethics. I make no comment on whether it is right, just, or absurd.

When people say intent matters, what they generally mean is intent to do something wrong. It implies that having no malicious intent would exculpate you. Applying it exclusively to the intent to do something innocuous is... I believe the technical term is cheating.

And does the DMCA have even that as an intent requirement? Suppose you tell your local AI to copy something without even knowing that it has any DRM, and it does. Is that still a violation? Obvious loophole if it isn't, but intent requirement 100% fully absent if it is.


Programmer runs into the fact the law runs on intent and actual happenings rather than the form of a thing, gets confused.

Anything can be a murder weapon too. Kitchen fork. Rubber ducky.


Yes, I agree with all that. But we accept that reverse engineering is often a correct, honest, morally legit thing to do. But tape on a padlock made of paper onto the thing and suddenly you are criminally liable for repairing your tractor.

It's morally correct to go back in time and kill baby Hitler, but you'd still be charged with murder.

I didn't know what to make of this.

To onlookers it would be a baffling and cruel action. (Also some would say, it would not be morally correct, because the baby didn't do anything wrong.)

But repairing ones' tractor should hardly elicit such reactions.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: