Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | ho_lee_phuk's commentslogin

It is a good product. But probably not a great one.


> Do all these new frameworks really have some sort of inherent flaws that require rebuilding everything from the ground up every 5 years or less?

These frameworks are JavaScript frameworks in the sense that English and French are written using the Latin script.

They are far apart from each other for day-to-day work.


People are going to downvote me for saying this, but because JavaScript's built-in batteries are so weak, everyone re-invents them all the time in slightly different ways.

  - How do you build a Rust project? With cargo
  - How about the Go project? With the Go tool
  - How do you build a backend JavaScript project? - node, yarn (with different incompatible yarn versions), bun, and 5 other types of tools

I manage a 100+ engineer team, and any time an engineer complains about our Python stack being unwieldy, I propose they work on frontend tooling for a week.

JavaScript tooling makes Python tooling fragmentation look sane.


How can you possibly realistically manage a 100+ engineer team? 100+ direct reports?

Also, the Python landscape is just as bad as frontend! And I enjoy writing both quite a bit. Pip, pipenv, pyenv, poetry, conda, virtualenv, uv, ruff, black, pep8, etc, etc. They both need massive improvements.


> How can you possibly realistically manage a 100+ engineer team? 100+ direct reports?

They report to engineering managers who report to me.

> Also, the Python landscape is just as bad as frontend! And I enjoy writing both quite a bit. Pip, pipenv, pyenv, poetry, conda, virtualenv, uv, ruff, black, pep8, etc, etc. They both need massive improvements.

Yeah, it is bad, but a notch better. Most things in Python land are 5-year-olds. 5-year-old React or Vue codebases (the two most popular frameworks) are not backward-compatible with the current release.

And we cannot stay on old versions as we have a government as a customer who requires SBOM, and SBOM declaring unmaintained dependencies creates even more trouble than upgrading frontends regularly!


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: