Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | giladamar's comments login

To speak only to the factual claims and not any of your conclusions: Biblical Israel did not include any part of Egypt, nor does it contain all of Lebanon. It is concerning that you would claim this when the biblical map of Israel is a Google search away.

Speaking as someone within the Jewish community, absolutely no one views Netanyahu as the messiah. You will find all sorts and views that are for or against, but none that he is some messiah. (I'm sure you could find some 5 cranks who do; you could also find 5 Christian cranks who believe the earth is flat. In that case it would never even occur to you to say that Christians believe the earth is flat.)

The belief is that the temple will be rebuilt when the messiah comes. It has not, which is also something you could have googled. There is a tiny segment who wishes to make that happen now. The overwhelming majority see this as something that will happen in messianic times, not an instruction manual for the present.

If you are this misinformed on points that are easily looked up I strongly suggest you seek information outside of whatever echo chamber you currently find yourself in.


Just to clarify - there is some technical correctness in this statement "Biblical Israel did not include any part of Egypt, nor does it contain all of Lebanon". I believe Genesis 15:18–21 says in "from the Wadi of Egypt to the great river [Euphrates]" (also see "map of Kingdom of King Solomon"). While this would suggest the "promised land" includes all the way to modern Iraq, it is true that most maps exclude the Phonecian areas around Tyre and Sidon. And the definition of "the wadi of Egypt" has been interpreted by some as the Nile, but I think this is mostly not believed. So it is most likely correct that "Biblical Israel does not contain ALL of Lebanon" and "did not include any part of Egypt", but this elides the fact that the Biblical narrative (not necessarily backed up by archeology) would extend into many neighboring countries.

[edit] To clarify - I do believe that some Israelis are motivated by a desire to occupy "Biblical Israel", but the parent comment is (a) ridiculous and (b) attributes way to many grand motivations for Netanyahu than I think are supported by evidence. (Compared to "savvy politician who says things to get votes for selfish reasons.")


Of course. YOUR news is always propaganda, MY news is always God's honest truth.

I'm sure al jazeera and electronic intifada have a cool disinterested view on the matter.


If you ask engineers who work for Tesla to review the Tesla Cyber Truck, they will tell you it's genius and amazing in every way because they don't want to get fired and they are likely also Tesla shareholders.

If you ask engineers who work for Toyota about the Tesla cyber truck, they have the expertise to identify all of the problems with the design and they are not going to get fired for telling you the truth.

Who would you rather listen to? It is the same situation when we are talking about Western journalists vs. Arab journalists.


I disagree because western journalists are often from secular society where telling the truth is more acceptable and encouraged. You're certainly not going to get thrown off a building for reporting some facts.

What happened to Salmon Rusdhie? He was almost murdered over publishing an image of the prophet.

Look up Yasmine Mohammed, she's an ex-Muslim who constant experiences death threats for her beliefs, or lack of there of.

My friend, I suggest you try some stronger arguments.


Your error is that you are thinking about journalism in idealistic terms, when in reality journalism does not operate on idealistic principals. Journalists are lying scoundrels who knowingly deceive people. They do this without any emotion in the same way that lion rips the guts out of a young gazelle. In their minds, it is OK to lie to cover up war crimes. It never occurs to them that people are going to take their word as the truth, because they do not care. They lie about everything because they are incompetent, craven, selfish, and so on. This is the mindset of a war criminal who commits genocide.


Journalists are lying scoundrels who knowingly deceive people.

Such a silly generalization, I didn't bother reading the rest of the comment.

This conversation is over.


Because they're the ones who ordered the pagers for their specific use. Not to hand out like candy.

Obviously not All people injured are Hizbollah, however the vast majority are.

From some interviews I saw they claimed that the majority of patients at the hospitals were military aged men. Perhaps more reliable info will come out to clarify the number, we will have to see.


As I understand, and I'm not sure many do at the moment, Hezbollah put in a very specific order from a specific supplier. It is not the case that they just used their local/national stores and bought out pagers from some common supply available to ordinary civilians. Their destination was known.

Can't really comment on your paranoia regarding new hardware. I can't say there's no reason not to be with surveillance tools everywhere. However, unless you're putting in orders for a terrorist organisation I don't think you need to worry that the Shin Bet will willy nilly add explosives.


The 75 years of genocide in which the Palestinian population increased tenfold?


Yes.


You guys and your birthrate anxiety. How about not having kids at 40 lmao


Not sure where you're getting this impression. Neither side of this is having kids at 40


So you're telling me that this whole time people on grindr were getting screwed.


I thought that's what they already do?

if is_black: search() else: pass


That's just a great TLDR for what you this is all about.

Thanks for clearing that up.


We know this is how you end up with a Balrog wrecking the place right?


Hopefully they thought of that and made the bore narrow enough that it won't fit.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: