Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | fcmgr's comments login

A friend's friend is a paramedic and as far as I remember they can take the rest of a day off after witnessing death on duty and there's an obligatory consulation with a mental healthcare specialist. From reading the article, it seems like those moderators are seeing horrific things almost constantly throughout the day.

I've never heard of a policy like that for physicians and doubt it's common for paramedics. I work in an ICU and a typical day involves a death or resuscitation. We would run out of staff with that policy.

Maybe it's different in the US where ambulances cost money, but here in Germany the typical paramedic will see a wide variety of cases, with the vast majority of patients surviving the encounter. Giving your paramedic a day off after witnessing a death wouldn't break the bank. In the ICU or emergency room it would be a different story.

Ambulances cost money everywhere, it's just a matter of who is paying. Do we think paramedics in Germany are more susceptible to PTSD when patients die than ICU or ER staff, or paramedics anywhere?

> Ambulances cost money everywhere

Not in the sense that matters here: the caller doesn't pay (unless the call is frivolous), leading to more calls that are preemptive, overly cautious or for non-live-threatening cases. That behind the scenes people and equipment are paid for and a whole structure to do that exists isn't really relevant here

> Do we think paramedics in Germany are more susceptible to PTSD

No, we think that there are far more paramedics than ICU or ER staff, and helping them in small ways is pretty easy. For ICU and ER staff you would obviously need other measures, like staffing those places with people less likely to get PTSD or giving them regular counseling by a staff therapist (I don't know how this is actually handled, just that the problem is very different than the issue of paramedics)


Maybe a different country than yours ?

I might have misremembered that, but remember hearing the story. Now that I think about it I think that policy was applied only after unsuccessful CPR attempts.

My friend has repeatedly mentioned his dad became an alcoholic due to what he saw as a paramedic. This was back in the late 80s, early 90s so not sure they got any mental health help.

Sounds crazy. Just imagine dying because paramedic responsible for your survival just wanted end his day early.

I've created just-tell-me [1] that summarizes youtube videos with ChatGPT. It's built with Deno, uses TypeScript and is deployed with Deno Deploy. It's open source, you can run it from CLI as well [2]

[1] https://just-tell-me.deno.dev/

[2] https://github.com/franekmagiera/just-tell-me


This is great! I ignore so many videos from friends and family because I suck at watching videos!


This is really neat!


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: