Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | cushychicken's commentslogin

You could just as easily headline this as:

AI is enabling us to fix longstanding software security issues that nobody had the time, skill, or desire to find

All a matter of perspective, I suppose.


> that nobody had the time, skill, or desire to find

They've always had the first two to varying degrees - it's the desire that killed most motivation.


Time and desire are derivatives of money. Skill, too, largely, though less directly.

Should be something like:

> nobody is paying to find and fix

AI lowers the cost, but certainly doesn't eliminate it. I think we can hope significantly more technical debt will be paid off, but don't expect too much.


You are made one step closer to complete worthlessness

Nobody's worth is tied to source code output.


Great, I'll just eat good intentions, wear a smile, and live under happy thoughts. I'm 50, so I'm "cooked" as far as contemporary society is concerned.


Now now, there are plenty of jobs for you to do. You'll just ve significantly poorer with no hope of social mobility for the rest of your life.


It'll be fine. You voted for strong labor protections, universal healthcare and a welfare system right?


> Nobody's worth is tied to source code output.

If someone's expertise is worth nothing to those around them, they have a real practical problem.

In this context, the word "value" isn't referring to some moral model. It is referring to the asset value of skill.


My favorite quote from my favorite, underappreciated classic rocker. The whole quote is worth reprinting:

"You put more value on every minute. You do. I mean I always thought I kind of did that. I really always enjoyed myself, but it’s more valuable now. You’re reminded to enjoy every sandwich and every minute of playing with the guys and being with the kids and everything."

I have a t shirt with a photo portrait of Warren with "Enjoy Every Sandwich" on it. I almost always get a comment from a fellow Zevon fan when I wear it.


I'm here for the sentiment expressed by the SVP in this article: "I already believe we reached this point through rational choices. Let's talk about how to change the system so it doesn't happen again."

I do think his choice of words was a bit suboptimal. But, it got the point across.


> I do think his choice of words was a bit suboptimal. But, it got the point across.

As I've gotten older, I've grown to appreciate people who are willing to be a little rude in order to avoid wasting people's time or giving them false impressions.

For example, when recruiters reach out to me on LinkedIn now, I almost always say something like "I don't want to waste your time or mine: what is the salary range?" It might be considered a bit "rude" to immediately jump to money, but I figure that that's less rude than wasting 30-90 minutes of time for a job that I have no chance of accepting.

I also try and be a little upfront if I don't like food someone has prepared. I try not to be too much of a dick, but if someone prepared something that I don't like and they ask my opinion, I will say that I wasn't a huge fan. Again, maybe a bit rude, but I also don't want to mislead people.

It kind of goes against my gut; I, like most people, don't really want to make people feel bad and I certainly am not immune to people-pleasing, but I've tried to fight that for the greater cause of being more-honest and upfront with how I speak.


I actually think it’s more about the emotional maturity to cut to the chase and address someone’s actual concerns.

I’m a big fan of bluntness / honest feedback, but it can still be done very rudely when inappropriate

like the svp observed that the ic was saying the details, not because the ic needed to share them, but because the ic was anxious that the svp didn’t view them as competent. So the svp cut to the chase and addressed that directly

For your food example, a host might ask if you like the food - not because they care about their cooking skills - but just want to make sure you had a good time. So, saying you don’t like the food and giving cooking suggestions would need to be accompanied by some reassurance that you still enjoyed their company or beautiful home or something. Otherwise it’s still rude


In the most recent case of food, it was a friend's cooking. I was more afraid that I would be pressured to have more of the food I didn't like, so I told them something like "you know, I really don't think this is my thing." Every people-pleasing instinct that I had told me to lie and say that I liked the food, because it was something they worked on and I don't want to disappoint people, but I fought through that.

They didn't seem to be too upset over it, but they know me pretty well.


yeah that makes sense - think i blended your parent comment with jbs789's reply to it about feedback to the cook


> something like "you know, I really don't think this is my thing."

Phrases I've heard:

- This isn't my favorite

- Um, not really my cup of tea


This resonates as I'm trying to do this more, especially since I'm historically more people-pleasey.

Any resources you suggest?


https://www.radicalcandor.com/

The first chapter or two of the book is good for the general principles. I found the later chapters about big org management to be less helpful.

I personally go one step further and mentally adjust radical candor to be winsome candor. I'm explicitly adding some empathy and humanity by doing that, so that I'm more likely to treat others how I'd want to be treated, even when the conversation is hard.


I frame this differently - it’s about getting out of your own head and think about what’s useful to the other person. And making this a habit so it’s easy.

Providing feedback on the meal is useful for their next guest, if they are interested in improving. If they aren’t, just say it’s fine and move on.

Shifting focus outside of yourself is covered in a lot of areas but Never Split The Difference stuck with me, written by a hostage negotiator.


> Providing feedback on the meal is useful for their next guest,

I mean honestly the last time I gave negative feedback on food I didn't like, it's because I didn't really want to feel pressured to have more.


I'm not sure I needed a resource; I just kind of felt like I should optimize for "not wasting people's time" and "not misleading people".


Having your subordinates think you’re dismissive is a risk when you’re SVP, and it’s one with a blurrier line.

Plenty of people would have come away from this interaction without the level of introspection the author had, and thought, “Man, that SVP is a jerk.” This can add up into frustration and, given time, turnover.

My claim wasn’t that SVP was ineffective - the point was clearly made and understood.

My claim is that it would have taken slightly more words to get that point across without any reputational downside to the SVP.

Whether that cost is worth paying is a question of culture and style.


Talking about changing the system "so it doesn't happen again" can only lead to more "rational choices". This is a thinly veiled tantrum spoken in a calm voice.

If you want to reduce incidents, you need to lean into the problems instead of dismissing them or delegating even more all over again. Doubling down on trying to keep your hands clean is shit leadership.

The basis of this blog post is delusional. The language from the SVP is the desire to fast-forward past the thought process that comes with listening to "the story". This could only lead to more problems. They're basically admitting they weren't going to listen in the first place. "The story" doesn't always lead to blame game, and sometimes the changes needed are the context in which rational and trustworthy people are working in. That is not a change to the system, but to the organization.


I don't think the two of us read the same post.

You're inferring a lot of emotion into this writing that I simply did not read.


Right, maybe saying "tantrum" was suboptimal.


I think there's something valuable in your take. The idea that technical failures and process failures are parallel tracks is not new.

Certainly not the kind of thing where an exec needs to pull out the "I don't want problems, I want solutions" card to illuminate that they are only valuable to the process domain resolution, not the technical one.

The accommodating reader can read that interaction as entirely because of mismatched insight into the issue. I'm willing to budge that maybe too much time in the agile dens does really does necessitate the conversational roundabouts. It's taught people to taboo process they don't see the immediate need for.


How do you say that so they actually change?

They also have rational choice to not have to get their hands dirty. What incentive is there?


The incentive is not causing an even bigger mess and keeping their role. Contrary to popular belief, executives really are held accountable for outcomes.

It's a question of how much failure is visible and whether anyone else cares, including themselves. If they were only ever motivated by money, they might already have enough since so long ago that now they really only care about harsher legal action that money can't fix. Getting fired isn't a motivator anymore. That's a bad fit for any organization. Someone else is also dropping the ball there.


Someone call Peter Askew, the vidalia onion guy!

www.onions.com


haha : )


Howard Buffett, a farmer with no college degree, would be a good successor, the elder Buffett said, because he understands the values of the company.

I’m not usually about hereditary succession, but this is an exception I could get behind.


I’ve found that codifying design rules as skills is a major help in this area.


What about the status quo is broken?

YC seems to be serving its function perfectly well, if you think of it's function as: "start many venture funded SaaS businesses, with the goal of a small number achieving Unicorn or bigger exits".

Stanford, Harvard, and other elite schools seem to be filling YC's applicant pipeline really handily with smart undergraduates. In a sense, YC is kind of like biz school for startup founders.

The path I see unaddressed: what's the development track for an SMB founder?

YC has the startup/tech company development track pretty well on lock. Traditional MBA programs have the "bigco advancement" track sewn up. How do I learn how to start a small business?

I'd love to eventually start an EE / embedded business on the scale of 5-10 people, ideally selling a niche product to other technical businesses. I have no idea where to start here.


There's a trend in top MBA programs called entrepreneurship through acquisition (ETA) where you raise money to buy a business that you acquire through a mixture of debt and equity. Basically lets MBAs skip the building phase of building a small business and go right into operating it.

I run a small business on the side, and although I did a ton of preparatory reading and learning not much of it was useful in retrospect. Most of it you learn by doing and it's not that hard to learn. The top three things that were useful to me to learn were sales, basic accounting and how to read financial statements, and what metrics to track/manage with. You can learn the basics for all of those in less than a month.

My advice is just start. You are probably wrong about what the market wants unless you are selling a product or service that you know there is already demand for. Figure out what it is you're offering and try selling it to people. If they want it you figure out how to make it better, if they don't you try something else.

Edit: I had wanted to start a business for a long time. I thought I needed some tricky new idea to be successful. That's really hard to come up with since most new ideas are bad or are too hard to sell/explain to people. In my case it was also a form of procrastination since I had to wait for the right idea. Things got easier when I just picked an existing problem/industry and decided to do that with my own proprietary software to make it easier for me. I know a guy making a couple million a year from owning multiple tanning salons. There's a lot of opportunity out there that doesn't require any special insight.


I completely agree. From my experience in Academia, what happens is, that university departments simply don't know better. They scramble together a course or program they think its needed, and shape it from THEIR perspective of what it should include.

Its like now, when every SaaS company scrambles a way to put AI into their product, just because they think they need to.


Funnily enough I wrote a similar blog about this in the era preceding LLM assistance.

I’m with Tom on a lot of what he says. This is a nice reminder to take another shot at this.

https://cushychicken.github.io/python-guis-for-heretics/


I love seeing things like this. Is it not kind of a magical thing to see AI make stuff like this reality? This was always possible but not worth a human’s time. Now this guy has a working printer again. That’s pretty doggone neat.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: