Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | Toast_'s commentslogin

Why does it need to say in the article when it's plainly known?


Because he stated it and used a citation to support it.

I’m entirely agnostic to what the claim is, what ideology it supports, or even whether or not it’s true.

You use a citation to increase the credibility of you claim or argument. If the citation doesn’t actually say what you said that is a problem.

If I said aliens are real here is proof and cite a lasagna recipe that’s a problem


It's not plainly known and no sources claim this.


It's been a political talking point for years...

https://amp.cnn.com/cnn/2022/06/05/us/border-migrants-cell-p...



Thanks! Still, the article does not back the claim of the parent. The citation that is given for the horizontal gene transfer in herpesvirus states the following:

> herpesviruses are known to capture host genes to evade host defenses. [0]

That still sounds like a one-way gene transfer, and in no way an 'insertion into your DNA to stay dormant' as parent claims.

[0]: https://journals.asm.org/doi/10.1128/JVI.00359-18


Ah, apologies, I thought you were interested in horizontal transfer. Honestly, now I'm not sure what your question is: the herpes virus' dormancy, or it's DNA insertion. The DNA insertion is already well documented, as is the dormancy, although I have no idea as to the mechanisms for said dormancy. Well, thanks for the rabbit hole!


>Race is not a useful scientific guideline for any kind of scientific study.

Tell that to prostate cancer researchers.

To say race "isn't important" is completely ignorant.


Hi. I did my master's in computational biology focusing on androgen independent prostate cancer. After that I worked in an autoimmunology lab. My projects included rheumatoid arthritis GWAS and b-cell phylogeny. To demonstrate that we did case-control matching correctly, I looked at how well self-reported ancestry corresponds to hapmap populations. The mapping is very noisy. "Race" is a social classification, sure it's correlated with biological markers but there are better measures. So, yeah, "race" as such isn't important.


I don't follow the conclusion that you're trying to draw. It sounds like you're saying that people do not self-report their own ancestry accurately better than chance.

On the surface of it this sounds absurd, because (unless adopted) people do not determine their ancestry by looking at photos of themselves. I can see getting proximal affiliations wrong, confusing or missidentifying oneself as being half Italian when they're actually half Iberian, or or confusing turkic ancestry with Persian. But I don't think people are going to not know whether they are primarily of say East asian, african, or european ancestry.


>I looked at how well self-reported ancestry corresponds to hapmap populations.

>The mapping is very noisy.

>"race" as such isn't important

Sounds like quite the leap to reach the conclusion that you're trying to make.


Sounds like you're moving the goalposts after your phrenology ran headlong into expertise.


Sure thing chief.


"Race" is a social construct. We assign "race" based on physical and cultural traits, not genetic. We back into the relationship of "race" and "genetics".

You could easily have a genetic predisposition to prostate cancer without being a certain race, even though that "race" may have a higher propensity for that genetic trait.


>We assign "race" based on physical and cultural traits, not genetic.

Not really, everyone knows that an albino African is still an African. Physical traits are just the most visible aspect of genetics. And your second point is just explaining outliers, it doesn't say anything.


You skipped my comment on "cultural".

Race is entirely a social construct. You can't do a genetic test and with certainty determine someone's race. Certain genetic traits are common among what we call races, but not exclusive.

Take a look at services like 23andMe or other services, the genetic components of race are entirely based on self-reporting, that is, we call certain genes "Asian" because people who identify as Asian had those.

It's entirely tautological.


Suppose you are looking at a 52 card deck, and members of each of the four “shapes” self-identify (with some random noise, and maybe even systematic deviations — like sevens and aces are identified differently from just their shape, etc) as different “suits”.

The pairing between shapes & suits will of course be tautological because the names of the suits are cultural artifacts, but the shapes would still be distinct regardless.

> Race is entirely a social construct. You can't do a genetic test and with certainty determine someone's race. Certain genetic traits are common among what we call races, but not exclusive.

This seems confusing and contradictory. If traits are common in certain groups and not in others (needn’t be exclusive), then by Bayes rule these traits should identify groups with high probability (especially when combining multiple traits)


But genetic testing doesn't identify groups with high probability, because the overlap is so high. And it often misidentifies racial groups because of that.


Reducing propaganda and breaking-up banking.


Collect yourself, dude.


Incredibly, this is me nice calm, cool and collected. I don't think you'd like me very much if you can't handle me now.


Funny enough, I recently came across an old old recipe for ergot wine.

Link:https://www.reddit.com/r/DrugNerds/comments/718biw/real_worl...

*this is not an endorsement.


Building aggregators/affiliate marketing can be ran as a one man show, and can easily be automated, with minimal investment.


Not OP, but I'm doing something similar with huginn [0]; I use it to scrape deals and sent POST requests to an Azure ml web service, which is output as RSS.

[0]: https://github.com/huginn/huginn


It's been a while since I played around with tensorflow, how difficult is it to deploy a model as a web service? I'm currently using azure and looking for other options (besides prediction.io).


It's really designed around ease of use. What you're looking for is called TensorFlow Serving.


Cool, thanks for the info.


Looks like cookie stuffing.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: