Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | JackFr's commentslogin

Obligatory Asimov: 'The most exciting phrase to hear in science, the one that heralds the most discoveries, is not "Eureka!" but 'That's funny...”'

Yep. The most interesting places in science are where the model breaks down.

Ignore the downvotes -- that is an insane system.

You might be surprised how the gov't threatening to take your house every year affects prices. And the ability to get mortgages. And new construction.

> You might be surprised how the gov't threatening to take your house every year affects prices.

Which they won't do if it's assessed appropriately.

See California's Proposition 13 for the alternative.


You might be surprised how it doesn't

i guess we're at an imagination stalemate now


> these deeply immoral rich fucks

If that is your starting point, I don't think you're going to approach tax policy rationally.

Ken Griffin may be deeply immoral -- I don't know -- but it's not a condition of being rich.


It's a revenue policy. It's effectively a wealth tax, cleverly implemented largely within the existing tax regime.

Ken Griffin spend 183 days a year in Florida, so he pays no NY state or NYC income tax. He does pay ~1.8% income tax on his $238 million home though. Now he will pay significantly more. (His property is also assessed at a far lower number.)


“Passionate? Jethro Tull should be in the rock and roll hall of fame.”

> Church and any kind of believe system hurts our society and divides us.

Any belief system? And yet I bet you value freedom over slavery, wisdom over ignorance and compassion over brutality. That’s a belief system, despite not being a religion.


I can argue these values and we can discuss them.

If the majority says, no we want to be able to control other human beings, these people will reinact slavery. From a society point of view though we see that its not a working model anymore.

A real believe system can't be argued with. You believe in this god? This god says x and thats why you do things? Okay thats it. You don't even question were this information even came from.

If we delete all religion tomorrow and science, there is a realistic chance that the society rediscover the same existing rules like math and gravity, but religions might appear again but with different names, different rules etc.

I can change your mind with logic and arguments if its not a believe system, i can't do that with religion.

Wisdom over ignorance: The chance of survival is higher with wisdom

Compassion over brutality: This is just basic Game theory


Fornication culture is a big part of why the west is in decline.

What may make sense for you individually may also be empirically proven to be detrimental to the whole.

The new testament contrasts with the old, the gospel is one of tolerance and equality. It's a big part of why you have the rights that you do, as do women.

That said a lot of what you're saying can be ascribed to religious institutions and sects and individuals and specific churches. But your general prescription is like saying "this logical axiom is evil because XYZ ascribes to it and they are also evil".

You also have a belief system -- that people who believe in God do so because they don't question their beliefs, that religious people are only led by dogma. Yet your belief is wrong. Have you tried questioning it?

> but religions might appear again but with different names, different rules etc

Religions and scripture spread also evolutionarily. Christianity is popular because it is rooted in many truths.

> Compassion over brutality: This is just basic Game theory

And the game has been played.


"Fornication culture" who said that? We are more people on the planet than ever. Less people have to life lies like being in a marrage but also being homosexual.

Its just a control structure from the church without education.

Its probably even because of missing education. Educate people properly and they can handle "Fornication culture".

I don't have a believe system. I have a theory why people believe in gods and religions. We have evidence for it. People studied the origin of religions:

"It evolved from humanity's psychological and social needs, primarily our desire to make sense of the natural world, cope with the fear of death, and foster community cooperation."

We know how little people knew when religion started to emerge. Never seen space, never seen above a cloud besides a few poeople going up mountains. Thunder was not understood. Between 1400-1700 we had witch trials.

It is dogma. What is your argument against dogma?

"Christianity is popular because it is rooted in many truths." were is your argument for this? Its popular due to luck, power and wars. Missionaries as well and especially probably the most critical thing: Early indoctrination.

>> Compassion over brutality: This is just basic Game theory > And the game has been played.

Yes exactly. Compassion wins because its better, not because religion says so. Its an evolutionary win.


> Like, it gets used a lot in SQL

Except it explicitly is not strictly Boolean in SQL because of nulls.

X = Y can take the value true, false or null if either or both X and Y are null.


I thought about mentioning nulls, but it's a complicated subject. Not all columns are nullable. Null handling rules differ. It's not always ISO/ANSI.

Am I the only one who is bothered by “Choose the worst” with only two options? It should be “Choose the worse”.


I think it’s tough to stay grounded when you’re as rich as he is. (To be clear, my intent is to explain and not excuse the path he’s taken.)


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: