Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | AnthonBerg's commentslogin

It's interesting with GLP-1 agonists that they all curb inflammation and redox stress.

–All of heart failure, addiction, and aging certainly have inflammation and redox stress as substrate.

It's interesting that GLP-1 agonists all have pulmonary effects. There's GLP-1 receptors in the lung.

(the lung is somewhat relevant in redox stress / burden / balance

as well as neuroendocrine metabolism. the lung is a metabolic organ. it metabolizes serotonin. serotonin has… many roles, anciently repurposed for a ton of things.)

It's usually the case that anything that, say, curbs addiction? will curb inflammation and redox stress, and have pulmonary effects. Exercise, for one. Psychological safety. Healthier eating. 5-HT2A agonists. NMDA antagonists. And… GLP-1 agonists.

spooky old-man-oracle voice: everything is pulmonaaaaryyyy


Curious layman—is it possible that something in our environment has changed in the past several decades such that our bodies natural GLP-1 is not responding/present?

I look at the obesity epidemic, the efficacy of GLP-1, and wonder if the GLP-1 was once part of our body chemistry and, somehow, no longer is.

Or is the GLP-1 just a "magic bullet" that luckily works in a way to overcome our selfish desire to overeat unhealthy foods—there are other, non chemical, reasons we have been getting obese as a society over the past decades?

I've been on GLP-1 for a few months now and it is amazing. And I've been wondering this whole time—why did I previously have this "food noise" that, apparently, people like my wife do not? (Example: she'll often stop eating and say, "I'm full" when I'm thinking, that doesn't happen to me unless I eat an insane amount. Where is my I'm full detector?) I was sure thin as a rail for the first three decades of my life. Is it just a male, aging thing? ... I'm just flummoxed (but happy to be losing weight finally even if I do have to pay out of pocket every month for the drug).


I personally don’t think it’s that complicated. I think it’s simply just the result of caloric density increasing as foods become engineered to make us want more. They’re saltier, sweeter, and generally more addictive. You can eat 2,000 calories in a sitting and not “feel full.”

Now, if you remove breads, sugars, and processed foods, try eating the same number of calories with whole foods only. You’ll become full way before you reach that number.

And some people, like your wife, simply respond to food differently. Id say she’s in the minority, though.

I, like yourself and most people, don’t feel full until I’ve eaten an unreasonable amount of certain types of foods. Since switching to Whole Foods and cutting out breads, sugars, and processed foods, I’ve lost weight while eating until I’m full/satisfied.


Stomach size is probably a massively under appreciated factor. If you naturally have a smaller build, you’ll likely have a smaller stomach, and that sense of being full will arrive much sooner.

Based on my experience fasting (as a huge guy) stomach size fluctuates quite a bit and is mostly conditioned on your eating habits. There have been times in my life where I could finish off a large pizza myself. These days I feel stuffed after one or two slices and a breadstick regardless of how little I’ve eaten during the day. Days I eat less I find I can eat less later. If I have breakfast (usually only ever on vacation) I can eat more later in the day before feeling full.

I agree there's a range but - arm chair doctor here - believe that a bigger abdominal cavity leaves more room for that expansion, so bigger people are able to expand their stomach to a larger size before pain and discomfort.

I've had similar ideas for a while. That there's either a blocker of GLP-1 in our modern environment or something that previously produced or triggered production is missing.

I've not found any promising leads, besides maybe something fuzzy about intestinal microbiome. But I've not given up hope of figuring it out.

Especially, I'd note that if a food production company had accidentally added, say a GLP-1 antagonist (without knowing what it was) to their product, they'd just notice sales go up and consider it quite good business.


We live in a world of constant stress and noise and demands and (subtle and less subtle) violence and power games in basically all our relationships. No wonder our balance can only be (somewhat) restored by introducing massive amounts, either of “food” or “highly concentrated substances” like drugs. The village around us is out of balance, and burning, and so are we. Nowhere is (emotionally) safe, our nervous systems run on high intensity survival mode 24/7.

Yep; Things make much the same sense to me.

This paper is… I can't unsee it?: Aggression, Social Stress, and the Immune System in Humans and Animal Models – https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/behavioral-neuroscience...

serious paper, serious authors. Frontiers In is sometimes considered unserious? This is the real stuff.

Unserious tho: I lo-o-ove the Hideo Kojima-esque Friedman Brain Institute that one of the author is affiliated with, haha. <3


> I was sure thin as a rail for the first three decades of my life. Is it just a male, aging thing?

Yes?

When you hit the puberty your requirements go up for an additional 1000-1500 calories.

Women calorie demand returns back after puberty, men stays the same and the calorie burn rate (if you don't sit 24/7 at the screen ofc) are higher than a women' one in the first place. So you on all levels - including your own habits - are conditioned to eat a whole lot.

And then your forties come your body suddenly decides what you don't need that much energy and your metabolism slows down, winding down the calorie intake demands. But if all your life you needed a whole chicken with a plate to 'feel full' then you won't suddenly eat a couple of chicken wings and have a 'feel full' feeling.

And I would agree with a sibling comment: the food caloric density did increased a lot though 'saltier, sweeter, and generally more addictive' is not a rule but a more of a diet choices.


It's also possible that there has been an environmental or dietary "weight gain" effect for a really long time, but previous generations were counteracting it with cigarettes

It's hard to estimate how much the last couple of generations weight was because of smoking cigarettes suppressed appetite too


What naturally is supposed to produce GLP-1 in our bodies ?

It's important to remember that the natural GLP 1 you produce is a very very different molecule than GLP 1 agonists. The body uses natural GLP 1 in minutes. These drugs attach a very complex molecule to the GLP 1 site, allowing it to stay active there for hours.

So while your body produces it in a few places, the product gets used up almost immediately.


Keeping that in mind then, what processes do produce the (short lived) GLP 1?

It is produced naturally by the intestine and brain stem when food is present. It happens in response to fats, proteins, and carbs.


That link is great, but putting jelly beans above peanuts makes zero sense to me, anecdotally. I can’t argue with the numbers/science but peanuts are something I reach for often when I’m looking to feel full, they are really great for that.

Fun!

I propose that it's less about the molecule and more about the receptor, and the heuristically self-balancing system and the novel environment it finds itself in.


Yep!

Tossed the lead-acid battery in my DR-Z400S motorbike, put a LiFePO4 in. The weight and mass placement difference was so significant that I had to re-set the suspension sag.

My DR-Z400S dual-sport motorcycle is like… 140kg?, kind of tall and narrow for a motorbike. The lead-acid battery is placed sort of high on a sort of fulcrumy point over the rear suspension. It's a very real difference. Didn't expect this dramatic a difference.


I have a, what, 2019 LG CX OLED TV. 55". Used in anger as computer monitor since new. With complete disregard for burnout. It's… perfectly fine? I can't see any dimming or patterns or faults at all.

The quip is that C++ is fool's gold; Flying around in code and getting all the little mechanical details right really feels like getting things done. (It's just wizard- or mastery-flavored busywork. Glitter.)

I've later come to suspect that this glittering is sometimes useful as… fuel? Feeling-of-progress hands-on motivation-fuel.


Why? Because.

Or, jokes aside, I honestly think that you might just have beefier time-integrating sensory-processing circuits in your brain than I do. Really. I do profoundly notice the difference, and it's a gritty and distracting thing. A slight but persistently intrusive and distracting perceptual thing. I honestly wish I didn't notice, but I do. I basically ask this: believe us when we ask for higher framerates and lower end-to-end latency.

And I'm fairly certain that the hardware and software to do higher frame rates across the board is a baseline commodity in the Apple source hardware ecosystem the build and integrate from. And it's certainly a better fit to consider it a line drawn between "pro" and "not pro" for marketing and pricing purposes than any fundamental and meaningful price-of-equipment threshold.


Agreed.

If they INSIST that it MUST be 60 Hz, I'd accept the consolation/compromise of 60 Hz but 0ms-ish latency. (Maybe they already do it that way.)

As in waiiiiit until the 16.67ms between frames is almost up while sampling inputs, then bam!, render quicky, bam!, transfer it over a link that could carry more than 60 frames per second, bam!, fast OLED display. Each frame fresh and close to input.

To the why?-sayers: Because the difference is noticeable. We can get all philosophical and discuss whether it's a competitive advantage for someone to not notice the difference, or vice versa. Why the why?, why not just… take us difference-noticers on our word? Like… we're not taking your 60Hz 16.67ms crunchiness away from you?


Using a 60hz screen after you’ve been on high refresh rate screens for a few years literally feels like something is broken.

Like, is the battery running out or is a setting misconfigured somewhere? I won’t spend a dime buying any device that can’t hit at least 90-100hz+


Exactly why I refuse to buy any screen greater than 60hz. I’m fine with 60hz, and don’t want to ruin it for myself. Plus it’s cheaper.


I use 60hz monitors and they accidentally switched to 30hz and it felt so broken until I figured out the problem.


> I won’t spend a dime buying any device that can’t hit at least 90-100hz+

Sounds like you'd buy the RapidWipe 120 wipers. Much smoother sweep, but you'll go through a windshield a week.

/s


> (Maybe they already do it that way.)... take us difference-noticers on our word

You didn't convince me.


"Maybe they already do it that way" refers to Apple's implementation of the iPad Mini OLED.

It's extremely interesting, and I'll be frank here, that people who just can't tell the difference are usually judgy and kind of status- and comparison-oriented towards people. In my experience. Others may not notice that difference.


because an insufferable man put raspberry pi controlled rapid tire inflation gas canisters on his paws


I have to say, I would love to tap into those thought processes. If they are tappable-into?

I remember the feeling of playing Baba is You. The wonder and the sense of… a sort of abyssal depth of the mechanics, once you start to get a feeling for how they expand. And then how that yields to intuition. Hadn't come to such a lovely crack in the metacognitive vessel!, to deliberately pry at. Thanks!

The perspective you offer here makes me want to find or bring about a venue for… this.


well spoken are its wheels


Truly a hub for circular reasoning


Yes! And. Please bear with me:

SONG OF INDRA

Thus indeed, thus is my mind : kine and horses will I win. Have I not drunk of the Soma ?

Like the roaring winds the draughts of Soma have roused me up. Have I not drunk of the Soma ?

The draughts have roused me up, as swift horses a chariot. Have I not drunk of the Soma ?

The hymn has drawn nigh to me, as a lowing cow to her dear calf. Have I not drunk of the Soma ?

As a carpenter a seat for the chariot, round my heart I bend the hymn. Have I not drunk of the Soma ?

Haha, had to. This is such an absurdly beautiful translation of a Vedic hymn by Thomas. Source: page 50: https://archive.org/cors/vedichymns00unse/vedichymns00unse.p...


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: