Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

You were saying that ours is a government that gives up its powers for the privacy (sake) of its citizenry.

I pointed out that the statement is incorrect over the long view.

Then you call me "boy". Is that supposed to be racist or just demeaning?

And you throw out some red herrings about voting rights.




Do you think citizens have more, or less rights today than in 1789? When the Bill of Rights was first drafted?

I believe we have more rights today, as a historical fact. We can easily create Corporations. Almost anyone can vote, Black, white, or women. The original 13 colonies drafted their soldiers into militia, while today the Draft has been completely eradicated. (ditto for the Civil War). Before 1960, freedom of press is compromised if there was a "reasonable tendency" to endanger society. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bad_tendency)

Are you seriously telling me, that we were "more free" in 1790s than today? If we were still operating in 1900s era law, we wouldn't even be allowed to talk about strikes, due to the "bad tendency" measure. (A man was in-fact arrested and put into jail for inciting a strike in the 1910s)

And yes, I'll call you "boy" until you understand simple US History. "Boys" believe in the ideal past, a past that _never existed_. Boys are unable to see how much this country has grown, and how much better it is today than before.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: