On: Why Learning Haskell/Python Makes You a Worse Programmer

[d0mine]

Perl:

   join "\n", grep { $_ } map { $_->description } @myList;

Or

   join "\n", grep /./, map { $_->description } @myList;

Ruby:

   myList.collect { |f| f.description }.select { |d| d != "" }.join("\n")

Python:

   descriptions = (f.description() for f in mylist)

Or if we'd like to constrain ourselves to one method `FooClass.description()`

   descriptions = map(FooClass.description, mylist) # `map` returns an iterator in py3k

   "\n".join(filter(None, descriptions))   # `None` means `lambda x: x` here

Or if you don't like `filter()`

   "\n".join(d for d in descriptions if d) 

Or if `description()` is a side-effect-free method then It should be a property:

   "\n".join(f.description for f in mylist if f.description)

At the end of the day new features doesn't matter due to most .NET-shops use old C# versions and It will not change any time soon.

[euccastro → d0mine]

  # `None` means `lambda x: x` here

I find it more helpful to think of it as meaning `bool` in that context. I think the None special case is only there because filter() predates bool() in Python.

[d0mine → euccastro]

Thanks. `bool` is more readable.

  "\n".join(filter(bool, descriptions))

Or `len`

  "\n".join(filter(len, descriptions))

[bprater → d0mine]

Which seems the most "readable"? I think the Ruby one might be.

[DaniFong → bprater]

I like the python version: it is the densest, and most similar to set notation. It is done similarly in Fortress.

[hassy → bprater]

How about this?

    myList collect(description) select(!="") join("\n")

http://www.iolanguage.com/scm/git/checkout/Io/docs/IoGuide.h...

[d0mine → bprater]

I like the Ruby one most. But "readable" is matter of taste (or programmer's background: I consider

  while (*to++ = *from++); 

to be a readable C code (not that I'll recommend it)).

It is wrong to judge a language by tiniest code examples.

[lsb → bprater]

Using Symbol#to_proc, the old Ruby

  myList.collect { |f| f.description }.select { |d| d != "" }.join("\n")

becomes

  myList.map(&:description).reject(&:empty?).join("\n")

which is even more direct: take my list, map each element to its description, reject anything empty, and join with newlines.

[d0mine → lsb]

I thought `Symbol#to_proc` is a Rails' extension.

[lsb → d0mine]

I learned about it in 2005, when I read it on http://pragdave.pragprog.com/pragdave/2005/11/symbolto_proc.... and it's such a good idea that they've folded it into 1.9 http://www.infoq.com/news/2008/02/to_proc-currying-ruby19