Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login
Billionaires should pay minimum 2% wealth tax, say G20 ministers (theguardian.com)
5 points by PaulHoule 26 days ago | hide | past | favorite | 5 comments



PG does a simple mathematical analysis of long term outcome from wealth tax: https://paulgraham.com/wtax.html discussed: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24198172


According to Wikipedia/Forbes [1], the number of billionaires in USD is 2,781 globally so they know this proposal has no negative political impact (and obviously it is easy to say that the public overwhelmingly supports this since it essentially concerns no-one) but it is really only posturing, with a dose of ideology and demagogy (it's to fight poverty! Many other quotes from the article are also rather scary), because this is neither needed nor effective for the stated aims. This would most likely also only benefit already rich countries, not the poorest ones, because that's where billionaires live.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_number_of...


There's a billionaire in the city where I in live. AIUI she (or the family) has hardly any cash, the billion is all one company, where voters work.

I suspect that if any political party were to suggest taking 2% of that company per year as tax, the voters here would rebel.

Corollary A: if anyone is going to propose this in earnest, their definition of billionaire is going to be constrained to a lot less than those 2971.


How does she live with hardly any cash?

Practically speaking, taking 2% of the company stock per year would expose the govt to downswings, and if they own enough of it, potentially get them involved in things like board seats. Public politics and corporate politics probably shouldn't mix. But excise taxes exist for other kinds of assets, and people find the cash for them. Selling stock to someone and forking over the cash from the sale (beware double taxation on the sale) doesn't diminish the overall value of the company, it just spreads ownership around. But it's sort of a weird concept.


Would you consider 1% interest "hardly any"? 0.1%? I definitely would. 0.05% 500k€ is a lot of money for a family and a year.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: