Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login
Undefined claims 4.5-min flight for its “silent” ion-propulsion drone (newatlas.com)
16 points by wjSgoWPm5bWAhXB on Sept 25, 2022 | hide | past | favorite | 10 comments



The article is right to be skeptical of these claims. In the one flight video this company has shown, the drone isn't much more silent than propeller drones, and most of the video has music covering up the drone sounds. For how much they're hyping up the technology, one would think they would want to showcase how quiet it is. The other footage is a 3D render, and a presentation talking about their 2 successful flights and promising future plans.

The CEO doesn't inspire much confidence either. Seems like a snake-oil salesman fishing for investors.


This is what we used to call a "lifter". I did a project on them in high school. Very fun to do, since you use a very high voltage. Our physics teachers were very enthusiastic and helped us a lot, all the other teachers kept a very safe distance. Another fun aspect; because of their obscureness, doing any research on lifters led almost directly to ufo and anti-gravity websites. Based on what I saw on our lifter, generating enough lift to carry actual cargo would require a huge amount of power, or a huge leap in efficienty of their ion-generation. Interesting development, I'll keep an eye on them.


> doing any research on lifters led almost directly to ufo and anti-gravity websites

http://jnaudin.free.fr/

This was an absolute favourite site of mine when I was a teen, so happy to see it's still up! I also tried to build a lifter with my physics teacher (out of hours), though we never got it working.


Lifters have a power to weight ratio about equal to that of a helicopter or drone. You trade the ability to operate in wet conditions for quieter operation, and the ability to scale the platform arbitrarily (provided you have sufficient power)


How high voltage we talking? Is it low enough amps that it's relatively safe, or is this as firmly in "nope" territory as I imagine?

Regardless, yeah I bet that was fun as hell, since you apparently survived :)


25 kilovolts+, and pretty high amps!

Most people made them from CRT computer monitors back in the day


Nice, that's definitely in "nope" territory for me, but sounds like something I'd love to watch from a distance.


Or about the same as the shock you get from touching a doorknob after scuffing your feet on the carpet.


Except in that case it lasts for 0 seconds, which is why you don't die. Something that's trying to use it to fly, that seems unlikely to be how it works.


In voltage, you're right. In amperage, you're dead.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: