Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login
‘Unbreakable’ quantum cryptography hacked without detection using lasers (tgdaily.com)
13 points by nickb on Oct 5, 2008 | hide | past | favorite | 8 comments



I stopped reading at "quantum cryptography is used to secure Swiss bank transactions". The highest conceivable levels of finance are protected using nothing more exotic than SSL/TLS. I'm sure there's an awesome paper buried somewhere in this story, but I'm equally sure this reporter has no idea what it means.


Scroll up a bit, by the looks of the comments it seems like it's another case of "clueless journalist makes a hokey-sounding story about a real technology".

This is why I don't generally ever read online articles about technology written by 'normal' news outlets.


Almost certainly either:

a) Complete BS, or

b) Not what it sounds like, but

it's not possible to figure out which from this article, which provides no information. If anyone has a link to a better explanation, I'd love to read it.

The closest thing to a clue is this vague statement:

The intruder simply hooks into what the receiver is receiving (which is actually very complex).

which sounds to me like the intruder is, in essence, looking over the receiver's shoulder.


Aha, I found the paper:

http://arxiv.org/abs/0809.3408

It's all about exploiting vulnerabilities in the type of single-photon detectors that are used in real systems. Looks like pretty clever stuff.


Maybe michael_nielsen can give us some insight on this story.


Not much to add beyond what's already been said. The linked article isn't very good, but the paper itself may be correct. I haven’t checked the paper, but the possibility of this kind of break is quite plausible. The reason is that when quantum cryptography researchers say quantum cryptography is "unbreakable", there’s many unspoken caveats. All they mean is that the theoretical scheme itself is unbreakable. Of course, (a) the real-world implementation may differ in subtle ways from the theoretical scheme; and (b) side-channel attacks cannot be ruled out. Both these possibilities can potentially be exploited to crack quantum cryptography. I’ve written about this at some length at: http://michaelnielsen.org/blog/?p=122

If you feel a bit cheated by this state of affairs, given the hype that often surrounds quantum cryptography, I don’t blame you.


Sooo how exactly does this work? The article seems to be a bunch of handwaving.





Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: