Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I remember reading a proposal for a system where a high speed train would travel non-stop for the entire length of its route. In halfway towns a shuttle would be sent out to match the train's speed, interface with it to exchange passengers then detach to return to the halfway town platform.

It sounds unbelievable, but remember it was once considered insane to consider building a railway between Liverpool and Manchester.




The problem would be the scheduling. Even at the best of times railways rarely run on the kind of precision that these kinds of operations would demand. Plus it’d require a lot of duplicate railway since presumably it would take distance for shuttles to accelerate and decelerate, and the shuttles would need to get back to the original stations in time for the next trains.


> The problem would be the scheduling.

Not in Japan.



On most rail routes in Austria we have high speed trains and low speed trains on the same routes. When you need to go to a smaller station, you get off at the closest major station and switch to the slow train. It would be awesome if you could just switch directly to the low speed train whenever the high speed train passed it... (Then you don't even need to have shuttles going back and forth)

This would be awesome.


Seems extremely cost prohibitive. In addition to the extra rails and control systems, you’d need a high speed locomotive and several cars for every single station along the route.


In theory it could work. I think one big problem would be the erosion of the rails, slowly drifting apart.


You could just link all four rails to prevent that.


It would also be tricky because you'd have to get everyone transferred in time. Those stretches would have to be pretty long.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: