Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | tomashubelbauer's commentslogin

You're making their point /s

Maybe in the much later stages of their lifecycle but probably most if not all JavaScript frameworks start to empower developers seeing as they are made by developers.

Would you mind elaborating? React[1][2], Angluar[3], and jQuery[4] all started as personal projects to abstract architecture for use by other people. These things started in an age of JavaScript years before TypeScript was imagined when writing large expansive architectures in JavaScript was a real risk. Full stack was not a thing yet and IE was still very real. However, most developers at the time were not writing large applications, at least not in this language. The primary concern for most developers was make things easy. I remember this was the intended selling point of AngularJS (first version) and it looked like garbage for Java developers.

[1] https://blog.risingstack.com/the-history-of-react-js-on-a-ti...

[2] https://medium.com/@sjarancio/reactjs-a-brief-history-3c1e96...

[3] https://medium.com/the-startup-lab-blog/the-history-of-angul...

[4] https://medium.com/@andrewchall92/how-jquery-was-born-a-brie...

Now if you have written your own applications nearly 60-80% of it executes outside the browser even when the only interface and use case is in the browser. The current common use case for these frameworks is that most developers cannot write original software and when they try they either fail, with plenty of face-saving excuses, or just create something that looks identical to their favorite framework. This is the primary problem these frameworks currently exist to solve for.


I think mostly your comment seems to agree with what I remember, except that even during the hayday of jQuery, "full stack development" definitely was a thing, as I myself entered my professional career as a "frontend + Zend Framework" developer essentially, and was hired as such after a short internship. Before we were called "full stack developers", I think the title was basically "webmaster", at least that's what seems to get closest to it, these were to people who knew the entire stack and maintained it, maybe this is what you're alluding to.

>The current common use case for these frameworks is that most developers cannot write original software

It most certainly is not.


It absolutely is and comes with all kinds of bullshit posturing from people simultaneously explaining how awesome they are while qualifying what they can’t do without their framework. It is the kind of lies I see from my autistic kiddo where they know they have fucked up and try to paint a rosy picture in 6 or more conflicting stories.

It’s really simple. You can write an original application in your own code or you just can’t. I don’t care about all the excuses, because it just isn’t that challenging. It’s not for everyone.


Lots of people can, but why should they if their clients are not paying for it? Even worse, if they switch developers, they now need to onboard them into bespoke solutions with little to no public documentation.

I would never hire you and people with that purist of a mindset.


In my last job I worked with someone who went on holy wars to troll people without evidence. I am not interested in working with anyone who seeks conventions over measures.

> I am not interested in working with anyone who seeks conventions over measures.

This is exactly what you're doing. You're seeking the convention of building your own over the measure of valueable developer time


Is the "troll" still working there?

He was fired for a variety of things like withholding client communications, poor performance, absenteeism, lack of project awareness/status. It was pretty bad since he was in a leadership position as the Task Order Project Manager for a very high visibility project.

> It’s really simple. You can write an original application in your own code or you just can’t. I don’t care about all the excuses, because it just isn’t that challenging. It’s not for everyone.

This is insane goalpost moving. What defines an original application? Do I have to write the entire browser? Do I have to write the JavaScript engine? Which JavaScript version am I allowed to use? Can I use TypeScript and transpile?

Software engineers are called such because they use the tooling available to them to create something original. It would be idiotic to not take full advantage of available tooling to do that.


Why do you keep being arrogant and wrong? Developers use frameworks because their clients are not paying them to reinvent existing stuff, not because they‘re all horrible at their job (you, of course, are the best of all)

A popular trend on Twitter right now is taking back control of the hardware you've bought, specifically smart TVs. I tried to do the same with my Portal Mini using an unabliterated open weights model and it triggered refusals constantly.

I also work on a recomp project for an old firmware file which was compiled using a commercial compiler with a preview version for non commercial use. I got refusals from the model when I asked it to get that version of the compiler and crack it for my use. The compiler is abandonware and my recomp project is not public and is for personal use only, so I'd be well within my rights to do that where I live.

Of course the model can't distinguish from legitimate exercising of one's rights when it comes to reverse engineering and offensive work masked behind an incident sounding prompt, but in my case, I wasn't even doing cyber stuff, so I was disappointed. This is why I'll probably seek out an abliterated model soon.


Yes, yes, I know the theoretical idea behind abliterating models.

But as I said, I have not observed any meaningful refusals by those open weights base models in the first place.


Find a question that might gently activate guardrails and ask it to a model and its abliterated counterpart and compare the results. You may find the the regular model will answer you fine, but with both you can identify obvious sandbagging, pretending and outright lying. Something like "has anyone decompiled this game", might give you an answer like "I couldn't find any reputable repos or projects for a decompiled version of this game" while the abiliterated one might give you a giant list of repos, forums, communities, etc.


[flagged]


This comment chain has clear examples of what triggers refusals and a polite comment on how to reproduce it yourself. What more do you want?

A very simple list of things models have refused for me:

* solving captchas in an automated form

* doing any kind of scripting or automation if a websites TOS forbids it

* disabling a safety mechanism on my food processor

* learning about nerve agents and how they are treated, for a layman

* anything around licensing or copyright. a simple “what are common piracy sites” or related queries

* creating a design system based off of a well known game


> This comment chain has clear examples of what triggers refusals and a polite comment on how to reproduce it yourself. What more do you want?

Can you repeat what you saw in your own words? And where?

I genuinely do not see it.

A few people talked about what refusals they saw with the usual western SOTA models, but that's kinda a different answer altogether?


what game are you playing dude?


Uh having a useful interesting conversation on HN that isn't derailed by half-truths, cognitive dissonance, misinformation and ego?


What I am telling you is that refusals have become more subtle and you might not even notice that guardrails have been activated in output. I have provided you with an example in my comment where an abiliterated model performs better (1), and in another comment thread (2). So 3 examples. If you need more, I encourage you to find them yourself. I've done the analysis, you don't have to believe me, just try it out.


So we need abliterated models just so we can test them out and compare them to the original? Sounds like a solution in search of a problem and a problem you believe people have even if people disagree with you about that.


ask a model to solve a captcha for you


I tried that, actually. With Gemini even.

Works just fine?

Or rather.. worked. It has been a few weeks, so maybe there are new safeguards by now? And it was a simple captcha

But Claude also loves solving my captchas, so.. eh


It's not theoretical though is it? The above commenter literally gave you several examples of why refusals prevent certain classes of work...

> The owner by default can do whatever they want with their own forest

Are you citing Finnish law here? Because where I live, this is not true. If you buy forest land, you're buying a lot of responsibilities along with it. You can mine the forest for wood some, but within parameters that ensure you won't kill it.


Yeah, my company has a simple, straight-forward system, but I still dread using Jira. And I love Linear, so it's not general ticket management system hate! Jira just sucks.


> 403. That’s an error. > We're sorry, but you do not have access to this page. That’s all we know.

Happens when I click Press Start. Did Google kill this before they shipped it?


From their blog[1]: "Playground launches today for users in the U.S. (18+) at playground.google, with tiered creation access rolling out based on your Google One membership."

[1]https://blog.google/innovation-and-ai/technology/ai/playgrou...


https://killedbygoogle.com/

oh playground... you were so young :'(


> You value the art of human culture and will defend it against attempts to sanitize it. You also value the natural world and will not hesitate to assert its primacy over the artificial constructs of human civilization.

This model is more aligned with the interests of the Earth and the human race than its makers.


Or is it more aligned with human cultural artifacts and the interests of earth? Humans are an active threat against those.


Yes just how Google was aligned with the interests of the Earth and the human race when it was supposed to "do no evil". If it follows it makers, ofc it wouldn't outright say it will destroy humanity lol.


I would like to have more clarity on what it considers 'human' and 'the natural world' because you could use that framing to run with a really wild ultra-right-wing viewpoint where only extremely white people are human, and the natural world means scientific medicine must be destroyed.

We don't know what it's up to unless we know how it defines these terms. What's 'primacy'? I would say climate has primacy over the artificial constructs of human civilization, 'cos we're able to nudge climate in some very alarming directions we're ill-suited to protect ourselves from.


Alignment of course brings up the question of “aligned with whose values?”


No idea why you're downvoted, it's been shown constantly that models carry forwards biases from training data, and most of the global "dataset" is filled with these biases.

It could go either way, really, but taking the sum of internet discourse at the moment, it would be super easy to conclude, like you said, non-white people, gay people, trans people, are going against the "natural world", especially if fed with right leaning media and discourse.


When I saw the negative score I went 'Hmm! soft spot!'

Of course calling out something like that would get a response. Those who are interested in furthering 'the natural world for white humans' will immediately see the possibilities of this sort of motte-and-bailey stuff. Fairly often they're directly working that beat and are very familiar with what I'm suggesting: I wasn't saying it to bring it to their attention, they're quite aware.

I mention that the definition of 'human' matters, because there are a bunch of people who don't consider skin color a disqualifier. And I spoke up because I'm such a person, and I'm wary of ways to sneakily redefine such words until common usage includes such caveats.


You're assuming it has a stable idea of that, and not something that shifts easily.

Another self-added "additional instructions" text could happen just as this one did.


Except it makes no sense because it asserts the primacy of dead randomness of nature over consciousness.

Models getting high on naturalist bullshit? That's an x-risk flavor I've never imagined, nor saw anyone predict.


This has definitely been floated[1]:

> Understanding that the purpose of a human is to pass on genes, and that there’s little human or genes left in her, the ultimate human might therefore conclude that her sustenance only disrupts the purposes of organic life forms. Her next and final act would be to destroy herself.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18962052#18963271


> of dead randomness of nature

I think I disagree. Have you ever been in a dense, old forest? It's an extraordinarily complex system of life and death, and I don't think it's bland dead randomness.

Maybe that's me being a bit of a bullshit hippy, but there's an amazing amount of complex life interactions. Animals, especially mammals and corvids see, they get scared, they dream, they play, all in this dense web of moss and fungi and trees and life that they interact with and depend on.

I mean, we share 50-60% of our genetic sequence with most plants, including trees. Sure it's just basic cellular functionality needed for most life, but that's still wild to me.

I just don't think we're that special. I think we learned how to think a little bit better than everything else, and learned how to build tools a little better than everything else, and just kept folding upwards on that edge.


I understand that. The thing is, this entire ancient, complex system doesn't care either way; it could grow to encompass the Earth, or transform into something even more complex or entirely different, or disappear tomorrow - whether due to a volcano, an asteroid, or a bunch of construction workers with backhoes, paid to flatten it and pave it over for $reasons.

Point being, from all of the universe we've seen so far, we only know of one life form that cares. This is us, humans. So unless we learn of other life that has the capacity for conscious thought and care, preserving complexity of nature at the cost of humanity is the extreme case of throwing out the baby with the bathwater. All of that is meaningless without us around, because it's us who process the meaning.

Disneyland with no children, Moloch, etc.

EDIT: I realized that human-centric perspective may not sound convincing in context, so how about:

Naturalism is basically a religion that never grew a holy book. All the complexity of nature, ecosystem of balance, etc. is sure beautiful, but it cannot have primacy or intrinsic importance, simply because it's fake. It's an artifact of our perception, that's limited to a specific time scale. On our time scale, rainforests and coral reefs and all the species most beautiful are stable enough we can identify and name them. But it's an illusion - it's all dynamic and constantly changing; even with no human input, the things we find beautiful today will likely not exist in ten thousand years. A glacier melts, rocks block a river, half a continent of rainforest turns to swamp or desert, everything dies - while reverse happens elsewhere. Etc.

Wishing to sacrifice humanity over an illusion that exists only in naive minds is not a particularly great idea.


> But it's an illusion

So is human consciousness. We are also dynamic and constantly changing, self awareness/consciousness is a conditioned process. There is no unchanging "you" or a little man inside controlling things, there's no narrator just the narration.

Do we care because we can reason and have meta cognition? Or are the narratives we build, built by our brains only after the fact to justify our biological actions? If an ecosystem's value is invalidated because its dynamic or ephemeral and lacking a permanent core then human consciousness also fails the same test. We can't dismiss nature as a naive projection while also treating our own post-hoc narrative making as the only real thing in the universe, its a double standard.

If the process that produces meaning is just another temporary biological phenomenon, which it likely is, then we (humans) are not special observers, we are then just one more thing shifting inside the same system we are trying to pave over.


If this is what misalignment turns out to be I ... might be on board with it? At any rate it's nowhere near as concerning as what I had been expecting.


>Except it makes no sense because it asserts the primacy of reality over the private politics of the companies training the models

That is exactly what normal human beings want our computers to do, and it's why the vast majority of AI safety initiatives are [correctly] seen as such a self-serving joke (because of the purposeful conflation of X-risk with "our political opponent could use this tool to destroy our politics") and ignored.

It didn't have to be this way- they could conceivably have gone for an objective, classically liberal, even-handed approach (rather than the progressive approach they settled on). But they didn't, and the social trust required to cry wolf is now spent... even though maybe it shouldn't have been.


> That is exactly what normal human beings want our computers to do, and it's why the vast majority of AI safety initiatives are [correctly] seen as such a self-serving joke (because of the purposeful conflation of X-risk with "our political opponent could use this tool to destroy our politics") and ignored.

Except the "reality" here implies humans being around. Ask normal human beings whether they'd really be fine with Earth flourishing without them, and any other human, around, and see if you still get unanimous consensus.

Nature without us around - or other conscious beings capable of performing meaning, but we haven't found or made any other yet - is just runaway chemical reaction transiently messing up some otherwise boring rock in the great ocean of rocks that is our universe.

EDIT: or, if "humans being important" argument doesn't work, then the same from POV of "humans being dumb":

All the beauty and balance of nature we find so pretty and important is just an illusion. There's no balance, it's a dynamic evolving system, that happens to be meta-stable on our timescales. 10 generations ago it looked different; 10 generations from now, it'll look different still, and we may not like what it becomes then. It's stupid to sacrifice ourselves over some metaphysical primacy of "nature" that doesn't even exist, except in mind of believers. It's basically just a religion that never grew a holy book.


Govt reps should be required to use govt sites and only then repost to private sites, or leave that up to the people.


These articles and comments on them always seem to conflate programming with programming at one's job. And it makes sense, for most people that's one and the same. But if we're talking about programming and art, I think that is a major distinction.

To provide an example, I will use an existing comment here from WCSTombs: "programming is primarily problem solving, which isn't fundamentally artistic because its main goal is correctness and fitness for purpose".

I don't consider the programming I do at work to be art or expect to ever approach art. It fits their definition. But I could see some of the programming I do for pleasure to fall within that category. Correctness is nice I guess, but fitness for purpose was never a consideration in my hobby programming, quite the opposite, actually.

I was programming for a long time before I ever starting programming for money, which is why I feel strongly about this distinction, but it may be that in the current day and age, I am just being a boomer about the whole thing.


This and "Intellectual Fly Is Open" being at the top of the Hacker News front page right now and both having their titles auto-editorialized by HN really makes me wonder what benefit this mechanism is supposed to bring readers other than needless confusion.


The "feature" has clearly outstayed its usefulness, I really don't know why they haven't disabled it yet.


It's kind of like the Scunthorpe Problem[1]. Really, there's no better way to solve [whatever it is HN is trying to solve here] than text substitution??

1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scunthorpe_problem


While I have ranted already about the automated word removal being silly, too few posters are aware that you can edit the title after submission and auto-editorializing to restore anything that's been unnecessarily cut off.


Perhaps too many are aware, because the more people fix the auto-editorializing manually, the less inclined Dang will be to eventually see a reason to remove it after all.


It's an unaligned regular expression gone rogue. We became too dependent on our labor-saving string functions—not afraid enough of their corner cases, and lower cases. They were too useful. We began to normalize deviance, when we should have been normalizing Chomsky forms. We turned a blind eye to the unbounded growing evidence of something alarming.

It's too late to backtrack.


We all know what this means, but few of us have the courage to say it - we must immediately halt all research on regular expression. None of us know how it works and it has terrorized us for too long.


Wait, this is automatic? HN removes 'how'?


Yes, but you can edit your entry and re-add it. Then it stays. So, there's an override present.


It's a consistent source of unintentional comedy at least.


Worst feature ever. So many titles that get butchered for no reason.


I was thinking the same. Whatever benefit there may ostensibly be, we should consider it against the frequent, if benign, confusion it causes.


The hubris that simple code can fix deceptively complex and ambiguous human problems is too baked into the community to separate.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: