Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | rglullis's commentslogin

> nobody is wondering why kernel developers are still employed or what they bring to the table.

For now. Wait until we start hearing things like "Mythos reverse-engineered Apple ARM architecture and implemented the whole roadmap of the Asahi Project".


My compiler does not require billions of dollars of opearational infrastructure to work, except for the electrical grid.

And even in the case of outage, I can keep my computer running on a battery or a backup generator.


One claude instance also doesn't need billions of dollars of operational infrastructure to work.

Its great that you can keep your computer running, 1/3 of my information is ithe cloud (which is not a problem at all, even today) and 100% of my infrastructure is in the cloud.

Its not a problem at all, that a service has an outage. My laptop also had an outage when the logic board broke. Took 2 days to fix so what


> One claude instance also doesn't need billions of dollars of operational infrastructure to work.

Of course it does. It's the marginal cost that is low.

> 100% of my infrastructure is in the cloud.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Turkey_illusion

> My laptop also had an outage when the logic board broke.

And if you had a local backup, you'd be able to resume your work immediately.


> My laptop also had an outage when the logic board broke.

> And if you had a local backup, you'd be able to resume your work immediately.

Immediately after buying a new laptop. Or perhaps you mean you keep a spare laptop around? In any case, it's also an object that requires a huge environmentally destructive supply chain to create. Quite like a LLM...


> Immediately after buying a new laptop

No. I could go by with an older one, or in a pinch I could repurpose my current media server. Or I could put my data in an SSD with a bootable partition and borrow my wife's laptop...

> huge environmentally destructive supply chain to create.

Sunk cost fallacy? If the major electronics factories explode today, the existing computers won't stop working. If any of the Anthropic's datacenters go under, the compute capacity would have to be rebuilt.


If you're worried about the environment, you're better of stopping "outsourcing" your food gathering to factory farms or your walking to cars.

That's not what I'm talking about though, the question is whether the compiler does the thinking for you or not.

Or do you mean that the question of whether you're outsourcing your thinking to a LLM or not depends on whether you're running it locally? Would you claim you're outsourcing your thinking every time you run a script on a remote server?


My argument is specific to Claude, and it has nothing to do with "the environment".

It seems you didn't finish reading my comment before replying. Here's the relevant part in case you missed it:

> Or do you mean that the question of whether you're outsourcing your thinking to a LLM or not depends on whether you're running it locally? Would you claim you're outsourcing your thinking every time you run a script on a remote server?

In any case, your "argument" is more of an observation that

> Claude requires billions of dollars of operational infrastructure to work

Okay, so does a bunch of other things as well. So what?

Me and other commenters have tried quite hard to divine what you feel is relevant about this fact, without success. Perhaps it's time for you to try to articulate what significance you see in it.


My point is that your "outsourcing to a compiler" analogy does not make sense. And that running a hosted, proprietary LLM is not the same as "running a script in a remote server".

The whole "AI is a tool" argument only works if the "tool" is a commodity that is universally available and still exists even if the tool manufacturer disappears. Open-weights, locally hosted LLMs fit this criteria. Anything that depends on a cloud provider does not.


> The whole "AI is a tool" argument only works if the "tool" is a commodity that is universally available and still exists even if the tool manufacturer disappears.

You have quite strange criteria for what constitutes a "tool", but sure, at least I see where you're coming from then.


I think it will boil down to find out how many people out there are not willing to trust their agent with their credit card but are willing to give it a prepaid debit card - which effectively it's what Coinbase is providing, but dressing it as cryptocurrency.

It also means that if this starts getting any traction, then we could expect to start a nice bump in prepaid debit card adoption.


Please, no. Stories like these work because they are timeless. One of the reasons that TV nowadays is so boring is because every show runner wants to use it as a platform for their own social commentary.

Isn’t that what all stories are about though?

Every show or movie is a platform for the social commentary of the time. That's what a narrative is. This reminds me of the people who will say that Star Wars is not political.

No... it is. It all is. You can ask the creators, they'll tell you. Sometimes in the context of the modern day it might not seem like social commentary or political commentary because we take a lot for granted but, I assure you, at the time it certainly was, and it certainly still is.


This is not what I'm arguing.

Of course authors will inject their worldview into what they create. Of course stories will reflect fundamental aspects of humanity, and with that how people (and groups of people) relate to one another. This is all valid.

> Sometimes in the context of the modern day

The problem is that writers nowadays write *only* for the "modern day". Everything becomes "social commentary" for $CURRENT_THING, which means that the story becomes stale the moment that the powers-that-be move on and $CURRENT_THING stops being a thing.

Good stories are perenial and worthy of be retold, no matter who is in power at any given moment. "Malcolm in the Middle" is a TV show that has things that working class families can relate, no matter if they are living in 2006, 2026 or 2056. "The Wire" is a show with very clear social commentary, but the same story would be told whether you had a Democrat or a Republican in the White House. "The Boys" was a show that started with a perenial premise (what if gods were just as broken as humans) and by the third season it turned itself into a caricature of Trump's America. Guess which ones from these will be talked about 25 years from now, and which one is pretty much forgotten already?


>Good stories are perenial and worthy of be retold, no matter who is in power at any given moment. "Malcolm in the Middle" is a TV show that has things that working class families can relate, no matter if they are living in 2006, 2026 or 2056.

Is it? I’m almost 40, and I can’t relate to anyone who would decide to have that many kids at the level of wealth and quality of life that Malcolm’s parents were living. Hell, a family with 3 kids is pretty rare, much less one with 4 who end up with a 5th.

Also, with smartphones and other video surveillance, pretty much all the shenanigans the boys get into don’t happen in the future.


If you are not able to relate to a story unless they give you a perfect mirror of your life and your context, I'd say that the problem is with you, not the storytelling.

They don't have to be perfect but there's a Canadian version of Breaking Bad up on YouTube. It's minutes long, instead of multiple seasons, because Canada has universal healthcare. Or Romeo and Juliet. The story doesn't work after the invention of cellphones.

Some storytelling still works. The Land Before Time works because they're dinosaurs.


Walter White was not forced to sell drugs. Breaking Bad is clear about it. He had access to money, his friend offered.

Walter White liked selling drugs. It was pride, ego and appeal of it all. That was one of the key things about his character. He was not a victim.


And in Canada that egotistic, prideful man would not have lost face by going to the public healthcare system. It would just have been a Tuesday.

Living in a ruthless place brings out the war lords among us. Let's not.


Ok, but he was not a out to loose face. At all. He was offered a job he was succesfull at before.

And he continued escalating long after he was healthy and long after he has so much money, it was impossible to store and launder them.

That character is interesting specifically because he was not victim of the circumstances.


Saying a story is worthy of being told by measuring the verisimilitude of its plot devices has to be one of the brain-dead takes I've heard in a long while, if not ever...

The ultimate preppers just become Amish.

If it works it's not stupid. Or something.

Personally: I have a XTX7900 card which can run some decent models, eg, Qwen 27B and Gemma. For bigger stuff I have the Ollama Cloud subscription to access (mostly) GLM. I have a server with OpenWebUI, and for harnesses I use OpenCode, but I have been experimenting with pi.dev to create a workflow that takes the ideas from the Rational Unified Process (RUP) so that everything gets properly documented and reviewed by a human before getting to the implementation phase.

At work: Claude Code subscription, mostly with Opus.


If you *really* care, run your own inference. Everything else is just wishful thinking and/or convenience winning over self-sovereignty.

exactly, it's surprising to read this on HN with qualified individuals that assume that Cleartext chats and a contract is a form of technical security? :/

Breach of contract at an enterprise level is a corporate death sentence. Individuals might get screwed over but billion dollar corporations do not.

As an example, in the industry I work in, software license enforcement is quite easy to break if you want to. But you never would, because if your employer found out they would fire you on the spot. They don't want to violate their license agreements even if it meant free use because of the legal liability and the future loss of access to that product. Enterprises make a point of tracking their own license usage specifically to make sure they don't accidentally end up in violation. The systems are mostly about tracking and auditing for compliance, not about technical blockers to make it impossible.


The issue is that the contract can not be enforced. For your company to be penalized for violating the license agreement, first it needs to be detected by the license provider. If you are sending your code to OpenAI/Anthropic to get inference, how can one detect that it is not being copied by them and being used for training?

It doesn't matter how much they "continue to advance at a pretty rapid pace", if the economy has no actual demand for the new capabilities. Even if we accept the premise that LLMs can produce good code at scale now and automate most software development work, then what? As *an industry*, the bottleneck was that we needed people to write code, and that bottleneck has been removed since ~Opus 4.6. Where is the industry now bottlenecked which requires some significant quantum leap in model capability?

Opus 4.6's coding ability is nowhere near as good as Opus 5.5's. Some model next year will almost certainly be significantly better at coding (and planning, and designing, and ideating) than Opus 5.5.

You're narrowly focused on writing code. What about when they can run entire firms themselves, better than the average human CEO could? What about when we have models way, way, way better than Opus 4.6 and 5.5?

The point is we will eventually very likely have AI systems that can do everything. Everything. Anything and everything a human can do with - or even without - a computer, and then better than anything or everything a human can do, including in terms of creativity and innovation and novelty and insight. Obviously I don't know when that might possibly be, and it's not happening next year or something, but you can't just pretend like we hit the cap on the technology.


> What about when they can run entire firms themselves

That would mean the whole idea of free markets will be rendered obsolete, instantly destroying the idea that investing in Anthropic is sensible.


Don’t bother - these knuclkleheads don’t understand nuance and despite much of their devices being manufactured in China - they struggle to accept Chinese offerings can take significant market share.

Not if Anthropic consistently stays 6+ months ahead of all labs besides OpenAI.

It is a lot easier to switch model providers than it is to switch cloud providers. And the open weight models from Chinese Labs make Claude a lot more of a commodity than any service provided by AWS.

It is the other way around. Education/Training is only expensive because it is subsidized by the State.


It is expensive because it confers greatly enhanced earning potential. Students borrow against that future income. Sometimes from the state.

It confers enhanced future income largely because of the inherent vetting process that asures future employers this person is able to focus for extended periods of time on intellectual tasks, is able to follow through and function within a bureaucracy. I don't think it's as much about skills, at least it's way overkill for the skills that are actually needed on the job for most jobs.

I don't see the rise of LLMs as obviating the "functional cog in the Rube Goldberg machine" training.


It is also expensive because the debt is very hard to get erased through bankruptcy, so private companies are now offering more money to people than is actually needed. So universities see this $ and raise prices.

Kinda like how tax breaks on housing initially help people, and then the market adjusts based on the new inflow of $.


This is just another way of saying that people go to school to buy access to the network, not for education itself.


> Education/Training is only expensive because it is subsidized by the State. reply

The death of apprenticeships is because you are training your own competition. It worked in the past because you trained your kid for a trade that was arcane and took a couple decades to master, but now you'd be training someone with no loyalty to you in a field that can be speed run in a year or so with YouTube assistance.


Apprenticeships died long before YouTube. Their decline in the US is linked to the decline of trade unions who sponsor them.


It is much cheaper for a company to do NO training.

It does not matter if Education/Training is done by the government or another company all that matters is that the company does not have any training in its accounts. If it has that is an obvious cost to cut.

Long term this is not good for a company but for the next year or two at least it is better and that is all that their shareholders will look at,


> It is much cheaper for a company to do NO training.

Only if someone else is footing the bill.

> If it has that is an obvious cost to cut.

When it costs tens of thousands per year, yes. If training became 10-100 times cheaper, "training" becomes as expensive per employee as the cost of offering cafeteria food or "gym memberships". Training would be on par of offering any other type of employment benefit, and you don't see shareholders asking for big companies to get rid of any of those.


Yes they do.

Most UK large companies had cafeterias in the 1980s now they don't and you have to go out to get lunch.

Training always costs thousands a year.

If you train a person you have to pay their salary and overheads. whilst they are being trained and are not fully productive. Plus you need to pain for the people and machinery needed to provide the training. Much cheaper to do non of these.


> Most UK large companies had cafeterias in the 1980s now they don't and you have to go out to get lunch

And FAANG companies famously provide everything in campus (food, laundry, gym clubs) as perks. What's your point?

> Much cheaper to do non of these

That's a textbook example of the Doorman fallacy.


If it was that simple, the cost of education per student would be highest in places like Germany.


You neo-liberals have been wrong about this for 40 years now. You wrought us all with your Reaganomics, and have had the full attention of every government for this entire time (except maybe in Cuba) and the results have been truly disastrous, climate catastrophe and all.

If private enterprise was really this efficient, and government was really that inefficient, we should have seen ample evidence for that by now. The fact that we haven’t is proof that the promises of neo-liberalism are all lies.


> If private enterprise was really this efficient, and government was really that inefficient, we should have seen ample evidence for that by now.

Food. Consumer goods. Telecommunications services. Transportation. Clothes. All things that have gone down in absolute prices and relative amount of family income to be provided.

Education / Housing / Healthcare: all deemed "up to the State" and that takes increasingly more from people at ever diminishing returns.

We can have a long and serious conversation about how hard the Government should be involved in regulating these things, and how we could set up systems that ensure that these become universally available and not just for middle/upper class. We can even have a conversation about things that should be controlled by the Government even if it means a high cost to society. But to deny that things managed by the State are more expensive overall is a clear sign of ideological blindness.


> But to deny that things managed by the State are more expensive overall is a clear sign of ideological blindness.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50208837


The way to solve this is not by giving the monopoly back to the state, but by the state enacting regulations thay allows smaller players to join the grid.


Europe has been doing this for 20 years now. I have yet to see successful results. And realizing each failure of Neo-liberal policy Europe keeps doubling or quadrupling down. I believe they are on their 4th energy package at the moment. I am sure the fate if this 4th attempt will be identical to the other efforts of making capitalism fix the problem, and identical to any other neo-liberal policy. Europe will have more billionaires and peoples energy bills will be higher.

As the saying in Europe goes: Neo-liberalism will continue until the economy improves.


Really?

Do we have 20 years already since people are allowed to set up a solar panel in their backyard and sell excess capacity to the grid?

Do we have 20 years where farmers can grow their own biodiesel to (at least) power their own machinery, or does the state giving them subsidies to let them keep growing vegetables, wine and beef without having to compete in the global market?


We have had 20 years of energy distribution and infrastructure going from government ownership and into private hands, where different private distributors are allowed to compete for customers on the same grid. These were energy packages 1-2 (if I remember correctly). The results have been higher energy prices for European households.

Energy package 3 was supposed to fix this with some additional regulation and standardization. It did not. Energy package 4 is supposed to fix this with more standardization and regulations (including distributed generation; which I am in favor of btw.) however, it will not.

The problem is the privatizations of the 2000s, not in the regulations surrounding small scale solar. The problem is neo-liberalism. Get rid of corporations rent-seeking on our infrastructure. Our energy bills will not become lower until then.


> The results have been higher energy prices for European households.

Under state-owned infrastructure, you simply can never know the real cost of any of the services, because state-owned companies depend a lot more on subsidies that come from tax revenue than actual revenue from the service itself.

> Get rid of corporations rent-seeking on our infrastructure.

Get rid of corporations altogether. I firmly believe that any company (state owned or not) with more than 150 employees should be broken down.


In the UK whichj has the highest electricity prices in Europe all parts of the electricity supply chain are owned by companies.


I'm a bit confused why you have housing and healthcare "up to the state". Are we talking about the United States or somewhere else?


I am guessing Germany or Europe more broadly. Germany is in a pretty bad neo-liberal wave right now, and have been getting worse for the past 10-15 years. And given Germany‘s influence in the EU the effects of this neo-liberal wave are felt across Europe, even in non-EU countries like Iceland (which is currently being fined by the EU for not privatizing garbage disposal fast enough).

However, if you look at the popular movements on the streets of Europe at the moment, you can see that the people are in fact not happy about this. There are very few political means of getting rid of neo-liberalism (see e.g. Spain for a clear example of what I mean) so people are turning to the streets as the only viable alternative.


>If private enterprise was really this efficient, and government was really that inefficient, we should have seen ample evidence for that by now

There's a wealth of clear evidence for this in the economic data in Eastern vs Western Europe, East Germany vs West Germany when Eastern Europe was under Soviet rule. The countries under Soviet rule were significantly poorer and to this day most still haven't caught up with their Western European counterparts.


Eastern Europe underwent shock therapy and are today in many ways more extreme in neo-liberal policies then the western part of the same continent.

Western Europe didn’t start neo-liberal policies until after the cold war ended, and it went into full gear around the year 2000.

In either case. Is garbage disposal in Europe so much more efficient now that it has all been privatized, compared to the mid-90s? Are trains running cheaper? Is power transmission cheaper now that energy generation, and delivery have been split apart and sold to private investors on the public stock market?

No, the answer to all these questions are no. Because efficiencies in a system don‘t care about the ownership model, and neo-liberalism is a religious like creed that operates out of idealism for a world that does not exist.


> is garbage disposal in Europe so much more efficient now that it has all been privatized, compared to the mid-90s?

Is it?

> Are trains running cheaper?

They're up about 6% in real terms (or about 0.23% a year) since 2000 [1]. That said, I don't think most European rail is privatized, so this is a strange example.

[1] https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/databrowser/product/page/PRC_H... deflated with CP00


> Is it?

Yes and no. Garbage disposal is more efficient now then it was in the mid-90s, but that has everything to do with the infrastructure and nothing to do with the ownership model. More on that later.

The ownership of infrastructure and the operation are split where private operators are allowed to compete with national operators on the same infrastructure. This is true for trains and electricity, and in some cases garbage disposal. Many of the national operators are publicly traded with the national government being the majority shareholder.

Some countries in Europe have gone much further in privatizing the rail network then others. The UK being the canonical example of privatization, and Norway being an example of a country privatizing more slowly.

If the promises of neo-liberalism were true, we should see the efficiencies gained in the UK compared to Norway. Yet, no such evidence exists. And that is because efficiencies correlate with the quality and the quantity of infrastructure, not the ideological policies that dictate the ownership of the operators.


> efficiencies correlate with the quality and the quantity of infrastructure, not the ideological policies that dictate the ownership of the operators

I mostly agree. Infrastructure quality (including institutional quality) dominates. Ideology is usually cover for a lack of evidence.

But ownership modes do create different incentive structures. Full private ownership is famously terrible in natural monopolies. It’s a well-known market failure and folks who proselytize fully privatized utilities are stupid or venal. For many other things, however, private ownership works. A good example is package delivery. (Train operation is a weird case. The UK fumbled. Italy did not. On the other end of the spectrum, DB is a trash fire.)


You may want to double-check your priors on the incentive structures.

For goods and services where demand is inelastic and the barrier for entry is high, the invisible hand will end up colluding to extract the most value possible (housing, utilities, groceries, healthcare). If the state does this, the ruling party starts catching strays and is eventually replaced. Of course, for the distinction to matter, you need to be able to meaningfully create new parties.

Your point stands for elastic demand, where you can choose to vote with your wallet (restaurants, vacations, gyms). Capitalism did a good job of adding to this list during its growth stage (transportation, entertainment, communications) but nowadays it's mostly established cartels that dominate all of the above in what appears to be a race to the bottom.

The incentives for package delivery are closer to the first category than the second though, since consumers end up with whatever company the supplier signed up with, thus mostly eliminating choice and reducing quality to the bare minimum required by the contract (not unlike the postal services).

Even when the customer gets to choose, the end results are still worse than vertical integration. Consider the food delivery apps that replaced most restaurants' in-house delivery teams: they have a direct interest to collude to keep prices high since they all earn the same no matter what restaurant you buy from, whereas for the individual restaurant it makes sense to throw in free delivery to get you buying from them.

I guess the biggest downside to private ownership is that it creates an incentive to have collusion service providers masquerading as adding value (realtors, brokers, speculators, resellers, risk managers, etc.) while providing plausible deniability to the state (which is of course responsible for its failure to regulate the incentive structure for these value-added services on a case-by-case basis).


The thing is that the policy has been splitting off infrastructure from the operators, allowing competition of operators, and selling off shares of national operators. This policy is straight from the books of neo-liberalism, and it promised us greater efficiency.

My point is that these promises are lies. Neo-liberalism is a failed policy (yet it is the dominant policy among every single government in power today). And when GP claimed education was expensive because it is done by the government, I was here to call it out as another lie of neo-liberalism.


> And when GP claimed education was expensive because it is done by the government

Not what I said. Read again.


> Are trains running cheaper?

You are picking the textbook example of a natural monopoly as a way to argue against how free markets don't work?


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: