Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | parisivy's comments login

Music can be copied, shared and redistributed for a marginal fee. Text even more. Nevertheless, you have record and book collectors. What's the difference?


Records and books get official, physical prints? People collect stamps too, but if you turned them into JPEGs those same people wouldn't care anymore.


People collect video or digital art. What would be the difference in that case?


In that case, they can collect whatever they want. The unique or special value of owning it in your collection is effectively nothing since I can enjoy the full-fidelity version at no cost wherever I go. This is the inherent problem with "collecting" something that is digital and can be infinitely reproduced.

I collect things because they're unique. Things that exist everywhere in abundance are not interesting to me. I could collect Coke-a-Cola bottles, but that wouldn't be special; I'd just be hoarding a bunch of trash.


Great reply!


At which point, would we change our legal system to allow AGIs to own property or have fiduciary duties over a company? What would be the minimum requirements for it to happen.


I had thought about this a few years back. My final thought to avoid intervention from a human owner was that the company could be fully owned by a second company, which is then fully owned by the first. This chain would effectively remove the businesses from human ownership, and the AI would inherit the "personhood" of the business entities. I don't know where the legality is for such a thing.


It all boils down to the courts. If the AGI can protect itself via lawyers (probably AGIs themselves) then anything can happen.

But court could rule AGI don’t have to rights to ownership and try to enforce it. That last part might not be possible and lead to war?


Incorporating in a jurisdiction which allows anonymous ownership. Such as Nevada.


Did you fly Atlanta - Buenos Aires? I flew on Wednesday 6th. Were you my pilot? :)


Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: