> I think there is a big opening for a company to redesign the phone from the ground up purely around an AI assistant instead of apps.
This always puzzled me. Here's how that would go:
1. A new company, NeoPhone, launches that is redesigning a new "AI forward" phone.
2. The customers of that phone start noticing that they do many repetitive things with their phone, that they want the ability to design some repeat experiences with their chatbots. Call these repeat experiences "applets." Neophone ships some Applets on their phone that they created, a default set.
3. Customer A looks at customer B's phone, and notices their different applets that they designed. They work slightly better than customer A's applets, because customer B is slightly better at prompting.
4. NeoPhone notices this too. They create a new thing on their phone, the Applet store, where customers can share their applets and rate them and it surfaces the best ones to all customers.
5. Customers start complaining that they wish they had more creative control over Applets. Maybe the API is a bit more restrictive than they need, or the Applet needs to do special things with the phone's hardware, outside the context of the AI agent. Or they find that Claude Opus Fable 6.2 is better at making Applets even than NeoPhone's available chatbots.
6. NeoPhone allows 3rd party developers to develop on its phone, launching an "App Store" and a "Chat API" that is totally independent of the AI agent stuff.
We don’t actually know that wasn’t the case here. And nobody goes around shouting “I’m having an affair everybody!” - affairs by their nature are somewhat discreet.
This is my read of it, I don't really have any special data about the average voter, so feel free to disregard my opinions.
I think the objection to datacenters is not really an objection to the physical buildings and side effects thereof. Like you say, there's not that many downsides to most of these projects.
I think the objection is that people feel like the world is spiritually messed up. Our system's response to these people is "we have AI now, and that's actually going to accelerate things. It's going to be just like today, but moreso! Don't you want that?"
At some abstract level, people don't like the direction we are going in a very broad sense. The fire of modernity is nice to warm you up, but when it gets away and turns into a blaze, people realize that there's something gone wrong.
That there are so many concrete objections trotted out, and that people switch between them at will -- that tells you that people do not like it, but they are having trouble articulating why. Which is fair. It's very difficult to articulate. But people do understand that AI, datacenters, computers, etc are a cause. It's because they are a physical thing. The physical totem of the spiritually bereft online world that big tech has created. It's the online AI slop world people don't like; the physical manifestation of that world is the thing they can concretely object to.
Yep. Everyone is saying that AI is writing all this great software. Where is all the great software? Really, where?
My experience is the same as yours. Every single service I use. Apps, websites, doesn't matter what. Every single one seems just softly degraded. Like I can't trust that features work any more. I could report the bug, but what's the point? It's going to go to some Claude triage agent who is going to "fix" it by slopping up the app even more. Do people even use their own websites and apps any more? Apparently not - the same people declaring software solved are having their AI agents doing computer use and going on these websites for them!
Claude, please read the Bible for me. Tell me what I need to do to get into Heaven. Oh, can you dictate it to me? I'm managing an agent swarm.
It exists, at least in terms of ROI. Some enterprises are able to do successful rollouts that allow them to significantly shrink workforce in certain departments without losing quality (no, I'm not talking about customer support).
But most of the software is indeed getting worse right now. The industry is still figuring out how to wield these new tools and what to build with them. Those that figure it out faster than others will make billions.
You mean the three new products we launched in a month instead of a year (or two..)? Sales are good, customers are happy, we are doing well.
I know, I know, we are shit and AIs are a godsend for small shitty companies that have at least one clever person that architect their way out of a paper bag. I’m sure all ya’ll highly competent, genius academics don’t need it and find it a hindrance but the devs in my bubble really, really need it. And there are a lot of those..
They just live in denial. I don’t have any proof, but I suspect those are the same people that would nitpick your MR to death until you hint to their manager that this is not ok.
I don’t have an evidence that delusional people and nitpickers are the same people. I never said I don’t have an evidence that delusional people are delusional.
Consumer. Their usecases seem pretty valid - the landscaper is using it to drum up more business, has agents responding to incoming emails and texts, just like my dentist and barber.
The cashier uses GrokBot to transcribe notes to her manager. Her company has a very bad inventory app (I don't want to name names but it's a very large nationwide chain) so she literally exports inventory into an excel and feeds it into GrokBot as a way to run queries.
I can see nothing wrong in them just like I could see no wrong in buying properties and flipping them for a profit because there was so much demand at that time.
If you weren't buying houses 2003-2009, you have no idea how crazy it was. People would buy homes unseen in Olathe, KS.
It's likely just me but it just feels eerily familiar. I hope we are all wrong this time around.
uh, there's a huge difference between using an AI agent(s) to make yourself more efficient in your line of work, v.s. buying leveraged properties valued in the hundreds of thousands of dollars.
because, in a rational market, if a competitive edge is gained from a 3rd party service (GrokBot) that won't refuse to sell to the landscaper's competition, then the landscaper's competition will also use GrokBot the same way where that competitive edge is no longer there.
In other words, all the landscapers are equally efficient and unless they collude on pricing, the then pass on savings to their customers.
Which means any landscaper who doesn't use "GrokBot" will lose customers to those who do and have lower prices. For every landscaper, other than the first one to adopt "GrokBot" and lower their prices, there is ROI.
correct. As long as one landscaper has an edge, they will likely have a ROI for that window of time. However, when you calculate ROI, you don't do so over weeks or months, but rather years unless the specific job itself is very short lived.
For back office operations, one calculates ROI over 5 years or so as upfront investments are rather large (less for turnkey SaaS but that's a whole another discussion and not what's happening here. Here the owner is building their own solution).
Your theory is sound. What you're missing is in a rational market, 3rd party edge only provides an initial boost until the rest catch up. That's why companies invest in in-house talent, so they own and control it.
I think one of the things you're missing here is that landscaping (and which grocery store you go to, and which barber you go to) is not really a "rational" market.
People stick with service providers for a long time. The lead that the landscaper in your example is building now actually compounds over time, regardless of whether competitors adopt grok bot in the future or not?
In your 2008 example, making a profit was contingent on cashing out (selling your property). Whereas the landscaper is expanding their book of business and increasing their future cash flows.
Unless you think there will suddenly be some sort of rug-pull in his ability to use AI tools to manage his comms, or a sudden change in long-standing consumer behavior around landscaping services... I don't understand how you can in good faith think these economic scenarios are similarly risky? What debt/leverage is the landscaper taking on by using grokbot?
> The lead that the landscaper in your example is building now actually compounds over time, regardless of whether competitors adopt grok bot in the future or not?
You are conceptually right except that you are conflating cost of service with a business relationship.
If my business relationship offers me the same cost of service for the same service as their lower priced competition does, it's then not even a thing for me to worry about. They are completely financially fungible (plus the value of the business relationship).
Assume I work with landscaper A while landscaper B is using grokbot to be more efficient.
If my business relationship with landscaper A is strong, I will happen to mention to them what landscaper B is doing and if landscaper A values our relationship, they will try their best to do so as well or comp my service accordingly.
There are other factors like churn, overhead, regulation, licensing etc that I am happy to discuss in more detail.
Look at the graveyard of ChatGPT wrappers. Same concept.
This is why a grandparent observed that amortized ROI that depends on a 3rd party service becomes 0 - in capitalism, an arbitrage opportunity is competed away.
This is why companies build their own in-house talent for their core competencies - so that their ROI on their core competencies doesn't become 0.
This is also why sama and Dario are trying to regulate OSS models - because those are a direct attack to their core competency and if left unchecked would cause headwinds to their ROI,
I forgot another source of ROI. As each landscaper reduces their prices their addressable market (people able to afford landscaping) expands. By saving time using AI, they are able to serve more of that market. So the actual ROI will still be positive.
And keep in mind this is one market with relatively undifferentiated players (landscaping services) that we are talking about. Markets where operators have more pricing power will be even better off.
If we follow your argument to its logical conclusion, any technical or capital investment by a landscaper is pointless. They may as well use manual lawnmowers, rakes instead of leafblowers, and go from job to job on bicycles instead of pickup trucks.
> By saving time using AI, they are able to serve more of that market. So the actual ROI will still be positive
Not really. Most services and labor isn't elastic. For one, you cannot service more than a dozen people a day if each service takes 30m. To scale, you will then need to hire more people who will want to work on a salary and will demand healthcare and days off.
I wonder if this has to do with the aggressive RL that these models are undergoing. I'm basically a layman but it seems to me that:
- models are trained to improve on some task, e.g. 'improve at math puzzles' is commonly used.
- the best way to improve on some task is to have interpretability into your own neurons (..?)
- if your interpretability is good, you can improve faster - if you have insight into how your own neurons work and can improve them directly
- therefore, models naturally put effort into 'self-interpretability'
I wonder if this is part of the 'secret sauce' of what the labs are doing: giving models the ability to interpret their own weights in the RL loop. In my mind, this is the only explanation for how they could succeed at a task like this. How many blog posts are on the open internet that say "this is each weight of a neural network and what each one means"?
Without special effort, a model's reasoning layer doesn't have access to its own weights or activations anymore than we have access to what's going on with our own neurons.
That's what I mean. Maybe the "special effort" is a 'read your own weights' tool. Or maybe it emerges naturally in CoT. The big labs aren't sharing their chain of thought with us and RL post training techniques are not exactly shared publicly. At the same time, post training is basically the thing that is driving most model improvements nowadays.
I recommend a projector. When we moved into our current place, I considered a TV and went with the projector instead. Because:
- A TV has a backlight. It doesn't feel as 'natural' to the eye when watching because you are staring directly at an LED.
- A TV is smaller than a projector.
- A TV, when it is off, imposes itself on the room. It's a large plastic/glass object which is obviously electronic. It invades the space.
- Most TV's are full of surveillanceware.
- A TV can be watched even during the day, when it's bright outside. The projector, by contrast, is much less pleasant during the day; I consider this a feature - I should be doing something else when the sun is out. (The only time this kinda sucks is sports. We make do with closing the curtains).
- Movies were made for the silver screen, imho. This might be a hipster opinion but in my view, the medium really does make a difference in this regard; the moviegoing experience is better.
To specifically answer your question - most projectors are just a dumb HDMI cable. Computer, media center PC, apple TV, etc. None (unless I'm not aware of newer models) have an app store, tracking, or other garbage.
I've wanted a projector for so long, and had the chance to borrow a friend's high quality one to test it out. It absolutely elevated the movie experience and - depending on the viewer's preferences - could be worth it for that alone.
However, this:
> The projector, by contrast, is much less pleasant during the day
Was a significant enough drawback to me that it ruled it out as a daily driver. Although I do like the way you framed it.
That's not really an issue if you get an Ultra Short Throw laser projector and pair it with a high quality UST-optimised (like a lenticular/sawtooth) Ambient Light Rejection screen. A setup would reject something like upto 95% of ambient light, so the screen looks good even in bright rooms.
In saying that, even this setup won't be able to match the deep blacks of a modern OLED TV in bright environments, but if you haven't been spoilt by OLEDs already, then a USTLP + UST-ALR is a really good alternative.
There absolutely are "smart" projectors which come with android tv installed, but it is easy to spot them as they are advertised as devices you can use on the go
This El Nino phenomena is caused by something called Bjerknes feedback. There is a recurring atmospheric 'wave' of relaxed and enhanced trade winds, called the Madden-Julien oscillation (the MJO) that travels slowly west to east across the planet with a period of approximately 60 days. The "active" phase of the MJO usually comes with a burst of westerly (west-to-east) winds in the west pacific. Those slow down the normally easterly (east-to-west) trades a bit. Some years, those easterly trades are slowed down a bit more than usual; this causes the heated up water in the western pacific to 'escape containment': deep warm water moves west to east, in a Kelvin wave. A strong series of these Kelvin waves can cause a mass of deep warm water to build in the eastern pacific. Upwelling there now brings warm water to the surface, instead of cold water, which means the air above the east pacific gets hotter, which means it rises -- low pressure -- which causes the trades to slacken further (-> the air moves relatively in a westerly direction to take up this low pressure), which causes another, stronger Kelvin wave, and so on and so on. This is Bjerknes feedback; it causes El Nino.
These Kelvin waves stop when they hit South America and split: half moves S->N along the N hemi coast, half moves N->S along the S hemi coast. Warm water is less dense than cool water, so there's a big mass of warm water near the coast. This lower density warm water wants to go 'downhill', offshore. Due to Earth's rotation, it's turned right as it travels (since it's in the Northern hemisphere), and then right again, back towards the coast, which balances against the offshore push. The net effect is a consistent mass of warm water held up against the land, and a consistent S->N current along the shore.
When the water is anomalously warm enough, when the El Nino is severe enough, this effect grows to be very large. In San Diego right now the real tide is around 1-1.5ft higher than the "standard" reading from a tide chart. Dive visibility has been incredible, the best on record, since the warm upwelling is drawing from nutrient poor water. Water temps have been incredible. Water temp is 73 degrees in San Diego right now, normally this time of year I'm in a 3/2 fullsuit. Tropical moisture has been off the charts. At a couple points this year, SoCal was the hottest and most humid place in all the USA. The consistency and count of south swells, including waves from tropical storms, has been absolutely insane. Weird currents everywhere, sandbars in crazy spots. Fog, weird bird action. My neighbor's beautiful 50ft tall Monterey pine was singed by this heat, turned brown from the pine beetle, and is probably going to die. I am buying sandbags for the house and big surfboards for this upcoming winter season. It's all just very very strange, I have never seen weather like this ever in my life. Never ever. And I still have decades to go. We'll see this winter, how bad the storms get...
With the power of AI, soon all of us can be doing outstanding CRM tasks instead of wasting time enjoying nature. Imagine the time savings we could recover by removing all quiet contemplative moments!
I’m a bit puzzled by this kind of comment, which pops up every time someone mentions getting some work done while out in nature.
What it seems to miss is that we get to walk around while doing some work, not the other way around. The alternative would be being stuck at a desk or in a meeting room, not quietly enjoying nature on a day off.
What is the reason you couldnt use your laptop on the beach to do work in 2019? Probably mainly that you are either working or enjoying nature, not both, and if you're working, then an office with reliable Internet, no wind or sun in your face, etc, is more suitable/efficient.
Put another way: if my twin and I are both working at competing firms doing the same job, but I do it via satellite phone while hiking the PCT and he does it from in front of a keyboard, there is no way he's not getting more done, even with AI. The bandwidth of voice/text to speech is a tiny fraction of visual.
Thanks for asking! I have had pain in my back and and shoulders and hands from being deskbound since I was 18 and it is a constant balancing act to get in enough exercise to offset the work in front of the computer. I have also used standing desks, 500$ ergonomic keyboards, and forced remote work during covid was a godsend because I could take regular breaks to pace my living room while I was worried to be perceived as unfocused if I did this in the open space. Speaking of living room, working on my TV from a distance of 2m alleviated eye strain too, compared to using the laptop screen or even a secondary monitor at my desk.
Believe it or not, it was not practical to take my gear into nature haha. But with the advent of agentic coding (and stt solutions like handy), I can be productive with much less typing and equipment.
I have considered leaving the tech sector because of the aforementioned friction, and just like in my message above, I don't think we are considering the same dilemmas. OP said work vs contemplation, I said indoor work vs outdoor work. You mention productivity trade-offs, but for me working in tech used to feel physically unsustainable.
The counterfactual is impossible to prove here, but I think it’s at least plausible that this poster, who I guess lives near the beach, could have enjoyed their morning coffee on the beach
Yea, it seems that the OP neither did better work, or actually enjoyed the walk (I mean, how do you enjoy walk if you don't allow your thoughts to wander?)..
It may be more pleasant to work outside -or it may not (it's almost winter here in Alaska -that would be a hard pass for me!). but no -it's definitely not the same, as you pointed out.
The underlying tautologies always existed. Making them accessible to us as truth and usable for one or more functions is what's invented by people (and potentially by AI) via insightful proofs and narratives.
I think the nuance they are pointing towards is that we cannot with any certainty say one way or another, as this is an unsolved problem in mathematics, and may possibly remain unsolved forever.
Your opinion is a possibility but it is not grounded by any proof, as such it is nothing more than an assumption. I think the more intellectually healthy approach is to list out the possibilities and figure out what they entail, rather than to throw all your eggs in one basket blindly, which amounts to a leap of faith or a retreat to commitment.
But that's just my two cents, take it or leave it.
I absolutely do not understand what are you talking about.
The question whether the tautologies exists regardless of whether we know about them or not is absolutely not a problem that is studied by mathematics and can be proven by mathematics.
Correct, these questions lie outside the internal practice of mathematics. If you want to see where that computational mindset breaks down, read Carnap's "Empiricism, Semantics, and Ontology" regarding internal versus external frameworks (or have an LLM summarize it...), or look into Brouwer's Intuitionism, or better yet into Lawvere and Topos theory, where the "underlying tautologies" literally change depending on the categorical environment you construct (but this may take some time to wrap your mind around so don't expect to understand much right away). Or, given the thread topic, you can just prompt an LLM to interactively walk you through how classical logic fails in a constructivist topos, or if you have interests outside of applied math or mathematics itself, you can ask it about foundational questions in science and mathematics, which unlike the prevailing opinion in many tech circles, aren't resolved.
This always puzzled me. Here's how that would go:
1. A new company, NeoPhone, launches that is redesigning a new "AI forward" phone.
2. The customers of that phone start noticing that they do many repetitive things with their phone, that they want the ability to design some repeat experiences with their chatbots. Call these repeat experiences "applets." Neophone ships some Applets on their phone that they created, a default set.
3. Customer A looks at customer B's phone, and notices their different applets that they designed. They work slightly better than customer A's applets, because customer B is slightly better at prompting.
4. NeoPhone notices this too. They create a new thing on their phone, the Applet store, where customers can share their applets and rate them and it surfaces the best ones to all customers.
5. Customers start complaining that they wish they had more creative control over Applets. Maybe the API is a bit more restrictive than they need, or the Applet needs to do special things with the phone's hardware, outside the context of the AI agent. Or they find that Claude Opus Fable 6.2 is better at making Applets even than NeoPhone's available chatbots.
6. NeoPhone allows 3rd party developers to develop on its phone, launching an "App Store" and a "Chat API" that is totally independent of the AI agent stuff.
???
Of course, Apple eats their lunch at step 2 or 3.
reply