Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | lo_zamoyski's commentslogin

Part of this is a sign of the times. I am not one to view the past through rose-tinted glasses, but pop psychology and what not have normalized coddling and indulgence. As someone once said, it's not the strong who are dangerous, but the weak.

And productivity would be reduced why? Because rational faculties are impeded.

In any case, if that were the only concern, then I claim you would likely not see the legalizing or loosening of restrictions. On the contrary, I claim that this growing laxity is at least subconsciously if not explicitly motivated by a fear of growing discontent over our oligarchic political order, and the desire to “neutralize” the nasty effects of the disordered lifestyles it encourages and to render people docile.


> Essentially all of our problems are caused by excessive population

Except they aren't. This is the old Malthusian claim and it has been debunked time and again.

> Wars

Historically, war has been on a downward trajectory for a long time, certainly when measured by the violence and death any given person is likely to experience. Most war is not about the scarcity of resources. It is usually about power, the desire to dominate others, greed, and other intangibles, and of course defending oneself from such actors.

> migration

Like war, this claim is reducible to the one about limited resources, because "overpopulation" (whatever that means) per se is not a cause of anything. People generally migrate because somewhere else looks better in some way, usually because the destination is economically better developed and have better institutions. This has nothing to do with absolute resources, but with the standard of living in their home country relative to the standard elsewhere. Refugees and so on are a very small percentage of any global migration.

> resource depletion

This claim begins with a current understanding of the available resources. What we have found instead is that with more people, we have more resourcefulness and discovery. Farming is an excellent example. Innovation in agriculture tracks population growth. Today, we have more food than any of our ancestors would have dreamed of. We waste enormous amounts of food.

> hunger, water scarcity

Famine is nonexistent in the developed world and almost completely absent everywhere else. Most hunger is a matter of resource misallocation, not because there isn't enough to go around.

> we can finally see a way to a possible future without scarcity

This misunderstands scarcity, as if it were some fixed piece of pie on the table before us. According to this simplistic understanding, yeah, sure, you'll have to slice up that pie into thinner and thinner pieces until eventually everyone gets close to nothing. But this is not how things work. In practice, the more people there are, the more labor and ingenuity there is that scales non-linearly (including those caused by agglomeration effects and specialization). People will not only find new pies, but they will find things other than pies, or ways to replenish the supply in a renewable way.

> The economic engine will never be more powerful than it is now

Bold claim. History does not support it. Population contraction doesn't have to last forever and we can't know how economies will unfold.

> where growth isn't purely consumptive

I will say here that consumerism is a real problem, because it is not only wasteful in a number of ways, but it entrenches a habit of thinking that consumption is the purpose of life rather than a means to support it. Look at where the most consumption and waste occurs and you'll find it doesn't align with population density as a simplistic account of human beings would suggest.

What population contraction might achieve in the interim is that it may force a course correction. People are very stubborn and easily attached to bad habits, to the point that entire economic and political orders are reshaped and become dependent on those bad habits to function, entering into a vicious cycle that entrenches these very habits and bakes them into a common cultural sensibility of what is normative. We have refused to wean ourselves off the drug of consumerism, which I claim is one of the primary, fundamental, and underlying ideological and cultural causes and drivers of population contraction because the imperatives of consumption conflict with having children. As a result, we suffer the self-destructive consequences, and these consequences may very well force us into abandoning consumerism because it will have been made impossible to sustain. Time will tell.


I tend to agree, on the whole. LLMs force more attention toward the purpose of an app and how best to satisfy that purpose for a given audience. (Undisciplined SWEs can forget about end users and get lost in the details of some particular piece of tech.)

However, you could expect LLMs to train on existing successful apps and hardened design patterns that compose well into good UIs. In that case, you might expect the last mile polish to be the differentiating factor. However, the more marginal this last mile becomes, the more other social, political, business, etc. forces will determine which app rises and which falls. But this has always been the case, certainly in software.


To train for business and user outcomes LLMs need what they currently don't have: open insights into the real world app and business metrics.

If you meant training on UI and features of established apps then it gets even more complex, as success of B2C apps is obscured by their pricing strategies and marketing, and business models for successful B2B apps like Jira/Confluence/Office often revolve around sales, partnerships and other non-product things like that.

Any business is a set of design decision someone made, with their app just being a small subset of these.


You're right that people borrow all the time. Cultural exchange is normal. What I charitably suspect the parent was alluding to was the French (though, of course, not exclusively French) tendency to saddle so much of what they've received with French roots. If it weren't for the revolution, we might learn that Jesus himself was a Frenchman!

I would add sękacz to the list. As the wikipedia article notes, there is evidence that there were spit cakes in ancient Greece.

It's more or less the classic clash of two modernist attitudes, that of the rationalist (Chomsky) and the empiricist (Norvig). The intellectual wound this division introduces is longstanding. However, I would say Norvig has the overall advantage.

1. Norvig is correct that observation and fact/data collection are necessary for science. However, Chomsky is correct that the ultimate goal of science is to determine the principles governing something. Ergo: you need the first to do the second. The intellect abstracts from source data, but nothing is in the intellect that is not first in the senses.

2. Chomsky here is uninterested in things like speech - he only cares about the underlying syntax. But syntax - expressed and instantiated in matter - is known through speech, and probabilities presuppose an underlying determinate syntax. Ergo: a complete science of speech is end-to-end, from the "reading" or interpretation of noisy data through syntactic processing all the way through to expression.

3. Chomsky focuses heavily on internal generation. Norvig points out that interpretation is a separate, highly practical challenge. Figuring out what someone means in a noisy, ambiguous world is an exercise in prudence which involves weighing contingencies and probabilities to arrive at the most likely truth. Of course, this can only be done against a presupposed acceptance of the function of speech which is to communicate meaning and what is true (hence why lies work and why they are an abuse of speech). Probabilistic reasoning is still reasoning. It's reasoning in the face of incomplete information (against a backdrop of presuppositions) which is a component of prudential reasoning.


Science has multiple goals. One of the most important and valuable ones is to make accurate predictions.

Note that the base epistemology of science is inference to the best explanation, not "truth".


Thank goodness. What an eyesore. Of course, it does have the instrumental benefit of acting as a shibboleth.

If you think porn is harmless, then you are ignorant.

What a repressed weirdo.

Humans are never to think of sex, for it corrupts and poisons the desire to purchase and click ads. All innate desires and drives must be purified in the fires of the Black Friday Sale.

It's literally neurologically harmful, but few will see this because their morality is not rooted in anything authoritatively objective beyond goongood.

Here's a living example of the reason why AI companies censor their models. Its because people like you exist in significant numbers.

In the US, city and town centers were first hit hard mid-20th century by the Interstate Highway System which enabled suburban sprawl and big-box retailers. Later came e-commerce. When something does take the place of a local shop or restaurant, it often ends up being a chain of some kind. Add the post-pandemic shift to hybrid work and you also see a huge increase of office space vacancies.

There's also the fact that property developers, commercial landlords, and institutional lenders frequently favor corporate tenants over independent operators. Rising property values and high commercial rents also price out local, independent owners.

However, there have been some exceptions under the New Urbanism banner where you see localized revivals. Some cities (like Jersey City) cap chain occupancy of retail space to 30%. Portland and Austin use zoning rules to make commercial real estate unattractive to chains. Commercial community land trusts can also be used to freeze rent and make space more affordable for local businesses. I doubt there's a one-size-fits-all approach.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: