Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | lesuorac's commentslogin

> Two years of wasted time

Try two generations. I think it was obvious since the oil shocks that fossil fuels were not a good bedrock of the economy.


It's interesting to try to work out what the civ-style "dependency tree" of viable electric cars has been. It requires at the bare minimum high energy density light batteries, which were a spinoff of the cellphone revolution. As well as high efficiency digital power control, which while not impossible in 1970 would have been larger and heavier without modern SiC semiconductors.

Solar panels are an even more remarkable example of compounding a thousand different 1% improvements.


>Solar panels are an even more remarkable example of compounding a thousand different 1% improvements.

But they aren't really. In terms of efficiency, a 2x increase is a lot yes but the thing that has finally made them really viable is simply the cost dropping like a rock.

I don't care if I have to buy 2x as many solar panels when they cost as much as a fence post.

That cost reduction was entirely investment into production capacity. None of that couldn't have been accomplished decades ago.

That's the saddest part. If we had been adults in the 70s, we could already be done the green revolution basically. We could have seriously prevented global warming.

But a bunch of idiots rejected that and instead voted for people who doubled down on fucking up the middle east and burning liquids.


I interpreted the "1% improvements" to be exactly that effect of cost dropping like a rock (economic efficiency), not about the energy conversion efficiency.

PV entrepreneurs are the real heroes of the climate movement, IMHO. They figured out markets that would have enough demand to push forward with developing the tech. Germany's government is a major hero too, they pushed the tech forward so far at a crucial time. Then China took up the mantle.

Both supply and demand need to build together for the industry to grow. Government subsidies played a huge role in accelerating this, and will have paid for themselves so many times over. We're going to live in a world of super-cheap technology thanks to the modest tax-cut-based investments of governments the world over.

It does suck that so many powerful people were against the obvious-in-retrospect good idea of solar PV, but I'd love to focus on all the heroes that pushed through anyway and made it happen. They deserve a lot of thanks!


The real heroes are still the boots on the ground climate/green/anti-nuclear movements of multiple decades that enabled the parties to be voted into power, that set up the subsidies which gave entrepreneurs an actual market, initial funding, public research to use and planning security.

As you said, subsidies played a huge role. Look at the timeline when Germany and then Spain set up their subsidies and the following ramp up in PV production.

Sure, it was an idea at the right time, but the right time needed decades of political groundwork.

While the entrepreneurs deserve some credit, they generally got cash. The movements got massive backlash by conservatives and some got terrorism charges for protesting non-violently.


Well, perhaps, but the time for the followers in the field to push on EV manufacturing capability has been the past 5-10 years. And the US majors are all followers, not leaders. About two years ago they all put out press releases saying "we are not seeing EV sales so we are pulling back on manufacturing" meaning "we couldn't figure it out and are scared so we are abandoning our future."

With the strangle hold that these industries have on getting the government to bail them out, we are in a really bad position on the national level. We have let bad politics and weak management override good economic decision making.


idk the paper seems very suspect to me.

At the very end you can see what states they’re talking about and it’s basically just New York and California (no other state enacted a law 3 years before 2019).

California’s median income increased 17% from 2016 to 2019 (the 3 years following the law).

New york income increased 17% too.

Federally it increased 5%.

I think using some random spreadsheet as your data source just isn’t a great idea. NBER should be aware the IRS will let people have access to income data for research purposes.


What plan did people make that falls apart when Democrats aren’t in office for a couple months?

> This also puts some of the troubling reports that politicians were bringing phones into SCIFs into context…

I mean politicians are so addicted to twitter the nsa makes special phones…


Not sure which direction you're intending this. The NSA is making special phones to protect politicians, or to make it easier to ensure they can read everything?

Por que no los dos?

It's always better to protect politicians from someone else


Politicians bringing phones isn’t a scif isn’t necessarily a bad thing.

Like giving people direct access to $6.3 billion?

It was rather indirect access.

Multiple people, multiple dumb decisions.

I wonder if it would in the sense that you’d be aware you have only a million covered so maybe don’t give them direct access to 6 billion.

When the risks get written down people tend to behave differently.


> If you or your retirement is a shareholder in one of these companies, you'd rather they return $100 billion to you with boring buybacks or dividends than put it in an exciting AI investment that returns $1-$10 billion.

If you’re a retireer yeah you just want a steady dividend (or buyback).

But i mean for a 401k that won’t be spent from for 20+ years you absolutely want business to be investing into themselves. Otherwise go buy gold.


Gold doesn’t provide a dividend.

Inside a 401k dividends get reinvested, on top of that companies value income go up with inflation simply because they’re getting a similar cut of larger numbers.

That’s why long term stocks are a vastly better investment.


It's a criminal case, don't they have a presumption of legality then?

Presumption of legality pending trial is rather different from "quite obviously legal[emphasis in original]" or "definitionally legal".

"until they work their way through the courts, it's "legal"" is a much better phrasing and if the comment had stuck to that it probably wouldn't be downvoted.


I’m not so sure of that.

The recent Money Stuff newsletter had a blurb about how many anthrophic employees were quitting because you can’t use stock as collateral while working there. That condition only applies to emoloyees so once they left they can do that and rebalance their wealth out of a single position.


I did say if I had a $40M payday. Having purely paper shares isn't a payday in this context, only a liquidation event.

In any event, it'd take a number far less than $40M of liquid cash for me to drop out of the workforce forever.


I’d be happy to bet with you if I rolled my own log4j I would have never implemented jndi as a formatting argument.

Sure I shouldn’t roll my own crypto but I can write a logger…


Logging is a very complicated security area. You often get sensitive data in the logs and it gets sent across the network to monitoring servers.

Also any part of the program can send data to the logger. This means the logger can receive malicious payloads from anywhere. Maybe your logger handles ascii control characters badly?


I dunno I pretty much always wrote my own logger. Not even a shared library or anything just copypaste into next project or often don't even bother with that, just knock something out on the spot. Even before AI.

The only even slightly tricky part is like "don't mess unicode up", rest is straightforward. Sure it can be complicated with logging sinks, configurability, when to flush, monitoring and so on but in many cases you just don't need all that. You just build it whenever you do need it.


Logging is complicated for the general purpose point of view. Most people never need all of those features - which is kind of the point here. Log4j had so many features that 90% of projects didn’t need. Sure, large projects with multiple servers pointing at log receivers is complicated. But how many people were affected by the needs of probably 2 companies?

Capture log messages and write them directly to stderr? That’s easy.

This is where the LLM coded library replacements make sense. When you have non-critical code that can be easily swapped, I’m happy to let an LLM generate a logging package. If I have a need to send log messages out to a separate server for archival? I’d be a little more critical.


Imagine that you don't need monitoring servers, like possibly the majority of actual log4j deployments?

For example Minecraft uses log4j to write messages to the console and a rotating file.

Technically you can configure it to send to other places - presumably. In practice you'd be better just redirecting stdout, tailing the file, or installing a mod?


Honestly unless you insist on allowing running your software on Windows you're much better off delegating the logging to syslog over a thin wrapper. It can handle about anything except most exotic cases. This however goes against Java land portability promises and its NIH attitude so we have what we have.

Java is really really good at handling plugins. You can load additional JAR files alongside the app's own JAR file (indeed many apps are shipped as multiple JAR files) and classes from different files are integrated just as well as classes from the same file, and you can load them by name. It's pretty easy to have a command-line option that says "use this logger class instead" and make it the user's problem to supply a suitable class at startup time, and I think this is the way that makes the most sense in Java. It works on any OS and allows more detailed data exchange than just a log string; the logging plugin could even choose to take a stack trace whenever it's called, or read global data like the player's account name.

And probably more importantly, AI can write a very simple logger with no extra features than you absolutely need in 5 minutes, if that.

Can, or should?

I can’t be bothered to check the exact assembly to see if timing attacks are possible.

But crypto really is just a small thing. I’m not going to design a nuclear reactor but I’ll definitely do stuff that depends on the electricity from one. Similarly one can still do their own authentication; its not like even Apple forgot to rate limit…


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: