The Japanese countryside (which includes suburbs with some farms scattered about) makes American suburbs look pedestrian friendly by comparison. Talking from personal experience two days ago[0], I was in Nagano at night walking around unlit streets barely wide enough for one car, being constantly passed by both cyclists and cars. I felt like I needed high-vis. The closest I can think of would be the American East Coast, which also has lots of chaos layout streets, but even they usually have the money for streetlights and they don't have the severe space constraints of Japan.
Bonus points: near the end of the walk there was a two-lane road that I had to walk half a km to get to the nearest crossing for, and then half a km back. Bonus points for the one car dealership in front of my destination that was only fenced off on the back side just to spite me (or, more likely, they don't want people using it as a pedestrian cut-through). The road blocking my path was constantly jammed with cars. Somehow, Nagano invented the one-lane stroad! Also, Google Maps doesn't have a good understanding of crosswalk locations, because there was a closer one on the other side that you can't really see on foot at night.
[0] I am trying to go to as many Round1s as possible to get a title in Music Diver for playing the game in a bunch of prefectures. The game gets EOS'd at the end of the month (but only in Japan, which is unheard of). Round1 likes building giant locations in the middle of nowhere with terrible transit access. I think the one in Nagoya even had a shuttle bus from the train station - which I didn't use, lol.
> That "Vino" driver for DisplayLink driver was a clean-room reverse-engineered DisplayLink driver that was developed in part by AI and written in Rust.
It is my strongly-held opinion that, regardless of what you think about AI in general, reverse engineering projects ought to stay as far away as possible from LLM code gen as possible. They are a very easy and straightforward way for a copyright owner to claim access to their code, since basically ALL code was trained on. Unless you have hard evidence the particular bit of code you want to RE was not in the training set, you should not use an LLM to reverse-engineer or rewrite it.
This is not a moral argument; as much as I hate AI companies playing fast and loose with other people's work, the underlying arguments that make RE legal work much better if you do not look at the source code. And while US judges are straining to keep AI training fair use, that does not make the AI a copyright laundering device. A copyright owner can absolutely reach through a fair use to get to you. Think of it like if you downloaded 10 different YouTube video essays on the same movie and attempted to stitch them together into a normal copy of the underlying movie. Obviously, your use has a different (and worse) legal status than the reviews do.
With typical clean room RE you get two artificers with clean copyrightbility - a fair use spec describing the system, a new implementation. This is not legally required, but the paper trail is a good defense.
If AI writes the spec, it may have just tainted itself if that work is then used to in future training. The output is not protected by copyright, but that probably doesn’t matter. If AI writes the output, there is no protection over that either, which may or may not matter.
Ultimately, however, this is a mechanical, derivative work. It isn’t washed because no creative human expression was introduced in either phase.
If the phases are split into AI writing the spec and human writing the implementation, and the spec is determined to be infringing, the implementation is infringing. The AI spec has no judgement over what’s copyrightable expression in the original, and there’s a high likelihood it produces an unauthorized derivative.
If a human writes the spec and an AI writes the code, the output is probably clean, but also not copyrightable. This is less of a concern for open source projects written by a single maintainer, but may have effects for larger projects or proprietary projects. However, writing the spec is the harder of the two parts and what people like using AI for.
Except in the most egregious cases, AI is not going to be found to be derivative or infringing. The consequences go far beyond this particular type of situation; it is being used everywhere by the richest corporations to produce all kinds of content. They will not allow those works to suddenly have questionable provenance.
Don’t look at tech companies that don’t care about laws and price that into their costs. Pay attention to publishers and what they allow. USCO has written opinions on this and doubled and tripled down on those opinions. AI doesn’t magically erase copyright.
> They will not allow those works to suddenly have questionable provenance.
Even though many of those "richest corporations" trained their models on huge quantities of torrented ("pirated") copyrighted content and other such "stolen" data. Nothing at all questionable there... LOL
Mostly agree. It's been super helpful for personal use but I don't think it's possible to achieve a true "clean room" implementation. Anything copyright encumbered should stay away.
On the other hand, it's been great for poking at cheap IoT devices and figuring out how to interact without crappy proprietary apps.
Counter Argument, if the code is propietary and well kept, how did the AI got trained on it? Didn't the copyright holder fail to protect his IP by letting AI train on it? If the specification is only released under NDA, how could a AI be trained on it?
I think the copyright holder should prove first in court, that his super secret specs or code was effectively used for training the AI.
> Unless you have hard evidence the particular bit of code you want to RE was not in the training set, you should not use an LLM to reverse-engineer or rewrite it.
Wouldn't that be on Synaptics to prove? And with how protective they seem to be of their IP, I doubt their code is in the training set
Yes, but I'm giving the "defendant's lawyer" opinion. In reality, you can be completely tainted and still do good RE work, but proving that in a court of law will be harder.
And furthermore, the real victory is not in the courts; the real victory is staying out of the courts to begin with. If you win in court, you still lost huge sums of money. And a lot of staying out of court boils down to restricting one's conduct to things a plaintiff's lawyer would counsel against suing for. Hence why most legal opinions in the FOSS space are unusually conservative (while still, occasionally, just being completely off-base).
But when LLM is used to create an image or video, the user usually consider the LLM as a copyright laundering device and claim full copyright on the produced image or video, regardless of what the licenses of the training set would be. Why coders don't get the privilege of that?
No, you cannot launder copyright through an LLM. It's the same for both images, video, and code; and that question is independent of whether or not it's legal to train the LLM on copyrighted data. The LLM training gets to be fair use, but fair use is not transitive. Infringement reaches through the LLM to get at any outputs which are substantially similar to the original no matter how many fair uses you put in the middle.
Fun fact: the FAT32 limit - which, by the way, was literally just added by Dave Plummer because he thought anything larger would have too much wasted slack space - made its way into the SD card spec. It is perfectly valid behavior for a device to refuse to read a >32GB card with a FAT32 file system, or a <32GB card with exFAT, or a card with multiple partitions, etc. None of those are actually SD cards as they are formatted.
In practice, nobody in their right mind would design a device's firmware that poorly, unless they were deliberately trying to force users to stay within the bounds of the device's QA test procedures. I don't have any examples of this. There are devices that will misbehave with such a card, however: for example, the Nintendo 3DS will happily use an oversize FAT32 card, but the Data Management screen will take way longer to load for some reason.
Also fun fact: the first time you plug a correctly formatted SDXC into a Nintendo Switch, it "downloads an update" and restarts. Presumably Nintendo wanted to save money on exFAT licensing fees so Nintendo is only paying for each unit that actually uses the exFAT library?
3- Yup, nailed it, same reason WMA and Flash require "activation" on the PSP and why newer MPEG codecs like H.264 and AAC require an "optional media update" on the Xbox 360
2- The slowdown usually comes from scanning the FAT to count the free space, with the PSP being notorious for this
Another related point is the varying support for the "semi-official" 64K cluster size, which gives a curious effect on the 3DS: in GBA mode (officially only used for 10 games only distributed as compensation to those who bought the original model at full launch price), a strip of "junk" (coming from the virtualized GBA's VRAM, IIRC it's just wraparound) will be shown at the bottom of the screen...
I fully expect a Louis Rossmann video by tomorrow detailing every privacy fuck-up Ford has done in the last 3 months and how this promise is really just a promise to take away ownership in the name of protection.
Context for Europeans: the US mobile market was basically total vendor lock-in hell up until the mid-2010s. There were only two carriers (AT&T and T-Mobile[1]) you could bring-your-own-phone with, the other two (Verizon and Sprint[2]) only allowed the phones they sold on their network. Phone service and plans were bundled together.
In fact, one of the critical arguments Apple made as to why they weren't a monopoly was "Sure, we demand 30% - but the phone company monopoly we made obsolete used to charge 70%!" Mobile app stores on other platforms were absolutely hell.
One extra wrinkle of this is that Apple didn't actually partner with AT&T, they partnered with Cingular, the smallest national[0] carrier, who only agreed to let Apple ship an unmolested device because they got 5 year exclusivity. Then Cingular got bought out by AT&T. AFAIK AT&T didn't want the iPhone, they wanted the AT&T (insert terrible name here) Powered by AppleTM, with like 20 AT&T services preinstalled and unremovable. 'Cause that's literally what happened with the first Samsung Galaxy phone, every carrier gave it a different name and their own bloatware.
And yes, this hatred was mutual: the 5 year exclusivity meant iPhones were shackled to a terrible network in the US, and there was a significant amount of effort put into baseband jailbreaking just so people could violate Apple's exclusivity agreement and use their iPhone with their choice of carrier - which, to be clear, meant "use it on T-Mobile".
Also, while I'm giving a lot of credit to Apple, the thing that really broke the vendor lock-in was:
1. Google deliberately bidding up spectrum to trigger an FCC open-access pledge on LTE bands, which forced Verizon to allow third-party networks
2. Qualcomm giving up on UMB, forcing Verizon to adopt LTE, and by extension, SIM cards[3]
3. Clearwire / Sprint's WiMAX service totally failing, also forcing Sprint to adopt LTE and SIMs
[0] The US has a few "regional" carriers like US Cellular that only operate towers in some markets and license spectrum outside of that area.
[1] Yes, they were owned by Deutsche Telekom at one point
[2] At one point owned by Softbank, now owned by T-Mobile
[3] Strictly speaking, the SIM card spec includes CDMA/3GPP2[4] support, but the largest CDMA market was the US, and any carrier that wanted to support foreign phones used GSM/3GPP track standards
[4] Yes, Qualcomm was really that petty that they named their 3G standards body "3G 2"
> Strictly speaking, the SIM card spec includes CDMA/3GPP2
I think the only market that had R-UIM cards (CDMA SIM cards) was Japan, but even with those you couldn't use non-carrier phones since they had all the configuration hard-coded into the devices. It did allow roaming abroad by putting your card into a foreign GSM phone you'd rent at the airport.
The NYPD has their own terrorism and counterintelligence divisions. They are pretty much an FBI governed at a city level (minus all of the cool forensics science).
I wouldn't put it beyond NYPD (in theory) except IIRC the NYPD actually drives him around in their SUVs and he has an NYPD team that does his personal security.
You're describing Russia, not America. In America voter turnout is at record highs, people are protesting loud and visibly, and "Flock camera" is a cultural byword for oppressive dragnet surveillance.
I don't think people have connected the dots between Flock and Ring yet, but it's only a matter of time.
from the article, it seems they only got charged bc they filmed the act and published it? so it wasn't any hype and they could actually easily vote illegaly?
Funny you mention superhero films, because that's also what killed the American comic book industry.
If you go to a bookstore and ask someone not particularly familiar with the industry to go find a comic book; you are very likely to have them hand a manga or manhwa tankobon[0] back to you. Trade paperbacks[1] are sold in bookstores, but the western comics section will be a small fraction of the manga & manhwa section.
The root cause of this is that in the 80s, comic book companies - say it with me, folks! - underwent massive amounts of consolidation to chase efficiencies at the expense of their ability to innovate and their ability to withstand systemic shocks. The particularized version of this is that the comic book companies ceded their cultural ubiquity to milk comics fans dry.
The efficiency being chased was "direct sales" - i.e. selling comic books to dedicated comic book stores, rather than in mass-market areas like grocery stores. A key thing to note is that the mass-market sellers retain the right to return unsold inventory and get a refund[3], but comic book stores bought on "all sales final" terms. What this ultimately meant was that comic book publishers didn't have to worry about the quality of the books anymore.
There was a long-standing cultural stigma in the US that comic books are for children. This was itself downstream of a push to censor comics that was partially successful and resulted in the Comics Code stunting the growth of the medium[4] in the US. Eventually, thanks to - among other things, Marvel wanting to publish an anti-drug PSA in a Spiderman book - the Comics Code Authority lost their power and we were able to publish comic books for adults in the US again.
Anyway, Alan Moore wrote a really gritty Batman book and kicked off a rush to capitalize on a growing adult comics wave. This, along with a bunch of people realizing that old #1s of comics published during Baby Boomers' childhoods[5] were super rare kicked off a huge speculator wave. The comics publishers - who at this point were just DC and Marvel - saw the dollar signs and started flooding the market with slop to meet the demands of speculators who were buying #1s just because they were a #1.
This continued until it could not. In an act of supreme hubris, Marvel decided to buy a comics distributor in pursuit of extreme vertical integration and wound up completely destroying their ability to correctly print a book. Then they went bankrupt, got bought out by a corporate raider, and sold their movie rights to anyone who had a buck. DC wound up in the hands of WB (lol), Marvel became a Disney property.
Yes, the 2010s comic book movie wave was directly caused by the 1990s comic book industry's death. And, for that matter, the exact same extreme consolidation that killed comics is coming for Hollywood. Disney bought Fox, Larry Ellison bought Paramount and WB and merged them into Skydance. The entirety of America's cultural industries are looking more and more like DC and Marvel fighting over the ashes of a culturally dead country.
[0] Japanese for trade paperback[1][2].
[1] English for tankobon[0].
[2] Okay, this term actually has two meanings:
1. A paperback that is not printed to mass-market standard. Publishers don't really do mass-market paperbacks anymore, even manga that is printed to mass-market sizes isn't priced like the mass-market books they are in Japan.
2. Anthologies of previously-published comic books - floppies in the western case, massive pulp-fiction magazine bricks in the Japanese case. Sometimes they're not even in paperback!
[3] Which, funnily enough doesn't even usually require returning the whole book, just the covers.
[4] The shit the Comics Code did to US comics makes the censorship changes in the 4Kids dubbed version of One Piece look liberating in comparison.
>comic book companies - say it with me, folks! - underwent massive amounts of consolidation to chase efficiencies at the expense of their ability to innovate
How is a very large operation more efficient at producing comic-book sales than a smaller operation?
Why cannot new comic-book companies easily be created? One guess I have is that most of the profit potential is in sales of new stories about characters that are well-known, like Superman or the Incredible Hulk, and copyright law prevents new entrants from selling those stories.
DC and Marvel are more efficient at shutting out competition, not producing more books. The short answer to "why cannot new comic-book companies easily be created" is that it has nothing to do with copyright and everything to do with the fact that nobody wants to be in direct competition with DC or Marvel.
In the late 80s, you had three different forces trying to push comic books (back) into the mainstream: speculators, graphic novels, and manga. I primarily covered the speculator boom because it's what ultimately killed off the big two, but concurrent with that was an indie comics boom. A lot of artists fled DC and Marvel the moment it was viable for them to do so and the indie companies they'd founded were actually giving the big two a run for their money for a bit. Some of those companies are still around, too!
The main problem is that indie comics didn't increase the standing of the genre. They were doing a lot of the same superhero comics as the big two, just with better terms for artists. As a result a lot of them wound up getting hurt by the big two going under rather than being able to capitalize on it.
There actually was a push to increase the range of comics being sold, too; that's what ultimately gave us the term "graphic novel". The problem is mainly that there isn't a hard distinction between "comic book" and "graphic novel". The latter was supposed to be for people why didn't want their work to carry the stigma of "comic book", but it ultimately wound up being used by the comic book companies anyway[3]. Still, there were some successful graphic novels, like Bone[0]; the main problem is just that it didn't usher in a wave of mass-market non-superhero comics. If you want to establish a medium you really need to carpet-bomb the entire market with it.
Ironically, part of the reason why manga got huge was because they had a decade head-start on this exact trend. In the 70s there were a lot of manga artists who called their books "gekiga" or "komaga"[1] and that spawned the entire seinen and josei demographic of modern manga. When companies started translating manga for the US they had lots of material to work with that western comics companies would never touch. Tokyopop cut their teeth with imports of girls comics, a thing that pretty much didn't exist in the US at all!
There's also webcomics - but that's not competition for comic books; it's competition for syndicated newspaper comic strips. (Japan calls these 4-koma.) One of the most irksome features of western comics is how much unnecessary fragmentation there is:
- A "comic book" is specifically a male-oriented superhero book sold in individual weekly volumes, which is predominantly but not entirely monopolized by DC & Marvel's rotting corpses
- A "comic strip" is any general audience comic distributed on a daily basis in newspapers, which is monopolized by Andrews McMeel Syndication
- A "webcomic" is a self-published[4] serialized work distributed online, usually for free, at high frequency (daily updates are common) and either in strip or book form.
- A "graphic novel" is a catch-all for any comic book that doesn't fit the comic book bucket, but sometimes it just means a collection of comic book volumes
- And "manga" is for import books from Japan (and "manhwa" for Korean books), which are far wider in scope purely because Japan's publishers had their shit together and America's didn't[2].
This fragmentation gets so particularly dumb that there is actually a thing called "original English-language manga", which specifically means any comic written in English but produced to manga standard. Because westerners who wanted to write comics that weren't superhero books dropped the graphic novel designation and started apeing the constraints of Japanese works. Oh, and this term also covers Megatokyo, a webcomic produced in a weird 2-by-2-koma standard specifically designed to split the difference between western comic strips and Japanese 4-koma. Confused yet?
If you want a good example of why categorization and taxonomy are dismal sciences, just point to this comment.
With that out of the way, you probably have also guessed that I don't think copyright plays a role in this. For the most part, it doesn't. But I do also want to point out that the big mistake a lot of copyright abolitionists make is assuming that copyright works like patents; i.e. that if DC owns Batman, then nobody is allowed to write stories about athletic rich guys moonlighting as superheroes. It's important to note, however, that copyright is actually really, really fucking narrow.
Fans chafe under copyright because fans want to do tributes and other things that don't strictly speaking step on the original creators' toes but are still legally problematic. But if you abandon the hope of, say, writing your own take on an existing superhero, you can actually still do a lot while not technically infringing. Toby Fox wrote two games totally aping the style of EarthBound[5], to the point where he's joked about how if MOTHER 3 came to the west, people would find out how unoriginal he is, and Nintendo's never bothered to sue him. Because there's nothing to sue over unless you're outright making a clone. Nothing stops you from writing your own superhero books aside from the fact that DC & Marvel have that particular corner of comics completely locked down and enshittified.
[0] Never underestimate the power of Scholastic to pump books into US schools.
[1] These literally mean "dramatic pictures" and "panel pictures" but I'd draw cultural parallels to "graphic novels" and "sequential art", respectively.
[2] There is an alternate universe where United Feature Syndicate realizes they can sell their own magazine full of weekly long-format comics and parallel reinvents Shonen Jump.
[3] Specifically as a synonym for trade paperbacks. No, I don't mean "upmarket paperback books", in comic books "trade paperback" specifically means "collections of previously published work" and sometimes they aren't even paperback. Manga calls these tankobons and most manga you buy in a store will be tankobons.
[4] Japanese: doujin
[5] Which itself aped the art style of the comic strip Peanuts, and was also aped by South Park
Bonus points: near the end of the walk there was a two-lane road that I had to walk half a km to get to the nearest crossing for, and then half a km back. Bonus points for the one car dealership in front of my destination that was only fenced off on the back side just to spite me (or, more likely, they don't want people using it as a pedestrian cut-through). The road blocking my path was constantly jammed with cars. Somehow, Nagano invented the one-lane stroad! Also, Google Maps doesn't have a good understanding of crosswalk locations, because there was a closer one on the other side that you can't really see on foot at night.
[0] I am trying to go to as many Round1s as possible to get a title in Music Diver for playing the game in a bunch of prefectures. The game gets EOS'd at the end of the month (but only in Japan, which is unheard of). Round1 likes building giant locations in the middle of nowhere with terrible transit access. I think the one in Nagoya even had a shuttle bus from the train station - which I didn't use, lol.
reply