This is true of a whole lot of stuff. Many special offers are loss leaders that largely rely on human behavior to make up for the losses, like a credit card that gives you $500 cash back if you spend $2500 in the first 3 months. This only works when a fair number of the humans stick with that card long term, if there are agents running around creditmaxxing then the offers don't work any more.
If you are an inveterate optimizer, it works to your advantage. If you are not, well I guess you just don't care. So net net, yes we prefer this equilibrium.
I think there's a fourth class (to the third class another commenter mentions) that you're missing here, which the credit card example makes obvious: people who fall for the "human behavior" trick the company aims for, and are exploited or hurt by those practices.
Credit card case: people prone to overspending and falling in a debt loop, lured in by $500 due to being poor or in precarious situation (perhaps from falling in similar traps in the past), and who end up keeping the card long-term, as the 3-months spending requirement ends up trapping them in the CC spending loop.
This equilibrium you describe, is in many cases built on preying on the weakest and most vulnerable, so no, I don't think it's fine.
You're forgetting about the third class of person, who thinks it's not worth their time, and, frankly, distasteful to spend that much time and effort optimizing, but also finds the offers presented to those that aren't optimizing insultingly poor value.
That's the kind of person that will not download the app to get the coupons and hunt for the good deals at Safeway, but will also not accept the exceptionally high sticker price, and instead will go shop at another store.
Perfect, if the business model is to scam you out of money because you don't use a service, then it should go away, regardless of the few people getting 'benefit'.
Index funds are the only way to guarantee that you will out perform the "average" investor. Why? Because the median investor underperforms the market, hence, buy the market and you are better than median.
I feel pretty safe that if the AI stuff underperforms for whatever reason, that excess capital will flow back into boring things like Walmart. Or if AI eats the world, well, owning an index means I still have a piece of the pie.
> owning an index means I still have a piece of the pie
You're assuming within-pie transfers.
US equities in 1990's were 40% of the world market; now they are 80%. It's pretty easy to imagine them going back to 40% or less as capital moves elsewhere. But owning indexes across currencies and markets is another layer of risk.
If your retirement savings went down by 20% and you had to put off retirement by 5 years, but then you died after 5 years, you've lost your retirement!
If you have advance knowledge of the future, you wouldn't need retirement savings either. you'd simply get on kalshi and make all of your money sports betting.
> the $15 trillion held in private sector workers’ retirement accounts is now, for the first time in history, available to be invested in private funds.
The article acts as if this means there are $15T of funds that Coreweave can tap into at will, but all this means is that 401k plan admins are allowed to add private equity to the list of options in 401ks. I expect quite a small percent of plan participants to actually make use of said options even IF they are added, unless plan admins start changing the default investments to include them. Not saying that can't happen, but it hasn't happened yet.
People always say, "maximizing shareholder value" like it's obviously a bad thing, when actually every retiree and prospective retiree is a shareholder.
That's such a viciously poor-faith strawman that one has to wonder if you're trolling. In case you're not, you're probably beyond saving if you genuinely believe something like this, but I'll bite anyway.
When people say "maximizing shareholder value" they are obviously not referring to people who have worked their entire lives to save up some money to live on in their elderly years, so they're not thrown out onto the streets after their decades of service.
Not whatever 'ackchyually' technically correct definition you're referring to by 'shareholder', equating these humans with those who just want more money for the sake of more money, and who will stop at nothing to devise plots to extract it from the rest of us, enshittifying anything they need to in the process and making the world a worse place for the rest of us.
reply