Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | Jerrrry's comments login

Hard to think anyone who can't solve a captcha is something other than a parasite.

Parasites can solve captchas, people with accessibility issues and the poorest of people are the one being locked out.


Captchas are not only for stopping people with disabilities anymore. They also stop people using non-approved browsers, people trying to stay anonymous, people coming from the wrong geographic areas...

If the AI has access to a credit card, but Mgulu from Nigeria doesn't, then the system doing the filtering might evolve to filter out the 'undesirable' rather than the non human.

It isn’t just those with accessibility problems that get stuck. Some are stupidly difficult- I’ve given up on one in recent times.

Maybe my disability is CAPTCHA blindness.


Why are you explicitly saying "human"...

I like this definition for a "proto"-intelligent trait.


good compression = pattern eventually

maximum compression = indelineable from random data


  >Okay to be clear, I've written a paper on exactly this topic which will be announced in a week or so. So you won't find anything on the subject yet, haha. But I use almost exactly this example.

I would use Floating Point arithmetic as the example/analogy: one trades off accuracy/precision for exactness/correct-ness when in the extremities. Answers near the more granular representations will be only be able to represented by their nearest value. If this is forsee-able, the floating point implementation can be adjusted to change where the floating point's "extremities'" are.

I used the above analogy and the following when articulating the magnitude of near-lossless-ness that large LLM's have managed to attain, especially when all of the humanities corpus is compressed into a USB flash drive; the Kolmogorov complexity re-mitted/captured is similar to a master-piece like the Mona Lisa having to be described in X many brush-strokes to achieve Y amount of fidelity.


Its human users can infer it, the other uses can't, yet.

Well said, "Better unsaid."

Shame is the best moderator.

Also, HN's miscellaneous audience of rule breakers benefit from having some rules be better off not stated. Especially this one, as it is almost as good as a "Gun-Free Zone"


That and cultural specificities make furry costumes an intelligencia budget item

How do you know you're not in a local minima?

the whole one digs can be deepened similar to Zeno's Paradox by procrastinating a little bit with bad small distractions allowing time to exponentiate small problems into untractable ones.

It is a little reductionary, almost akin to telling depressed people to have a slightly better today than the day before; not necessarily wrong but just rephrasing the problem.

It is correct, but only by definition.


You should also have another loop in your head, along with the one asking "what's the smallest thing I can do right now," asking "what's the most important and daunting thing that needs to be done right now."

That actually reveals another procrastination tip I forgot to mention: do the hardest stuff first. "Eat the frog" is what I tell myself.

Also, that's not quite how Zeno's paradox works.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: