Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

full disclosure. i'm one of the co-founders of crate :)

In December 2010 we found about Elasticsearch and were truly amazed by it's simplicity, speed and elegance. We built our service and consultancy business around it.

In 2011 we've built some of the largest ES applications at that time (6TB, 120node cluster, http://2012.berlinbuzzwords.de/sessions/you-know-search-quer...) and started to develop a set of plugins, such as the in-out-plugin to allow distributed dump/restore.

With this background - and the mission to build a datastore that is as easy to use and administer as Elasticsearch we founded in 2013 Crate and raised some Seed money. Since that we're working hard to make this vision become true. We're often confronted with the results of the so-called Jepsen-Test (https://aphyr.com/posts/317-call-me-maybe-elasticsearch) that Aphyr published in 2014. Don't forget: Lucene, Netty, Elasticsearch, Crate - all are Open Source products (APL) and rely on all kinds of contributions - such as this analysis! No matter be it bad news or good news. We can only improve based on hard testing and feedback. However, this caused a lot of rumblings in the Elasticsearch ecosystem and the reaction of Elasticsearch was exemplary:

1) explain the reasoning and make an official statement: https://www.elastic.co/blog/resiliency-elasticsearch/

2) list all the issues and hunt them down. one by one: http://www.elastic.co/guide/en/elasticsearch/resiliency/curr... (and add new ones as they occur).

3) stay in contact with the community that reported the issues: https://twitter.com/aphyr/status/525712547911974913

All that being said. We see many people using Crate as primary store (and of course backing up their data) but we also see people that don't put that much trust in a younger database and keep all their primary data in another location and sync/index to Crate.

ALWAYS make backups (COPY TO / COPY FROM), make sure you have replicas, and most important configure minimum_master_nodes correctly to avoid split brain.

At Crate we stand on the shoulders of these great Open Source project, try to be as good citizens as possible and focus mainly on our Query engine (Analyzer, Planner, Execution Engine).

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact