Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login
Medium abuses nofollow (captnemo.in)
6 points by captn3m0 on April 6, 2015 | hide | past | favorite | 8 comments



What a horrible article. They are not "abusing" anything; it's their site and it's common for large sites to deploy nofollow. It discourages spammers from creating lots of outbound links for seo purposes and weakens the overall value of outbound links from their site.

"Medium hosts 300,000 articles published by half a million users, and yet none of these links back to external website, because of something called "rel=nofollow". - what are you talking about? That's not how it works at all. The hyperlinks still operate just fine.


Yes, I understand what nofollow is for. The links do work, but they are not followed by search engines, which means content is not credited, as it should be.

Also, the title was styled after a similar blog post about StackOverflow (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4774470).


Why should it be? They own the site, so they don't need to give up their link juice to every legit person and every spammer who wants to link out from their site.

Your own link just stated that they enacted nofollow due to abuse and because Google was punishing them by removing pages all together. Then you go on and call them "abusers" for protecting their content. wat.


I'm not saying that removing nofollow for medium is the right solution. That would be inviting a horde of spammers on to the site.

However, there can be better solutions (such as the ones by StackOverflow). Content quality (which can be measured by medium) to allow good quality content have outbound links would be another.

A simple start would be to have a whitelist of domains that can be considered authoritative (as suggested in the linked tweet).

Yes, this is a hard problem, but it needs to be solved.


No, it doesn't. Go buy your own domain.

off the top of my head, digitalpoint is a popular forum that has always operated with nofollow and I imagine many other sites do, as well.


If they removed nofollow it would influence companies with huge SEO budgets to start working on there at putting out discreet promotional content. You would see services offering links on Medium etc..


I agree that it would be nice if Medium could find a way to allow search engines to do their magic without inviting a deluge of promotional content.

That being said, this article approaches the problem in a very confrontational and unappealing way...


You might be right. I should tone it down.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: