Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

1) Exceptions are not a solution and are in fact no different than error codes in this case. If your init system throws an exception, what does that mean? It means your computer goes down.

The actual solution here is Maybe / Optionals (depending on your language of choice) as Haskell and Rust and Scala have. These would require the caller to unwrap the result, and thus make this bug actually impossible. The "returns -1" really is the equivalent of a null pointer exception which is an issue that is solved by Options not by Exceptions. Exceptions are definitely not a solution in any way.

2) I didn't see the "too complicated" between the lines bit. However, you're wrong about having to be root to trigger this. The watch, if you missed it, was on all of /etc. There are many folders in /etc which are not root owned. Furthermore, just because you have to be root to cause unexpected behavior means little in this case. Sure, this won't likely be exploited maliciously to take down a box and if that were the fear it wouldn't matter. That wasn't the concern though. The concern is this happening by accident. Even if a program is running as root, it shouldn't be able to bring down the box purely by accident.

3) A patch that prevents an init system from crashing at the expense of missing a file change (which was under /etc and quite possibly not even relevant to the init system) isn't that bad. Take it and add an issue to improve it (e.g. by directory walking as suggested). Seriously, your init system crashing because a few programs decide to write a few hundred default config files to /etc, is dumb.

For an easy example: using ansible-galaxy to fetch a role/playbook, by default (at least in the past) installed in /etc/ansible/roles/$ROLENAME. These roles can be on the order of several thousand files. The init system need not care about this at all.

The most important point here, though, is that Exceptions are absolutely not the solution here and, in fact, we've known that exceptions are fundamentally wrong for the last 40 years and yet people still learn them as part of Java and think they're good design.

Guidelines | FAQ | Support | API | Security | Lists | Bookmarklet | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact