Hacker News new | comments | show | ask | jobs | submit login

How far does it go? Would you say the same about a nazi or KKK member?

The Chicago police protected neo-nazis when they marched in Skokie--at a time when there were residents there who still had tattoos from the camps.

So, yeah, we should strive to protect freedom of speech and be tolerant, even when people are shitbags.

Yes, I would expect the government to protect his right to free speech and political opinion. However, that doesn't mean anyone has to respect his opinions, much like neo-nazis don't garner much respect in public opinion (but the police will work to protect their safety when expressing their opinion).

Freedom of speech is for both sides, for CEOs who are anti-gay and for any employee who ask him to leave for being so.

Godwin's Law in 16 minutes. Not bad.

That's not a Godwin. Nazis were/are well known to promote hate based on differences between people and promote laws to keep certain groups oppressed. It's a perfectly valid comparison.

It did sound like a comparision, my bad.

Saying "Godwin's Law" is not an argument, FFS

Guidelines | FAQ | Support | API | Security | Lists | Bookmarklet | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact