Hacker News new | comments | show | ask | jobs | submit login

I dont wish to be, umm, mean. But I know of at least 3 companies (ours included) that could run this in a few minutes.

this is my code (using mighty, our python based cluster service):

  import mighty

  word_generator = mighty.word_generator("wordlist",(mighty.APPEND_NUMERALS,5))
  phrase_generator = mighty.word_concentate(word_generator,' ')

  job = mighty.match_to_hash('PROVIDEDHASH',mighty.SHA1,phrase_generator.iterate_all)
  job.priority = mighty.CRITICAL
  mighty.submit_job(job)
Done. Takes about 5 minutes (I wont enter - it's not fair).

EDIT: added CRITICAL as the priority or it takes longer :)

EDIT: ok so the code is a bit the wrong side of the tracks. It wouldnt take long to refactor it :)




This isn't actually correct, is it? Assuming an average 6-letter word length, there are about 10^67 valid combinations that your iterate_all() can go through: (((2^6) * 1000) ^ 12) * (94 ^ 5) = 3.5 * 10^67

Since this is much larger than the total hash space (2^160 = 10^48), you can hope you'll get a collision after the number of tries equal to half of the hashspace (10^48 / 2). That means you'll have to generate 10^47 hashes. At 5 minutes of runtime, you'll have to generate 10^45 hashes per second.

Bottom line: if you can run this on 200,000 cores, you'll have to generate 10^40 hashes per second per core, and that seems impossible to me.


Weeell we have 20,023 computers (that fluctuates a tad). That's probably about 30,000 cores in the end.

I cant iterate the whole lot - but I can cover a substantial portion more of the keyspace in 5 mins than most could in the 30hrs. I bet 5 minutes will easily get me damn close :)


I'm seeing about 1 million hashes per second on a single core. So, you can do about 10^11 hashes per second on 30,000 cores. At that rate, it will only take you 10^48 years to cover the keyspace.

You won't even cover a fraction of a percent of the keyspace before the sun burns out.


I think it unlikely you have a compute cluster that can generate 3.3 million, billion, billion, billion SHA1 hashes per second (edit: and that assumes not adding the random 5 characters to the end). The actual contest will have a word list of a thousand words.

Also, (a) you're allowed to permute case of letters, exploding the search space even more, which is handy because (b) I presume the target sha1 will come from words not on the word list, making an exact match unlikely (hence score based on hamming distance).




Applications are open for YC Summer 2018

Guidelines | FAQ | Support | API | Security | Lists | Bookmarklet | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: