Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

As the creator of unirest-java, I will be happy if you want to contribute to the project.

If you have any ideas (I have little experience in building libs like this, but will definitely learn): currently I need a streaming JSON decoder (which handles base64-encoded blobs as some values, so values need to be stream-decoded too, possibly with another custom step). So far this lib (and nearly every other) seems to assume a pre-defined set of classes, and/or that you want the full response before acting on it (no streaming access).

Before you ask, I don't control the response, so I can't do something more sane :) And it's on Android, so memory can be quite restrictive, and GC hurts a lot with so much allocation.

I don't see an easy way to plug those requirements into this library. Superficially it seems I can modify/add something inherited from BaseRequest and add my own HttpClientHelper.requestAsync-style method to do this, but it's yet another library that doesn't quite allow this kind of thing natively.

But by the time I've understood and made those changes, I might as well just do it all by hand in that particular request. This is especially true since my code has to be read and understood by others I work with, and it makes updating the Unirest library a much more error-prone event that might leave people in the lurch since they didn't write the extension. There's no real happy solution.


Not that I really think it should easily handle my case - it looks really nice to use, and it's probably not worth it to you / most people, and my case is weird and might ruin everything to properly support. But it's a minor thing that annoys me a bit and makes me want to make my own (minor annoyances are a major motivator for my personal projects). Before I can make anything decent though I need to see a few more ways to do things, try a few crazy architectures, etc. This has helped remind me what it can look like at least, and the code looks surprisingly clean underneath. Definitely a worthwhile read :)

Guidelines | FAQ | Support | API | Security | Lists | Bookmarklet | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact