Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Okay, maybe it says something about me as a person, but I can't quite understand that as a reason. I mean, I understand why people volunteer at a soup kitchen, but not this. Why would somebody go out to protect some unknown people on the internet from the mistakes of a for-profit company that is probably screwing over those same people, and themselves, in 100 other ways? I'm not anti-corporations or anything like that, but I do recognize that they are looking out for themselves (as is their right), I don't understand why everybody who deals with them in some way or another doesn't do that, too.

Plus - the fastest way of getting a vuln fixed is by having it out in the open, hopefully in a way so public that the affected companies' PR department needs to get involved. That at least incentivizes them to proactively look for issues, rather than set up a security@ alias, hire some well-known names from the scene to fix issues send there and calm the pocket protector crowd when shit hits the fan (cough, ctrl-f this page for examples), and pay reporters a fraction of the market value of their work (if anything at all).




I suspect that for most security bugfinders, the people they are protecting are not the giant corporations, it's the grandmas whose computers will be pwned within about a day or two of a 0-day hitting the open market. The number of people who read security blogs is miniscule compared to the number of people who use products with security flaws. You are not going to convince most of the latter to read vulnerabilities, but they're the ones who get hurt when a bug makes it out into the open unreported.


* I do recognize that they are looking out for themselves (as is their right), I don't understand why everybody who deals with them in some way or another doesn't do that*

But in what way is responsible disclosure not looking out for oneself? Even if you don't care about the potential reputation hit of releasing non-responsibly, how are you better of by not waiting a couple of weeks or so?


It's a computerized version of the soup kitchen.

Instead of handing out soup to a hundred folks, they help the entire internet.

Good deeds don't really need justification.


this is more like volunteering to clean up broken glass from your local park than volunteering at a soup kitchen. the internet is a shared public space, and some of the inhabitants are better equipped to help improve it for everyone.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: