Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Do you have a good list of what harm LGBT parents are causing children, preferably with references?



I don't think there's clear definition of what "harm" means, and for sure studies themselves can are are and will be hotly debated.


"No, I'm just talking out of my ass" would have been a sufficient answer, instead of your evasive wordplay.


You explicitly said that a father could not replace a mother for sure, and now you are simply saying that the whole subject is "hotly debated"? If a child is worse off without having a mother or a father and does not get one of them, then such a suboptimal childhood (by your words) is definitely harmful, without having to resort to exotic interpretations of the word "harm".

You had no problem denouncing that this should have anything to with (gender) equality, but as soon as the focus naturally shifts to a more touchy subject (gay peoples right to raise children at all) you chicken out and resort to platitudes.


For sure means I am certain. May I? Is there anything social that is not debated?

I just learned today about a gay couple that adopted a child and used him for child-porn and pedophile sex. Would I bring that up as an argument? No. Have I? No. It's not.

People DO have different views on what harming a child means. It's not a platitude at all.


> May I? Is there anything social that is not debated?

What does this even mean? Gender equality and LGBT rights are debated, you chose to comment on the former and not on the latter.

> I just learned today about a gay couple that adopted a child and used him for child-porn and pedophile sex. Would I bring that up as an argument? No. Have I? No. It's not.

And so what? You've shown yourself to be above using specific incidents to condemn a whole group of people? If you have information that pertains to the claim that a child needs both a mother and a father, you can use that even if it does not include homosexual parents, since you can extrapolate from that information. After all, you said yourself that "I am certain", so this rock-hard belief is most likely backed by something other than your own experiences.

And if you don't have anything to back it up, just say so instead of just saying that "they exist, and are kind of hotly debated". I mean, what kind of answer or insight is that? It's just a platitude.

> People DO have different views on what harming a child means. It's not a platitude at all.

Oh come on, having a substandard childhood is definitely harmful compared to having a normal one. There's no need to conjure up images of violence or something traumatic when it comes to the word "harm". You were simply dodging the question.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: