Hacker News new | comments | show | ask | jobs | submit login

I'm done with LinkedIn.

I've been on the fence about it for a year now. I get more recruiter spam than value.

I'm also a bit too old for the schadenfreude that accompanies news of my overpaid friends getting canned. I'm running my own race these days and I've never been happier since I stopped comparing my lot in life to the few lucky SOBs I know that survived the cull of sub-prime.

I think a better strategy is (1) your own domain and/or (2) a site on github with actual code to validate* your talents.

*I hate those "Joe Schmo supported you skill in [insert banal technical skill here]" messages. I once put down C++ because I had been working with it for a couple years. Then, I thought better (I would not take a C++ programming job. Period. Hate that language.) and took it off. Next thing I know, I've got coworkers supporting my C++ acumen and LinkedIn trying to push it back on my profile. Ugh. I call that invasive feature creep.

On top of that, they seem to leave the backdoor open a bit too much for a company with $20b market cap.

LinkedIn's value is not centered around your personal profile - it's about the other people that are linked to you and will always have an up-to-date CV/contact details for you.

It is a self-updating rolodex, Outlook Contacts list, phone book, whateveryouwanttocallit.

I really don't want to bookmark 300+ individual pages that all have different creative layouts, get moved, etc. My LinkedIn profile stays up-to-date, you update yours, that's the implicit deal. And we all profit from it. all being defined as a western work related group, english spoken. this is not facebook. Link your gitbub repo from there, absolutely, good idea, but having LinkedIn as your standardized contact info is very valuable.

is LinkedIn managed in a bad way? sure. But for some reason the modern business world has chosen it to focus on it. Xing and other local players never grew enough. the benefits of starting out it in the US. all the surrounding crap they're building is fluff, their core feature is being a global rolodex. would love to slap sense into their product management team.

Thus I've never had more than minimal info on my linkedin profile.

As of this writing, I only have my undergrad and grad school names listed. I don't think I even have my areas of study on there.

Works perfectly as a rolodex.

I don't even have that; just my name and the other required stuff. I still accept connections in the hope that I will join one day, but that seems more and more unlikely.

linked-in's value is also linked somewhat to your curiosity to check who has viewed your profile.

This feature was interesting, but on the other hand it affected my own ability to look at other people's profiles - because, no, I don't want people to know that I looked at their profile.

Which is why I completely disabled it. Having the ability to see who viewed your profile seemed cool at first, but then again, it's useless and the downsides are great.

Quick link for the setting to browse anonymously: https://www.linkedin.com/settings/?tab=profile&modal=nsettin...

+1 to pinaceae

You already upvoted him. No need to comment to that effect.

>I think a better strategy is (1) your own domain and/or (2) a site on github with actual code to validate* your talents.

That's because their target audience is not restricted to the tech savvy. Not everyone knows how to host and maintain their own domain. Not everyone uses github or know what git is.

This was basically why LinkedIn came into fruition in the first place.

I totally get it. I'm only talking about me.

I'm sure this community is generally capable of rolling their own LinkedIn.

I chose both routes. I don't particularly like like LinkedIn, but if it helps me network┬╣ then it's a positive tool to have until I no longer need it.

┬╣ yes, I also hate that word, but there you go.

> I think a better strategy is (1) your own domain and/or (2) a site on github with actual code to validate* your talents.

Possibly, but that's for programmers. There are more professions out there.

I just closed my account too. The help page said that my account would no longer be visible on LinkedIn, but after closing and logging out, I still get the "sign up to see the full profile" bait on visiting my old URL (search result from Google).

If recruiters bother you so much, why do offer them bait? Just remove your CV and replace it with a link to your personal site.

I feel a little unloved because recruiters almost never contact me on LinkedIn. I guess my skills aren't cool enough, or else it's because I do more hiring than job seeking..?

I would have thought with Java, C#, objective C, php, node, etc that I'd be a good catch but apparently not!

Guidelines | FAQ | Support | API | Security | Lists | Bookmarklet | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact