Hacker News new | comments | show | ask | jobs | submit login

Promises are not an alternative to callbacks - they are a wrapper around them that make working with them much nicer (though still a little painful as you imply). They add composability which I think has wider implications than many realize at first.

Consider that with things like jQuery deferreds I can start a request in one function and pass it around adding handlers in others...something very hard to do with the old CB model. Maybe later on you have some optional action that you only want to occur if a previous action had completed. This sort of thing is easy with deferreds. It makes bundling together disparate actions easier as well as handling series of things as you mention.

Having an abstraction layer in there also has a lot of potential that is (somewhat) untapped. There is a lot of possibility for library authors to add excellent error handling or debugging capabilities in there - things that are currently a bit painful with POC (plain 'ol callbacks).

I agree generators have strong possibilities in this area- I would note thought that they are not an alternative to promises - the two are orthogonal, and in fact they work quite well together. Just take a look at what some other Mozilla folks are doing with http://taskjs.org/ for example.

Guidelines | FAQ | Support | API | Security | Lists | Bookmarklet | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact