Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I also have been coding for over 40 years now, and I am going to take your example and expand it a bit: wiggling a baton and hearing nice music come out is fun in its own way, all the years of training allowed you to develop the "ear" so you know what sounds good, and to a certain extent to recognize errors the player you are directing is doing, and isn't it nice to be able to just wave your hands and music comes out without having to work on scales, or embochure, or finger dexterity and so on.

The downside is that of course the further you stay away from actually playing your instrument, the rustier you will get; this might or might not be an issue, but it is a significant downside, also being away from the technique side means that as the years go by, you might not be able anymore to have an intuitive understanding of "this sounds wrong" and why it does.

I don't want to stretch the metaphor too far, but it does feel that agentic coding is a bit like building skill tech debt, the more you do it, the more you'll have to work later to bring back the skills you lost. The meta could be that models will get so good so that only a small percentage of developers will ever need to sully their eyes again with looking at code (same as while when we started most people had at least a passing familiarity with assembly, nowadays nearly nobody does), jury's out on that.

Either way, what before needed a full orchestra of developers, now could be doable by a good conductor and maybe a couple of soloists: how many orchestras will be needed? and what will the section musicians not good enough to be soloists and that don't have an interest in becoming a conductor will do? and how are new conductors going to develop their technical chops if there are no more orchestral jobs?



> how many orchestras will be needed?

Many more. There isn't a fixed amount of software needed in the world: the amount will expand to fit the capacity. There's a reason it's been consistently difficult to find good programmers: there's more work than the existing population can handle. By expanding to use AI, I expect that the amount of programming work will grow, not shrink. However, the amount of programmers may decline.


Yes, and I will also add that there is so much software out there completely unaffected by LLMs. Those apps tend to be the vast majority of internal corporate/financial/government/etc. IT services.

If I were to guess, those devs are at least half of the readers of HN, if not the commenters as well. That's why there's so much push back and arguing against LLMs.

Software like that is almost entirely maintenance work. The requirements trickle in slowly and the changes are small but precise. They require deep knowledge of the broader topic, not just programming.

The deadlines are generous now, but what happens longer term? In the future nobody knows how to code without LLMs, most of the topical knowledge is long gone, and the deadlines are always urgent.


I think there actually is a fixed amount of software needed in the world. FAANG has had de facto unlimited programming manpower for years and years and they've mostly squandered it on enshittifying once-decent software. Honestly, I can't think of anything in my life right now that demands more software. If anything, I'd like the software I already use to be drastically polished and simplified.

But hey, maybe the slopocalypse will incentivize us to disconnect and engage with the physical world a bit more.


> I'd like the software I already use to be drastically polished and simplified

That's the unlimited software demand we have to code.


That is pretty much the opposite of what AI is competent at. (And there’s no profit in that anyway.)


Most software is purchased or built by businesses for their internal needs. Are you a business?


The greenfield projects where LLMs make sense will ramp back up when the economics make sense again. It's only been a few years since the "soft landing" BS in 2022-2023.

All of the drama and discomfort since then is 100% caused by that residual economic impact. LLM hype and more aggressive enshittification are just the symptoms, not the root cause. It's not "the new normal", or rather it's totally normal but not the default case for the majority of fiscal years. These dips happen almost every decade.

When that ramp up happens (it kind of already is), the media will do a 180 like the first half of the 2020s never even happened. You will be slightly annoyed, but not complaining because hey we all have more money again.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: