Hacker News new | comments | show | ask | jobs | submit login

Sometimes this is true. It depends on the developers.

Sometimes the developers don't have product skills but know they don't have product skills. This is also fine.

Sometimes the developers think they have product skills when they don't, and this is always a complete disaster.

I can't tell what situation the company described in the article is in. Perhaps the product manager is incompetent (there's lots of incompetent product managers out there), and the developers are correcting for this. Perhaps the developers have good product sense that the product manager is underutilizing.

But if the developers don't have the product skills they need, skills you get by spending lots and lots of time talking with customers instead of (or in addition to) writing code, no amount of process tweaking is going to fix the real problem - individuals assuming that their technical skill translates into product skills, and insisting on also doing something they're not good at.

I've often wondered why the subset of developers who lack product skills and/or the relevant domain knowledge frequently insist on getting involved with product anyway. After all, the head of human resources rarely insists on committing code.

Guidelines | FAQ | Support | API | Security | Lists | Bookmarklet | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact