Hacker News new | comments | show | ask | jobs | submit login

I guess the EFF would offer help if they're asked for it?

Other than that, i don't think Facebook has much legal ground if the facts presented in the blog post are everything to the story...

IANAL, of course

I went to the EFF for help on a similar case once (I am the author of the old Chrome "Facebook Adblock" extension).

I went to the EFF for advice mostly, did I need to comply with the takedown? Should I be concerned that I couldn't meet all of the ridiculous demands (they wanted personally identifying information about everyone who had downloaded the extension!). EFF's response? In summary "We're not sure on this oneā€¦ But can we blog about it? This may or may not cause you more problems."

I didn't hear from them again after I asked them to keep it quiet for the time being.

They don't care about the legal standing. They know that they can use the lawsuit threat as a weapon to force others into compliance. It's due to the cost of funding a lawsuit which is how corporations get their way whether they have strong legal case or not.

Yes there are cases of the "small man" being able to fight back and win. I doubt its par for the course and it's one of the severe drawbacks of our legal system in the US

Guidelines | FAQ | Support | API | Security | Lists | Bookmarklet | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact