Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Actual link rather than to Slashdot discussion:


The problem for me is that isn't addressed by this is the decision to make it default on in Ubuntu. That failure of judgement* means that I can't trust them not to change something else that I have to notice and find out how to easily disable. Easy to turn off is not good enough for such a feature.

Edit to add: Basically I think RMS is right about this one (as he often is) although in many cases I make compromises that he would find wholly unacceptable.

* It might be ethics but I would give Canonical the benefit of the doubt on that one.

I think I've written this before, but: this feature would go nowhere if it was disabled by default. If you want to know whether mainstream users will or will not like it, you can't stick it in some obscure alpha (they'll never test it), and you can't make it optional (only a few percent will ever come across the tick box at all).

So yeah, I don't like this feature either (for all the reasons RMS pointed out), but I don't see how otherwise they could have tested it. Maybe not a failure of judgement then, but rather choosing innovation over privacy?

(Note the 12.10 betas also had all these queries going over the network in plain text... so I kind of see the whole experiment as taking the "move fast and break things" mantra taken to the extreme)

Opt in doesn't necessarily mean hidden in settings. For this feature it probably should be a pop up that appears the first time each user enters a search request before it gets sent over the network.

The question could have a positive spin "Would you like to see network enhanced search results?" with details and privacy policy links. Options of "Yes", "Ask later" and "Disable enhanced search". They could even put an "Are you sure?" If disable is selected.

This seems bizarre in retrospect, but somehow none of the above had occurred to me before. Thanks for taking the time to type it and enlighten.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact