|I've seen really good programmers using both.|
I've had a really good run with IntelliJ IDEA after horrific experiences with Eclipse.
I've used gEdit and SublimeText as well in the past while struggling with VIm and emacs.
I can understand that using a text editor brings you closer to your tools while an IDE can make you 'lazy'.
But I also feel that IDEs (at least IntelliJ IDEA) makes you way more productive and allows you to refactor with ease.
I currently use IDEA in a team that's full of VIm aficionados. No they aren't forcing me to 'convert' ;-) but I am a little curious.
I guess text editor + plugins could give you a pretty good mini IDE.
What do you use?