Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

As another response to your comment already covers, in the last few years, a fair bit of debate emerged questioning if the asteroid was just a contributing coup de grace after a prolonged period of vast, exinction-level climatic destruction.

This because the impactor arrived right around the same time in which the Deccan Traps (gigantic lava producing volcanic zones, like slow moving, continent-destroying lava flows basically) were apparently already in full swing, creating their own climatic havoc around the world.

Even now, enough evidence exists in favor of the Traps being at least a major cause of devastation at the time that it's hard to be sure.

Basically, it could be that the Traps were doing their thing and would have caused some high amount of species extinction all by themselves, but perhaps not as much extinction as did happen, or it could be that they could have caused a mass extinction by themselves but that the asteroid -even if the Traps had not been active- would have anyhow caused the mass extinction that happened at the time. Thus, though it's definitely known that the asteroid hit and caused global cataclysm, it's debated if this by itself would have been enough in the absence of the Deccan Traps.

Obviously, because the traps were already destroying ecosystems and species doesn't mean that the asteroid couldn't have caused mass extinction all by itself, and the speed at which species died off according to fossil strata does indicate the much more sudden asteroid effects as the main culprit, but the coincidence of both together does muddy the waters a bit, so to speak.




Also, there has been some speculation that the asteroid actually caused the Deccan Traps to get much worse, since their location on the Indian subcontinent was at the time very close to being the antipode of the Chicxulub impact area, but i'm not sure if this has been dropped as a real theory now. If it were the case, then the asteroid would definitely be the main culprit, just in a more complex and dynamic way.




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2025 batch! Applications are open till Aug 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: