Hacker Newsnew | comments | show | ask | jobs | submit login

Don't be so fucking american. Swearwords are not not to be used. They serve its function, and here it is part of a well crafted site which is trying to make a point.

edit: Though I agree with harrywincup that the wtf-approach at first seems like nasa did nothing good.




This site doesn't make a point via swearing. In fact all it does is further dilute the word which is useful when needed. The site's format has been done before and basically is an improved take on a Did You Know? concept. The facts, the ratings make it interesting. The fucks make it childish. Children misuse words and curse just to hear themselves curse. Adults communicate the right thing for the right reasons at the right time.

If everything is fucked then nothing is fucked. If everything is WTF then nothing is WTF.

-----


NASA is American... So, who is the target audience then? Is the author intending to persuade western Europeans to fund NASA?

Swearing may be 'fun' but it still isn't what should be front facing for a business.

-----


You're right about the funding thing, but this page is interesting to Non-Americans as well.

-----


Business?

-----


A) Why did you think he is American? You can find cusswords distasteful and be from another country.

B) Why do you think he doesn't like the F-word? It's possible to respect a word for its emotional power while thinking it gratuitous or counter-productive in some cases.

-----


> A) Why did you think he is American? You can find cusswords distasteful and be from another country.

A squeamishness around swear words ('cussword' is not a word I've ever heard a non-american use) is I'm afriad one of the perceived traits of America by other english-speaking nations, so from a purely Bayesian point of view it's an assumption he could make with some confidence. Just like we (Englishman here) don't understand why one arab would get unspeakably offended by another arab hitting him with a shoe unless someone told us that it was the highest insult, culturally (it is not apparent that this is the most insulting thing you can do in and of itself, it's a conditioned, learned response). There is a quote, attributed to lots of people, but seemingly either George Bernard Shaw or Oscar Wilde, that Britain and America are 'two nations divided by a common language'. There is real incomprehension and bafflement in the UK, for example, that a swear word or nipple on US tv seems to cause comparable levels of outrage to a shooting spree.

So, I wouldn't jump down the GP's throat too much, even if his assertion was put forward rather abrasively.

-----


  > or example, that a swear word or nipple on US tv
  > seems to cause comparable levels of outrage to a
  > shooting spree.
Welcome to America, where people will flock in droves to show their support of anti-gay marriage attitudes[1], while none of those people will lift a finger to volunteer at a soup kitchen to help out people that actually need the support.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chick-fil-A#Controversy_regardi...

-----


The purpose of the swearword "fuck" is to signal that you are passionate and emotionally unrestrained about something, with a slight underlying threat of violence. Can someone explain why that is appropriate on this well crafted site?

-----


No it isn't. That may be how you interpret it but it's an incredibly versatile word with semantics that are notoriously hard to pin down.

In this case "what the fuck" is a well-established idiom. Many people don't even notice the vulgarity.

-----


Sure it is. It's "incredible versatile" if you want to express how angry you are about something, because you can basically use it as either a drop in replacement or an intensifier for any word you want, but the common meaning is to express your emotional state. Look at the examples on wiktionary, for example.

As for "what the fuck" being a well established idiom - I guess that depends on your demographic, but I don't see it showing up much in the respectable media, or in academic papers.

-----


Anger is not the only use case for the word "fuck", nor is expressing an emotional state. Really, there's a fuckload of other fucking examples; enough to make one tired as fuck just fucking thinking about them, so I won't enumerate them here (those readers who give a fuck can now exclaim "thank fuck!").

"Respectable" media are beholden to their advertisers, who in turn are concerned that specific demographics might be scandalised by certain words and affect their bottom line. I don't think HN or much of the internet fits into this category.

Academic papers are an interesting case. I suspect their avoidance of the word fuck is a combination of their inherited sense of propriety and the fact that such an ambiguous word as "fuck" rarely has a place in scientific writing.

-----


OK, don't fucking list all the fucking examples, fucking give one fucking single fucking example where fucking is used to fucking express something other than fucking anger, you fucking fuck.

(Other than belaboring the point, an example of which I have just given)

-----


this is a remix of http://whatthefuckhasobamadonesofar.com/

probably something else before that

-----


If my post made me seem stuck up, that is a shame. Go 'Merica!

-----


Perhaps we should try the same with ESA.

The first question that emanates would be on the order of "What's ESA?" No one in the world knows what it does.

Cheap shot making with pejorative intentions doesn't move forward the debate that we ,as a race,ought to do more in advancing our collective knowledge. Petty bickering doesn't help.

-----




Guidelines | FAQ | Support | API | Security | Lists | Bookmarklet | DMCA | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: