Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> there's no ads

This is a patently ignorant and ridiculous statement. They absolutely shove their own store garbage every release and upsell Nitro at every opportunity. Here's an article from last year about them explicitly introducing third party ads.

https://techbriefly.com/2024/04/01/discord-introduces-ads-to...






I would define ads as promoting other businesses' products, as you would see on YouTube etc.

Upselling is basically just unlocking additional features. If you object to that, then you're objecting to the freemium model, not to "ads".


> I would define ads as promoting other businesses' products, as you would see on YouTube etc.

They do that, they call them "quests". Companies pay them to promote their product/service and users get rewards for doing a task (like playing a game, watching a video, etc.) https://discord.com/ads/quests

The article that parent linked even says it.


Are they personalized? Is Discord in the business of selling user data to feed personalized ads to them?

Wow,

* please drink verification can


A freemium service advertizing it's premium offering hardly seems surprizing or objectional. They're not a charity

"It has no ads" and "it's not surprising that it has ads" are basically opposites.

Is this apropos anything? I was pushing back on the claim that there were no ads, though your username suggests the reason.

Why are you belligerent?

Well, concernedc1tizen, I don't like it when people spout of misinformation. Especially when it comes to deep societal issues like pervasive advertising. Making thoughtless and inaccurate blanket statements hurts the overall discussion.

"Belligerence" as you call it is direct, unambiguous, and will probably be remembered.


That's fair.

But I've never seen these ads myself, so it's surprising.

The Americans do take pervasive advertising to the next level though, with product placement, "influencers", and other deceptive tactics. Their behaviors are a major cost to the legal system, because more legislation has to be introduced to govern against their obviously anti-social and exploitative behavior.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: