Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> Musk wants to deorbit the space station

More than Musk; SpaceX was awarded the deorbit contract last year, under Biden.

https://www.nasa.gov/news-release/nasa-selects-international...

> I hope the astronauts get back safely

They'll be fine. SpaceX has a perfect record for manned flight so far.

Both scenarios are a bit like Harry Truman claiming to have done most of the work winning WWII.



Deorbit of the ISS was scheduled for 2030 with experiments and research continuing until deorbit. Mant research programs are depending on this continuation of service to complete recent proposals.

If you didn't think musk had a conflict of interest, this is exactly what it is. Surely you can see this for what it is.

Who wouldn't want their hundreds of millions of dollars contract paid out 3 years earlier than planned?

https://www.nasa.gov/news-release/nasa-selects-international...

https://www.the-independent.com/space/elon-musk-space-iss-de...


Musk is... not known for on-time estimates.

If he says 2027, he'll be ready right around 2030.


I don't think the expected final timeline is really the point. I think the point is cash flow, and to defund and disrupt competition. The benefit to musk is cash 3 years early and locking out competition -- win win.

Regardless, if the deorbit is scheduled 3 years earlier than expected then the US needs to pay pay pay to catch up to the schedule, right? Musk gets the money to start "Phase I" now instead of a year or two from now. It really seems like musk is conning the US and corruptly using his position for cash flow benefits.


> More than Musk; SpaceX was awarded the deorbit contract last year, under Biden.

The contract to deorbit after the end of its operational life in 2030.

Musk wants to deorbit the ISS as soon as possible instead, after getting in a twitter argument with astronaut Andreas Mogensen.


>after getting in a twitter argument with astronaut Andreas Mogensen.

And that's describing it very charitably towards Musk. https://xcancel.com/elonmusk/status/1892584783064052114 shows his response to being called out on a lie as calling a former commander of the ISS "fully retarded".


Which, given Musk's timelines to date, means he'll be ready to do it right around the already-expected 2030 date if he claims he can do it by 2027.


> Musk wants to deorbit the ISS as soon as possible

Musk has no say in the ISS. No need to worry about it.


> Musk has no say in the ISS.

This is a really absurd assertion to make in February 2025. His close buddy is the upcoming NASA administrator, and he clearly has the President's ear.


Musk is a Presidential adviser without a bounded specific portfolio, he has say in anything that (1) the executive branch has a say in, and (b) Trump chooses to listen to him on; as NASA is one of the participating agencies in ISS, the US executive branch has some role in it, and Musk could potentially exert influence over that.


Trump makes the decisions, not Musk. Trump has lots of advisors. Trump has not put Musk in charge of NASA or the space program.


If you said "doesn't have the final say", sure.

The man most certainly has a say.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: