Hacker Newsnew | comments | ask | jobs | submitlogin
stcredzero 631 days ago | link | parent

> Growth of modern day IDE's have rendered many programmers into kind of code assembly workers, autocomplete/intellisense does most of thinking these days.

Please tell me that there is irony involved in this quote. Otherwise the term "thinking" has been diluted to the point of existential crisis. What IDEs do is remembering and accounting. That's cognitive activity, but it's not something that involves sentience or thoughtfulness.

What separates the best programmers from the herd is thinking, and it's not embodied in an IDE.



kamaal 631 days ago | link

>>What IDEs do is remembering and accounting.

Nearly all creative work is delta improvements on remembering and accounting previous sources of knowledge.

>>What separates the best programmers from the herd is thinking, and it's not embodied in an IDE.

What makes you think there are hundreds and thousands of best programmers?

-----

stcredzero 631 days ago | link

> Nearly all creative work is delta improvements on remembering and accounting previous sources of knowledge.

[Citation Needed]

> What makes you think there are hundreds and thousands of best programmers?

There must be hundreds of thousands very good to pretty good programmers out there. To some extent what they do involves real thinking, though not necessarily all of it. Only the dimmest programmers are replaceable by a monkey with an IDE.

IDEs are to programmers as circular saws are to carpenters. The tools an automate a lot of work, but what distinguishes good from bad and the very best from the merely good is genuine skill and knowledge. Idiots will be quite capable of hurting themselves and incurring great expense to their employers.

-----




Lists | RSS | Bookmarklet | Guidelines | FAQ | DMCA | News News | Feature Requests | Bugs | Y Combinator | Apply | Library

Search: