Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Probably just a "it's hard for little pay-off" issue.

To use a bluetooth keyboard from the stage of "Press F10 to Enter Setup" we need the firmware (whether BT host, mainboard, or something else) to have a full bluetooth stack, some way to manage pairing/unpairing devices, and a bunch of other stuff.

If we do this outside the BT host, we probably need changes to the operating systems at least to handle how we're going to hand-off the state of the bluetooth stack when the OS takes control. Unless we want to _separately_ manage pairing/unpairing in the firmware, we would probably want some way to expose that to the operating system to be able to push its paired devices down.

And then it's probably still not super useful unless we substantially lengthen the prompt time because the time for you to turn the keyboard on, coax it into connecting, and hit the button is gonna probably have the OS booted already.

If you want this today just don't use bluetooth. Get one of the devices that uses "2.4GHz" or uses "Bluetooth + 2.4GHz" and shove a dongle in there. The keyboard/mouse will appear as a normal USB-connected device and you can use them how you want.






> If we do this outside the BT host, we probably need changes to the operating systems at least to handle how we're going to hand-off the state of the bluetooth stack when the OS takes control.

During the CSR hid2hci era, the adapter would just remember the last N pairings, since a sufficiently smart adapter can technically just store the keys used by the host when it tries to pair, then "impersonate" the host during the HCI part.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: